The Official Saddo's Pound 4 Pound List & bickering thread...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Taylor has taken Toney's spot @ #9.

Now we have to figure out what to do with Tarver...should we remove Chris John from the list & bring in Tarver?

The other players on the list are, IWO, pretty much on point...but maybe not the alignment...let's try this again people...

Thoughts?

---

Why remove Chris?
I say we wait till we see the result of the Hopkins fight before we put Tarver on here.
As I'm sure he loses to Rocky Balboa thus not enabling him for the P4P list. 8)


My P4P list:

1. PBF
2. WINKY
3. MAB
4. PAC
5. JOE
6. HATTON
7. R. MARQUEZ
8. J.L. CASTILLO
9. TAYLOR
10. C. JOHN

*Taylor comes in for Toney @ #9.

1. PBF
2. Winky
3. Pac
4. MAB
5. Hatton
6. R. Marquez
7. Castillo
8. Calzaghe
9. Tarver
10. Taylor

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CutMeMicK

I say we wait till we see the result of the Hopkins fight before we put Tarver on here.

---

Like it or not...Tarver has done more than enough to be on a P4P list dropping both Jones & Johnson & the others before his rise to fame.

MY P4P Rankings

1. Floyd Pretty Boy Mayweather
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Winky Wright
4. Ricky Hatton
5. Ivan "Iron Boy" Calderon
6. Pacman
7. Jose Luis Castillo
8. Marco Antonio Barrera
9. Antonio Tarver
10. Miguel Cotto

PBF
Wright
Pac
Hatton
Calzaghe
Castillo
Barrera
Marquez
Taylor
John

Tarver could squeek in at ten, but inactivity drops him down.
Barrera would be 4, but the same thing for him drops him a few places.
Taylor is not a solid position, but with a win against Wright, he goes top five. Calderon gets honorable mention, and if Arce-Darchinyan happens, the winner would knock someone out. Of course if Corrales beats Castillo, Castillo drops out and Corrales may enter.

1.Winky
2.MAB
3.PBF
4.Manny Pacquiao
5.Ricky Hatton
6.Joe Calzaghe
7.Rafael Marquez
8.Chris John
9. Antonio Tarver
10. Jermain Taylor

Cannot believe some of you don't have Calzaghe in your top 3 :o
He has THE best recored in boxing bar none currently.
Easily in my top 3 p4p.
His record is unrivaled....
Simple as that. 8)

Ok I must have been intoxicated when I made those rankings :lickish:

heres my actual P4P rankings

1. Winky
2. Floyd
3. Pacman
4. Calzaghe
5. Barrera
6. Hatton
7. Calderon
8. Castillo
9. Tarver
10. John

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CutMeMicK

OK..........heres the way I see it.


1. PBF
2. WINKY
3. MAB
4. PAC
5. JOE
6. HATTON
7. R. MARQUEZ
8. J.L. CASTILLO
9. TONEY
10. C. JOHN



* I put John at #10 cuz he did defeat JMM who was IMO @ #5 on my list so he has to crack in at #10.
* I don't think Cotto has done enough to crack the P4P list yet but hes getting there.
*IMO anytime you defeat a 'P4Pounder that automatically puts you at least at #10 looking at the other accomplishments/achivements will help you land higher as in the case of Joe.

---

Yea I agree with u CutMeMick that sound pretty fair standings to me.

all sorted ;)

http://www.saddoboxing.com/2703-boxi...p-10-list.html

Wacka re read your no4 and no 6 on your post ;)

Chris John is way overrated in these polls. He is a good fighter, but he isn't P4P material and doesn't deserve to be in the top ten based on his achievements either.

His beaten Derrick Gainer (who was in his stand there and don't do anything mode) and most think he lost to Marquez even though it was competetive.

I scored the fight 116-111 for Marquez. Marquez was repeatedly warned, and eventually got a deduction, for low blows where they were on target to land legally, but John backed up. None of them landed hard...but Marquez lost two points for them.

Have any of you ever seen him?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TheMasterpiece

Chris John is way overrated in these polls. He is a good fighter, but he isn't P4P material and doesn't deserve to be in the top ten based on his achievements either.

His beaten Derrick Gainer (who was in his stand there and don't do anything mode) and most think he lost to Marquez even though it was competetive.

I scored the fight 116-111 for Marquez. Marquez was repeatedly warned, and eventually got a deduction, for low blows where they were on target to land legally, but John backed up. None of them landed hard...but Marquez lost two points for them.

Have any of you ever seen him?

---

I agree. And I thought Wacko was removing him and putting Tarver on in his spot?

@Brit

I didnt know you're a Barrera fan ;)

but put him on #1 ;D :D


After the loss to PAC he beat guys like Ayala, Fana, Peden and Morales

so how do you explain MAB being in #1 ??

wlad should be somewhere on this list.

Hatton should be moved down at least a notch or two after Saturday's performance. I won't say he lost the fight--I'd give it to him by a point or two--but he definitely didn't look like an elite boxer in there, and I think he'd have even more trouble with other fighters who are nowhere to be found on our P4P list (Cotto, Margarito and Judah, for instance), as well as the currently lower-ranked Castillo.