Re: Saddoboxing Official Pound For Pound Results
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Violent Demise
Dawson and Williams are way to high. And it's a disgrace Rafael Marquez is not in there some where
I disagree on Dawson, for the simple reason that I think if all things were equal, he'd beat most outside the top 2 & Marquez & maybe Mosley imo. I personally have Williams a fair bit lower as I do also with the likes of Martinez & Hopkins, but its a public vote and to be fair this was the first one we've had where we haven't had anyone looking to influence the result with the placement *cough - the person who had Mayweather below Vic Darchinyan last time out - cough*. Rafa came in at 18th overall, I personally wouldn't disagree with that, I think if he's what he was, then he's definitely top 10, maybe top 5 for me, but I don't feel I got enough in the Vazquez fight to tell me that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by 0james0
There are many people I think should be lower, but clearly I am wrong as this was a public vote. Doesn't help that many people (including me) probably only managed a top 10 rather than 20.
I do think that a Klitchsco deserves to be in there, as much as I can't stand the guys, their acomplishments are head and shoulders more than most the guys in out top 10.
I agree with all of that. In terms of the brothers, Wlad came in at 11th and missed out to Caballero by just 2 points. Just looking at the results I didn't think Caballero would get in, but he got enough lower end points to just edge ahead. Vitali came in extremely low, I'm not sure where exactly, but he'd be lower that Yuri Gamboa, Chris John and Pongsaklek Wonjongkam to name just a few.
