Re: Pavlik vs Espino Set For December 19, Top Rank PPV
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Myk_Myk
Quote:
Originally Posted by
JazMerkin
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Myk_Myk
I don't see the reason to give the Williams camp any grief over wanting the fight at 160. They're holding all the cards and deserve to call the shots. Martinez is happy to get this opportunity and is not in a place with this fight to make demands. I know the apparent hypocrisy of the Williams camp is irritating, but this is boxing...
To be fair to Williams though, he's been training and eating with the goal of fighting at 160. It wouldn't be healthy for him, or to his advantage to turn around and try to come back down in a few weeks. The ball is in his court and it would be just stupid for him to bust his balls to come down to 154. Give him a break!
Read what I wrote. My problem is with them saying that they have to feed him big meals multiple times a day just to not go under the weight. If that was really the case they could easily have made 154. I have no problem with the fight being at 160 as long as it means they stop calling him a welterweight & acting like he's out of his weightclass he isn't. The way they act it wouldn't be busting his balls to make the weight because he's not a NATURAL middleweight. The evidence would seem to suggest he is. I just want them to cut the shit, I know he's a popular fighter, I like him a lot, but that doesn't mean he gets a pass on talking shit.
I hear ya. I was responding to this part: "I've been critical of Williams of late, for dragging Martinez up to 160..." I agree there is a lot of BSing, but as I said it goes with the territory. I
maintain that it would not have made any sense not make Martinez come up. You've got to try for every advantage and let egos take a back seat. Look what happened when ODLH wanted to make sure nobody would think he was picking on a smaller (Pac) man and didn't even rehydrate after weigh-in, and no I'm not saying he would have won, but still...
Rantcatrat, Martinez is 5' 11", started at WW, and moved up to LM. Clottey is 5' 8", started at LW, and moved up to WW. It would have been unrealistic to ask Clottley to come up to 160. Obviously it wasn't for Martinez, as he took the fight!
Martinez is a career 154 guy. He has fought at 154 since the early 2000's. Fighting at 160 is definitely an advantage for Paul - that we can both agree on. We can also both give Martinez big time props for taking this fight at 160 because he's a 154 guy. Also, the fact that Martinez started at welterweight and is now fighting Paul at middleweight is even more testiment to the fact that the fight being at 160 is a big advantage for Paul.
I'm not sure you understood the point I was making about Clottey. Williams offered to fight Clottey at 154 (not 160) after the Pavlik fight fell through. Clottey didn't accept the fight at 154. Clearly, Williams could have been able to make 154 if he offered to fight Clottey at 154 during the same time period. Yet, Williams wouldn't fight Martinez at 154? You pointed out the reason in your post - because it is to Paul's advantage to fight Martinez at 160 rather than 154.
Re: Pavlik vs Espino Set For December 19, Top Rank PPV
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Rantcatrat
I'm not sure you understood the point I was making about Clottey. Williams offered to fight Clottey at 154 (not 160) after the Pavlik fight fell through. Clottey didn't accept the fight at 154. Clearly, Williams could have been able to make 154 if he offered to fight Clottey at 154 during the same time period. Yet, Williams wouldn't fight Martinez at 154? You pointed out the reason in your post - because it is to Paul's advantage to fight Martinez at 160 rather than 154.
No I understood perfectly. My point is it would have been pointless to offer Clottey a fight at 160; which is evidenced by the fact that he didn't even take the fight at 154. I'm sure Williams could have come down to 154 to fight either man. And I'm sure the Williams camp felt more comfortable about coming down to 154 for Clottey (who would have had to come up even then) than for the rangier framed Martinez; who has been at 154, as you said, since 200. The fact that Martinez did agree to come up to 160, proves that the Williams camp knows how play their cards, and my whole point is that he shouldn't be disparaged for doing so, excepting all the BS from his camp we've already discussed.
As for Pavlik it certainly does look bad, but then again on the surface of it, he had to fight to keep his belts. That article Diane posted makes it sound like they're still waiting for his hand to heal and even his camp looks to be unsure about his state. We'll just have to see what happens after this fight. If he and Williams both win, there should be no more excuses.
Re: Pavlik vs Espino Set For December 19, Top Rank PPV
If Pavlik wasn't gonna be 100% for a Dec 5th fight with Williams then I'm happy it got scrapped. Win, lose or draw I want no excuses. I'm assuming when he steps in the ring on Dec 19 he'll be at about 70% to 80% which is more than enough to beat Espino but not Williams. He needs to get healthy first. I have no doubts if they win their next match they'll be sharing a ring come March/April.
On a side note, as a Pavlik fan I didn't like the idea of him having just one fight after the Hopkins debacle then jumping back into another super fight. Especially with that one fight coming way back in February. He needed 2-3 fights to get his confidence back IMO.
Re: Pavlik vs Espino Set For December 19, Top Rank PPV
Damn BHop took Pavliks heart and mind because at 1 point he was taking on all comers from Taylor twice and Miranda, when he was considered dangerous and stepped up to fight the Executioner. Now he is taking on pretenders in what could be considered an even worst title reign then Taylor's. I hope he gets himself together before its too late because he is still young and talented.
