P4P is a favourite list today holding no historical significance or basis in fact.
Printable View
P4P is a favourite list today holding no historical significance or basis in fact.
The Ring has destroyed what was left of it's credibility with it's lastest rankings.
Adrien Broner has excellent potential, but he's not yet proven himself to be top 10 P4P, let alone top 5.
Floyds ranked 1 and has fought about 4 times in 6 years. This shit term is hilarious.
Bradley...what has he done?Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMick
Gotta be someone else other than bradley.
@Second2None regardless of how it happened or wether you like the decision he does officially have a win over Pac. So he has to be there. However the win itself and the way it happened does not merit him a top sport for me which is why I put him that low.Quote:
Originally Posted by Second2NoneBradley...what has he done?Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMick
Gotta be someone else other than bradley.
I'd like to see what your list looks like.
Broner in the top 5? lol top 10? nope . Maybe in the top 20. Other then Broner being there, it is a good list. I think ring magazine is forgetting the Broner vs Ponce De leon fight
No way. Froch has beaten Pascal, Taylor, Johnson, Dirrell, Abraham and Bute.Quote:
Originally Posted by DavilaJones
Vitali, as dominating as he has been, has beaten a load of puddings.
I still have the same top 5
Pac
JMM
PBF
Donaire
Sergio
not in order ;) I just don't see how these guys can not be in the top 5 considering their whole career and capabilities.
http://i4.mirror.co.uk/incoming/arti...-528118249.jpgQuote:
Originally Posted by Otley
Didn't they have Mayweather and Pac "co" p4p number ones? Who was nine and ten last ranking who were dropped?
It was Mares and Vitali I thinkQuote:
Originally Posted by Spicoli
Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMick@Second2None regardless of how it happened or wether you like the decision he does officially have a win over Pac. So he has to be there. However the win itself and the way it happened does not merit him a top sport for me which is why I put him that low.Quote:
Originally Posted by Second2NoneBradley...what has he done?Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMick
Gotta be someone else other than bradley.
I'd like to see what your list looks like.
Agree, but to an extent. My list its pretty much identical to yours only problem its that I would probably have rigondeaux instead of bradley.
No fan of Mares here but lemme get this right...you can win a tournament and two titles within a year, remain undefeated and come off a clear win over one of the better boxers in the game and get dropped for a kid with arguably one meaningful win on his record ??? Wasn't Moreno on a p4p list himself?Quote:
Originally Posted by gest12645It was Mares and Vitali I thinkQuote:
Originally Posted by Spicoli
This is obviously not what have you accomplished but what you might and how loud can you get Jim lungs Lampley to bellow and yell about you. What an absolute charade. Ring...you fail :plthumbsdown:
I was ok with you saying Bradley possibly didn't belong in there that is until you said you'd have Rigondeaux then you just lost me... :-\Quote:
Originally Posted by Second2NoneQuote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMick@Second2None regardless of how it happened or wether you like the decision he does officially have a win over Pac. So he has to be there. However the win itself and the way it happened does not merit him a top sport for me which is why I put him that low.Quote:
Originally Posted by Second2NoneBradley...what has he done?Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMick
Gotta be someone else other than bradley.
I'd like to see what your list looks like.
Agree, but to an extent. My list its pretty much identical to yours only problem its that I would probably have rigondeaux instead of bradley.
Before Rigon there's still guys like Guerrero, Devon and even Viloria whos a 2 division title holder has a better case at P4P then Rigon... But that's just my opinion.
Both Mares & Moreno were P4P when they fought...Quote:
Originally Posted by SpicoliNo fan of Mares here but lemme get this right...you can win a tournament and two titles within a year, remain undefeated and come off a clear win over one of the better boxers in the game and get dropped for a kid with arguably one meaningful win on his record ??? Wasn't Moreno on a p4p list himself?Quote:
Originally Posted by gest12645It was Mares and Vitali I thinkQuote:
Originally Posted by Spicoli
This is obviously not what have you accomplished but what you might and how loud can you get Jim lungs Lampley to bellow and yell about you. What an absolute charade. Ring...you fail :plthumbsdown:
It's fucken nuts what they have done here.