Old Straweight, Junior Flyweight, Flyweight, Super-Flyweight & Bantamweight threads

Omar Salado is moved straight to the pool by a vote of 3 -2

Why he should be removed
-Last fight was at Super Flyweight
-Next fight is set for Super Flyweight
-Has personally stated he's moving up

Why he should stay
-Hasn't yet hit the 1 year of inactivity as a Flyweight

Based on his comments, I say he needs to be removed. The move is pretty much official. At his age, I can't see him dropping back down in weight.

Should Rodel Mayol remain in the pool at 108 after losing another technical decision to Ivan Calderon (currently #1)?

I think he should

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...trawweight.jpg

How far should Manuel Vargas (currently #10) drop after losing a controversial split decision to 4th ranked Donnie Nietes?

Remain 10th
Straight to the pool

I vote he remains ranked at 10th as I thought Vargas won the fight!

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...rFlyweight.jpg

Should Cristian Mijares (currently #4) remain rated? His last fight at 115 was the KO loss to Darchinyan on the 1st of November ’08 & his last 2 fights have been loses at Bantam.

Should he remain rated?
Should he be removed to the pool at 118?
Removed altogether?

I vote he is removed altogether after now suffering 3 losses in a row

I voted to remove him but I think it should be to the pool at 115, there was no option for pool at 112 or 115 but my vote would be for the Jr. Bantam pool

I said yes....His last fight a TD and before a Draw with Calderon.....Cant punish a guy for that

Pool

pool at 118

A fighter shouldn't lose his spot because of a robbery

3 strikes and you're out. A case could be made for his first fight with Cermano which was close, but he's not gonna get any meaningful fights after this. Drop him altogether.

Following the rules, I say leave him where he's at. But Jesus Christ, he should really be sitting on the 4 spot. That shiit was a disgrace

Have to say 3 and done.

With his three consecutive losses and retirement I say remove him altogether.

Mijares Retires from Boxing

Takefumi Sakata has been moved to the pool at 115 by a vote of 5 - 1

Rodel Mayol remains in the pool by a vote of 4 - 2

Manuel Vargas remains #10 by a vote of 5 - 1

Cristian Mijares is removed from our ratings altogether by a vote of 5 - 2

He lost again on Tuesday. I saw the fight. He was outclassed. Nongqayi is a pretty good fighter. But that's still 2 out of 3 fights for Arce. I think he's shot. If it was up to me, i'll drop him completely. But it's not. So I say we drop him 3 spots

I say 3 & I agree Arce is done. I had Nongqayi in my 1st initial ratings... he a pretty good fighter & was too good for this version of Arce!

Have to say 3 as well.Slowed noticeably.Nonggayi a pleasant surprise

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...ntamweight.jpg

Roberto Vasquez (number 9 at 118 & in the pool at 115) hasn’t fought at Bantam since Sep 18th ’08. His most recent fight was a loss to Hugo Cazares at 115 & next fight is also scheduled for the Jr. Bantam limit.

Should he remain ranked at 118 or be removed to the pool. Or just remain in the pool at 115?

I think he should just be in the pool at 115

Should Vusi Malinga remain in the pool at 118? He has been in the pool for 6 months & hasn’t fought in that time. His last fight was a 1st round KO loss to Hasegawa in March ’09 & his last win was over a year ago in June ’08.

I vote he should be removed.

Leave him for now. He's set to fight this month

I meant to vote to keep him in.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by killersheep

I meant to vote to keep him in.

---

No worries

Jorge Arce fall 3 places by a vote of 7 - 0

Roberto Vasquez is moved to the pool at 115 only by a vote of 5 - 0

Should Roberto Vasquez remain in the pool at 115 after now losing his last 2 fights in a row?
Roberto Vasquez

How should we rate Drian Francisco after he stopped Roberto Vasquez (currently in the pool at 115) in 10 rounds in a Jr. Bantamweight fight?
Drian Francisco

Should he earn the vacant #10 position?

Enter the pool at 115?

Not enter our ratings at all?

Should Jose Navarro remain in the pool at 115 after being stopped in 8 rounds by Michael Domingo in a Bantamweight fight?
Jose Navarro

How should we rate Michael Domingo after he stopped Jose Navarro (currently in the pool at 115) in 8 rounds in a bantamweight fight?
Michael Domingo

Should he earn the vacant #10 position?

Enter the pool at 118?

Not enter our ratings at all?

I always considered Vasquez a good fighter. Francisco destroyed him. He earns the 10th spot

Navarro has always been just an average fighter

He's lost 3 in a row?Shouldnt he be out just like Vasquez ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spicoli

He's lost 3 in a row?Shouldnt he be out just like Vasquez ?

---

Vasquez has only lost 2 in a row, being in the pool they still need to be voted out. Navarro has been inactive as well having not fought since Feb '08

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

I always considered Vasquez a good fighter. Francisco destroyed him. He earns the 10th spot

---

I too was pretty high on Vasquez but Francisco became the 1st to stop him, 10th should be his!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Navarro has always been just an average fighter

---

Your right but he fought top comp, plus Domingo has scored KO's over Vorapin & now Navarro since Sep '08 at 118. I think pool listing is fair...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Galaxy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Navarro has always been just an average fighter

---

Your right but he fought top comp, plus Domingo has scored KO's over Vorapin & now Navarro since Sep '08 at 118. I think pool listing is fair...

---

Yeah Navarro has faught top comp. But he never beat top comp.

Michael Domingo enters the pool at 118 by a vote of 5 - 1