The Top 3 Spots in P4P are done. Now let's close out the rest of the list...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tito_BHB

Yo ..so i'll add mine...
Very sorry if its laughable :P lol...Tis new years eve and on the drink as always.. So here goes

1. Floyd Mayweather..You hate , I hate.. But he's still on top still picking up titles Still Making big cash..
Dont think there can be doubt...

2.Manny pacqioua..( Yehh You know its spelt wrong.)
I for certain tipped a 12 round classic for the Grand Finale ..Wish it was so.. But pac is the man at the lower weight's for now.. Excellent fighter always wants the big fights..

3.Ronald 'Winky' Wright.
What can you say..Still on top.. The uncrowned middleweight champ..
Much like Jlc in the way that they both have rights to the list because they are both such great ..
Well rounded fighters..Just winky has been Much much busyier then jose this year....

4.Marco Antonio Barrera..
Still able to hold up at the top level and always up for fighting the true competition..
Definately some big fights this new year..Perhaps his last..But undoubtably one of the diamonds of boxing.

5. Jermain Taylor.
Shock to some?
Not the most entertaining or most loved.. But the big fights and real challenges keep coming and jermain wants em to keep coming.. No fear in the young champ..
Bhop twice, Winky wright, Kassim the dream... Thats a badass list for his last four fights and to remain undefeated..

6. Vlad Klit....
Although im sure the pound for pound list means.. They would be as effective and as great a fighter at any other wieght..Regarding a statement that the fighter IS that good..
Vlad might not be moving up wieght after wieght...
But everyone must admit he is the man at heavyweight..And they must beat him to become the Big name of the division..I am not sure who if anybody can..But certainly a great year for vlad.

7.Jose louis Castillo.
What can you say... He is a must have of the P4P list..
He is just really that talented... Certainly inactive..But im sure there is more to come and he cannot be denied from a true pound for pound list.

8. Miguel Cotto.
Still of the undefeated elite.. Now a two wieght world champ..Another true fighter who is not afraid of the competition...Of which type of fighter is needed in the world of boxing more and more nowadays..
He doesn't pick the fights but his promoters are well trusted to pick big fights for him and i Pick him over the rest to fill the void left by floyd ;)

9. Ricky Hatton...
My personal feeling on hatton's P4P rating is much the same as winky as jose..
His skill cannot be denied... Bad performance has its circumstance but the most humble fighter promises big things and very big fights for this year..So back at 140 ..The weight where lets not forget he is the man.. and he's the one to take out..He's the man who beat the man..And so makes the list

10. And finally...James Toney..
He has the fights down..First sam peter.. Many including i thought he won the first fight..
The rematch is here..Talk is that james' shape will amaze..And if so..Then thats great ...
If not..No matter..James is still there baltantly becuase he was born with and still owns incredible skill..
He's let himself go.. Smokes eats drinks.. But always on the top level..Becuase of his belssings..
If he straitens out..There is no stopping him.. But P4P is about skill and toney has it..

Thanks all.
Peace.

---

This is the very best list I ever saw even tony get destroyed by every single guy ever.

4.Cotto 5.W.Klitschko 6.Wright 7.N.Valuev 8.J.Arce 9.J.Taylor 10.M.Jarvis ;)

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr
2. Ronald 'Winky' Wright
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Marco Antonio Barrera
5. Rafael Marquez
6. Jermain Taylor
7. Joe Calzaghe
8. Juan Manuel Marquez
9. Miguel Cotto
10. Jose Luis Castillo

:coolclick:  wacko

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Wlad and Chris John should be considered.

Juan Manuel Marquez is not worthy on such a list and he lost clearly to Chris John

---

Hillarious. You clearly did not see the fight...nor do you take in the fact that John aint done a single thing else to warrant him being on the list...hence the reason nobody voted for the man.

---

Why so angry at me? You asked for suggestions and you got those....!!!!

Chris John smashed Marquez no matter what you said - and how the hell could you rate Marquez higher than John? Oh, I forgot....it is just because he is an American....just like Lacy beat Tsypko....

If you ask for suggestions - then do not be a child when you get those....!!!!

---

Juan Manuel Marquez is Mexican.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Wlad and Chris John should be considered.

Juan Manuel Marquez is not worthy on such a list and he lost clearly to Chris John

---

Hillarious. You clearly did not see the fight...nor do you take in the fact that John aint done a single thing else to warrant him being on the list...hence the reason nobody voted for the man.

---

Why so angry at me? You asked for suggestions and you got those....!!!!

Chris John smashed Marquez no matter what you said - and how the hell could you rate Marquez higher than John? Oh, I forgot....it is just because he is an American....just like Lacy beat Tsypko....

If you ask for suggestions - then do not be a child when you get those....!!!!

---

Juan Manuel Marquez is Mexican.

---

Well uh, he is North American

Thanks for putting in the extra work my fellow forum goers.

Keep those lists coming...I'm working this all out & polishing up my presentation & backgrounds on the candidates...a few more lists & then we make it solid.

Once again...cheers to all that participated. :coolclick: s are being handed to you as you read this.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by global

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Wlad and Chris John should be considered.

Juan Manuel Marquez is not worthy on such a list and he lost clearly to Chris John

---

Hillarious. You clearly did not see the fight...nor do you take in the fact that John aint done a single thing else to warrant him being on the list...hence the reason nobody voted for the man.

---

Why so angry at me? You asked for suggestions and you got those....!!!!

Chris John smashed Marquez no matter what you said - and how the hell could you rate Marquez higher than John? Oh, I forgot....it is just because he is an American....just like Lacy beat Tsypko....

If you ask for suggestions - then do not be a child when you get those....!!!!

---

Juan Manuel Marquez is Mexican.

---

Well uh, he is North American

---

what i got from his post was he was talking about countries

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by global

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Wlad and Chris John should be considered.

Juan Manuel Marquez is not worthy on such a list and he lost clearly to Chris John

---

Hillarious. You clearly did not see the fight...nor do you take in the fact that John aint done a single thing else to warrant him being on the list...hence the reason nobody voted for the man.

---

Why so angry at me? You asked for suggestions and you got those....!!!!

Chris John smashed Marquez no matter what you said - and how the hell could you rate Marquez higher than John? Oh, I forgot....it is just because he is an American....just like Lacy beat Tsypko....

If you ask for suggestions - then do not be a child when you get those....!!!!

---

Juan Manuel Marquez is Mexican.

---

Well uh, he is North American

---

what i got from his post was he was talking about countries

---

Who knows...doesn't matter either way...because if he saw the fight...he'd know that Chris John did not smash Marquez...that was a robbery...he should watch the fight instead of believing what he reads.

Plain & simple everyone knows that Marquez is highly rated & that he lost a controversial decision to the hometown hero.

John's can box...but he has never fought anyone worth mentioning outside of Marquez & Gainer & he's fought on his home turf of Indonesia in every fight but maybe 2 or 3 fights.

Marquez got hood-winked. Sorry...but that's the way it is.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by global

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Wlad and Chris John should be considered.

Juan Manuel Marquez is not worthy on such a list and he lost clearly to Chris John

---

Hillarious. You clearly did not see the fight...nor do you take in the fact that John aint done a single thing else to warrant him being on the list...hence the reason nobody voted for the man.

---

Why so angry at me? You asked for suggestions and you got those....!!!!

Chris John smashed Marquez no matter what you said - and how the hell could you rate Marquez higher than John? Oh, I forgot....it is just because he is an American....just like Lacy beat Tsypko....

If you ask for suggestions - then do not be a child when you get those....!!!!

---

Juan Manuel Marquez is Mexican.

---

Well uh, he is North American

---

what i got from his post was he was talking about countries

---

Yeah I was just joking. There is alot of broad statements about people from one country thinking one way or boxers from one country being better than boxers from another country on this site lately, its getting kind of rediculous

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by global

Yeah I was just joking. There is alot of broad statements about people from one country thinking one way or boxers from one country being better than boxers from another country on this site lately, its getting kind of rediculous

---

Agreed. I get overly aggrevated with that nationality bullshit in boxing.

Maybe it's just me...but I don't care where the hell a man comes from, nor the color of his skin, nor his religious beliefs...if he can fight & he's a fair sport...he's got my vote & respect.

i agree with both of you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by global

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

Wlad and Chris John should be considered.

Juan Manuel Marquez is not worthy on such a list and he lost clearly to Chris John

---

Hillarious. You clearly did not see the fight...nor do you take in the fact that John aint done a single thing else to warrant him being on the list...hence the reason nobody voted for the man.

---

Why so angry at me? You asked for suggestions and you got those....!!!!

Chris John smashed Marquez no matter what you said - and how the hell could you rate Marquez higher than John? Oh, I forgot....it is just because he is an American....just like Lacy beat Tsypko....

If you ask for suggestions - then do not be a child when you get those....!!!!

---

Juan Manuel Marquez is Mexican.

---

Well uh, he is North American

---

what i got from his post was he was talking about countries

---

Who knows...doesn't matter either way...because if he saw the fight...he'd know that Chris John did not smash Marquez...that was a robbery...he should watch the fight instead of believing what he reads.

Plain & simple everyone knows that Marquez is highly rated & that he lost a controversial decision to the hometown hero.

John's can box...but he has never fought anyone worth mentioning outside of Marquez & Gainer & he's fought on his home turf of Indonesia in every fight but maybe 2 or 3 fights.

Marquez got hood-winked. Sorry...but that's the way it is.

---

i've downloaded the fight about 3 weeks ago and still haven't watched it. i guess i have to start watching it soon.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IRON

i've downloaded the fight about 3 weeks ago and still haven't watched it. i guess i have to start watching it soon.

---

You definently need to watch it. See if you think that Marquez deserved to lose the points & then see if you believe he lost that fight...I assure you...you won't.

It's a good fight...just a shitty end result.

Again...John can box...but he didn't beat Marquez.

Ok my top 10 as follows.

1. Mayweather, stands apart from the rest imo, unbeaten, champion at 4 different weights, nobody comes close
2. Pacquiao. 2006 was the year of the Pac, in dethroning Morales he's become the people's champion. He'll probably take the official crown from Barrera in 2007/
3. Winky, Proved he could hold his own with a much bigger and younger undisputed middleweight champ. Arguably the best middleweight out there.
4. B Hop, he's coming back it seems. There's few better in the world than him, even at 42
5. Barrera, One of the best old men in boxing, a warhorse who has fought everybody and beaten nearly all of them. How much longer can he go on though?
6. Calzaghe, His choice of opponents havn't impressed me lately but I'm still convinced he'd beat Hopkins, school Taylor and be too slick for Kessler
7. Taylor, he's not impressed in his past 4 bouts but I didn't see him losing any although he scraped a draw against Winky. Needs a dominant performance in 2007.
8. R Marquez. To be honest not seen a lot of him, but people rate him so I'll place him here.
9. Castillo, He's faced everybody and is as solid as they come, looking forward to seeing him at this new weight in 2007
10. Hatton, it's close between him and Cotto. I think Cotto would beat him but right now Hatton has achieved more, but only just. Needs a big win in 2007 to get his bandwagon going on.

Just missed out, Cotto, the biggest new talent around. Look for him to become a star in 2007.
J M Marquez, his new crowd pleasing style will hopefully get him a deserved shot at Barrera or a remacth with Pacman.
James Toney, my favourite fighter. Conditioning sucks but at 39 yrs old this former middleweight has proven he can hang with the biggest of the big men.

1 pac

2 mayweather

3 winky

4 barrera

5 b hop

6 taylor

7 marquez

8 cotto

9 hatton

10 calzaghe

i suck at doing lists so dont rip into me lol peace

- so Marquez is in your middle of p4p doing nothing in 2006 other than clearly loose to the only quality fighter he fought in 06, Chris John - Oh, so I guess that your former p4p no1 Lacy should also be in your top 3 - he nearly defeated Calzaghe and clearly won against Tsypko. :lickish:

Happy New Year :)

Here is my list..Even though the tope 3 are taken I am going to add who I picked.....

1. Winky Wright--Hehas not lost since 99'..Since then his opp has an impressive 388-42 win loss record...He has a title reign in there...Draw with Taylor (a youger bigger fighter who had momentum on his side) Has the best defense in the game...one of the top 10 best defensive fighters in history...Truth is no one beats Wright but Wright!!!...If he didn't take the 12th rd off he would be MW Champion right now

2. Manny Pacquiao-He has beaten Morales twice ( though Morales is not the Morales of old..Raheem showed us that)...KO's Barerra a while back and pretty much dominates most of his opp....This guy is not the best boxer in the game but his wins over the last few years show you don't have to be. He fights the best he can and wins...Thats what P4P fighters do

3.Floyd Mayweather- I put him here only because he is unbeaten...Impressive when he wins yes but IMO a lot of thought goes into his opp...and he avoids the most dangerous fighters out there. I think he can beat the guys he avoids but still the fact he chooses the easist of the available puts a bad taste in my mouth

4.Bernard Hopkins-Still not sure if he is staying or going but?...The guy is an all time great...10+ years as MW champ beat the best they could offer up. Yes he lost 2 in a row to Taylor but was not dominated. Both were close fights. Problem is Taylor has just a little more in the tank pace wise. But then he comes back to Dominate Tarver two divisions higher!!!....Hopkins was on top too long for him to be disrespected and put any lower than 4th just because he has the Losses to Taylor. The Tarver fight showed he is still to be considered one of the best

5.Pongsaklek WonJongkam--We tend to forget about the little guys who we don't see often but anyone who knows anything about him knows he deserves a spot here. He is a hell of a fighter who hasn't lost in over 50 fights!!! Not all his opp is top tier but in the lower divisions records can fool you...Pong has went the other route..instead of one or two big fights to sit on and admire he just gets rid of everyone!!!!...Forget that garbage about Margarito being avoided....NO ONE!!!! under 122lbs wants a piece of this guy..Including my favorite Arce

6.Miguel Cotto-His jaw is in question that much is for sure but not only is he undefeated and Strong as an OX!!! but he is improving!!! plus he beat anyone put in front of him so far...Some good some bad but he has passed the test. He has worked hard and it has paid off. He is one of the few fighting champions in the sport. Miguel has a big future and he deserves a spot here

7.Jermain Taylor-Beat Hopkins twice and drew with Wright. but IMO he lacks that superstar potential...It seems as though he goes out to do just enough to win and nothing more!!!..If it were not for the two wins over Hopkins he would not even be on my list

8.Ivan Calderon-He is the best micro mini fighter in the world and his flawless record proves it!!!...He is no KO puncher but a damn good boxer!!!....if he was bigger he would be on everyones list...lack of exposure keeps him off of it

9.Marco Antonio Barrera- I fear the legend is at an end of his career. A few more fights is all that he has left but other than his loss to Pacquiao in 2003 and Morales in 2000 Marco has been the man under 135...until he is truly beaten by a low caliber fighter he will remain in the top 10

10-Jorge Arce-It is iffy weather or not he belongs in the top 10 P4P but I think he deserves it...last 8 wins by stoppage and a 25 in a row win streak,,,He is criticized about not fighting Darchinyan or Marquez but the same could be said about them...IMO why should Arce be the one to move up or down in weight?...He is the man to beat not them...though some would say different but I say who is the draw???....If Joe C can get away with fighting Manfredo and remain in most top 10 then a guy like Arce who gives us all out war everytime deserves the honor even more

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

- so Marquez is in your middle of p4p doing nothing in 2006 other than clearly loose to the only quality fighter he fought in 06, Chris John - Oh, so I guess that your former p4p no1 Lacy should also be in your top 3 - he nearly defeated Calzaghe and clearly won against Tsypko. :lickish:

Happy New Year :)

---

you talking to me bro if you are like i said im shite at making list i tried mate just not very good at making p4p lists :P

4. Jermain Taylor
5. Marco Barrera
6. Miguel Cotto
7. Castillo
8. Hatton
9. Marquez
10. JC

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

- so Marquez is in your middle of p4p doing nothing in 2006 other than clearly loose to the only quality fighter he fought in 06, Chris John - Oh, so I guess that your former p4p no1 Lacy should also be in your top 3 - he nearly defeated Calzaghe and clearly won against Tsypko. :lickish:

Happy New Year :)

---

You apparently don't know how to score fights...or maybe you haven't even seen the fight...or maybe you just go by what you read...or maybe your'e just royally off in the head...either way nobody takes anything you say seriously...especially me...but you do make me laugh.

Lacy was never my former P4P #1 & you are a moron.

Again...you must not be able to read...either that...or you have some royal eye issues.

I've specifially pointed out to you that Lacy is now ruined by Calzaghe...but keep on running your mouth & proving your own ignorance...because you are proving to be just that...rather ignorant.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

- so Marquez is in your middle of p4p doing nothing in 2006 other than clearly loose to the only quality fighter he fought in 06, Chris John - Oh, so I guess that your former p4p no1 Lacy should also be in your top 3 - he nearly defeated Calzaghe and clearly won against Tsypko. :lickish:

Happy New Year :)

---

You apparently don't know how to score fights...or maybe you haven't even seen the fight...or maybe you just go by what you read...or maybe your'e just royally off in the head...either way nobody takes anything you say seriously...especially me...but you do make me laugh.

Lacy was never my former P4P #1 & you are a moron.

Again...you must not be able to read...either that...or you have some royal eye issues.

I've specifially pointed out to you that Lacy is now ruined by Calzaghe...but keep on running your mouth & proving your own ignorance...because you are proving to be just that...rather ignorant.

---

Royally?? Royally??....HMMM I am starting to sense something ::**

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DaxxKahn

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Gun Tommy

- so Marquez is in your middle of p4p doing nothing in 2006 other than clearly loose to the only quality fighter he fought in 06, Chris John - Oh, so I guess that your former p4p no1 Lacy should also be in your top 3 - he nearly defeated Calzaghe and clearly won against Tsypko. :lickish:

Happy New Year :)

---

You apparently don't know how to score fights...or maybe you haven't even seen the fight...or maybe you just go by what you read...or maybe your'e just royally off in the head...either way nobody takes anything you say seriously...especially me...but you do make me laugh.

Lacy was never my former P4P #1 & you are a moron.

Again...you must not be able to read...either that...or you have some royal eye issues.

I've specifially pointed out to you that Lacy is now ruined by Calzaghe...but keep on running your mouth & proving your own ignorance...because you are proving to be just that...rather ignorant.

---

Royally?? Royally??....HMMM I am starting to sense something ::**

---

Lol :P Subtle.. ;D

Theres always reason to wonder though..
Especially when it comes to people talking silly things about the super middleweight division in general :P ;)
Peace

Manny Pac- Completely destroys the best competition faced.

Winky Wright- Proving himself for over a decade, and has only gotten better.

Floyd Mayweather- outclases his opponents, but weak opposition as of late.

Marco Barrera- Resume speaks for it self.

Erick Morales- Resume speaks for it self.

Juan Manuel Marquez- The complete package, skills, heart, and determination.

Rafael Marquez- silently becoming a must see fighter.

Miguel Cotto- The future at 147.

Arce- Very exciting little guy to watch.

Vlad Klitchko- Clearly the most dominant heavy right now.

Ok I don't know if I'm late. Probably. Not been in touch with the P4P things lately but lets give it a go.

4. Marco Antonio Barrera
5. Rafael Marquez
6. Joe Calzaghe
7. Jermain Taylor
8. Juan Manuel Marquez
9. Ricky Hatton
10. Miguel Cotto
10.

1. Pacman
2. Winky
3. PBF
4. MAB
5. Calzaghe
6. Castillo
7. Cotto
8. Hatton
9. Arce
10. Klitchko