IF Hatton beats Pacqauio does that mean he will be P4P #1?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Mark TKO

Think I would put him about #4/5 if he beats Pac

But if he wins he has to go above Pac - so does that mean Pac drops to number 6 ?? No way will Pac drop that for.

It's a tough one - and where does PBF go when he announces his return (has that happened yet ? thought it was supposed to be yesterday he announced it but not seen owt on news)

Tomorrow morning I will give it some more thought ;)

---

Does he? did Maxim suddenly become the GOAT p4per cos he beat SRR?

Pac is currently a 4 division champ who started out at 106 lbs. That means Ricky should be a champ at welter, junior middle and middle to best PAC's accomplishments. If Ricky beats Paul Williams at 154 and 160 lbs yes he is P4P number1.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TitoFan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CutMeMick

If Hatton beats Pac he becomes #2.

1. JMM
2. Hatton :o
3.Pac


If Pac beats Hatton then Pac becomes #1.

1. Pac
2. JMM


Of course this is just MY opinion. I currently have JMM as #1

---

Hatton jumping to # 2 p4p for beating an undersized Pacquaio? Say it ain't so, Mick.

:(

---

Ok, this post left me totally confused. :cwm3:
Hatton was beaten by an "undersized" Mayweather, and should be given full credit if he beats Pacquiao (ok... he was beaten by the undersized Mayweather, so he should be given full credit for beating the undersized Pacquaio? WTF?), Trinidad was given credit for beating the undersized Mayorga,(Mayorga AND Trinidad both were out of their best weights when they fought at 160... example denied) same will go for Berto if he beats Urango, and basically same crap happened when Khan beat Barrera, but yea i rank Hatton #5 if he beats Pacquiao,(ok... at least you're not putting him at # 1, which is of course what I'm arguing against. I'm my personal opinion, I'd leave his exactly where he is now... 7 is it?) push Manny down to #3, JMM to #1, and B-Hop to #2

---

Uhhhh... see my comments above.

Re: IF Hatton beats Pacqauio does that mean he will be P4P #1?

Well... look at this way. At least THIS question has been put to bed. NOW the question becomes: If he DOESN'T retire, how far down the p4p list does he drop? My personal opinion, out of the top 20 for sure.