Old Straweight, Junior Flyweight, Flyweight, Super-Flyweight & Bantamweight threads

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...ntamweight.jpg

How far should Joseph Agbeko (currently #4) drop? 0-3 spots?
Joseph Agbeko

Remain rated 4th
1 spot to 5th
2 spots to 6th
3 spots to 7th

I meant to click remains at fourth, accidently hit drops a spot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by killersheep

I meant to click remains at fourth, accidently hit drops a spot.

---

All good, I agree as Mabuza was stopped I feel Agbeko should remain ahead

Mabuzza was stopped. But he was winning going into the 12th round. I would place him ahead of Agbeko

I would drop him only from one position a lost that includes some debatable events (the headbutt for instance) but nothing more, if he makes a good fight against a significant opponent, he will have the right to climb up again otherwise he might face a significant drop for next time.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Mabuzza was stopped. But he was winning going into the 12th round. I would place him ahead of Agbeko

---

True Mabuza was ahead, but so was Taylor with Froch. Still got stopped. Agbeko fought a hell of a fight & saw the final bell

Remain at four.

The question for me is more 'How far should Nonito Donaire drop?'.

It still irks me beyond measure that he is considered 6th (FUCKING 6TH!!) in the current ring rankings for beating one single name opponent.

He's not even top 30 p4p and he barely struggled past that unknown Rafael Concepcion last time out, a fighter with a 13-3-1 record. :-X

I know I always harp on about this but he's only ever fought a single opponent who had ever been world champion, Darchinyan aside he has never fought a world class opponent.

Darchinyan has already been shown up as the limited, crude bully he always was, and his conqueror Agbeko has also since tasted defeat.

I guess for the Ring to be consistent Yohhny Perez, for beating the man who beat the man that Donaire beat must jump into the top 10 p4p also.

It's fucking absurd I tell you :p

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bilbo

The question for me is more 'How far should Nonito Donaire drop?'.

It still irks me beyond measure that he is considered 6th (FUCKING 6TH!!) in the current ring rankings for beating one single name opponent.

He's not even top 30 p4p and he barely struggled past that unknown Rafael Concepcion last time out, a fighter with a 13-3-1 record. :-X

I know I always harp on about this but he's only ever fought a single opponent who had ever been world champion, Darchinyan aside he has never fought a world class opponent.

Darchinyan has already been shown up as the limited, crude bully he always was, and his conqueror Agbeko has also since tasted defeat.

I guess for the Ring to be consistent Yohhny Perez, for beating the man who beat the man that Donaire beat must jump into the top 10 p4p also.

It's fucking absurd I tell you :p

---

[/rant]

What are you doing?

Joseph Agbeko remains 4th by a vote of 6 - 1

Should Z. Gorres remain in the pool at Bantam? Although he did win his fight; what is the likelihood of him ever fighting again?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Galaxy

Should Z. Gorres remain in the pool at Bantam? Although he did win his fight; what is the likelihood of him ever fighting again?

---

His career is over. He should be removed. He has bigger things to worry about

hello vd how are ya ?

his ranking on Saddo's is the least of his worries. :(

No need to put it to the vote.

Just hope he recovers...all I care about.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Howlin Mad Missy

his ranking on Saddo's is the least of his worries. :(

No need to put it to the vote.

---

Just trying to keep things official

Z. Gorres is removed from the pool by a vote of 4 - 1

Gorres' boxing career is over.

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18.../Flyweight.jpg

Should Daisuke Naito (currently #1) vs Koki Kameda (currently #5) on November 29 be for our vacant Flyweight championship?
Daisuke Naito
Koki Kameda

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18.../Flyweight.jpg

How far should Julio Cesar Miranda (currently #9) drop?
Julio Cesar Miranda
Should he remain 9th or be dropped to the pool?

Should Alejandro Hernandez enter the pool at 115 after fighting to a draw with current #9 Marvin Sonsona?
Alejandro Hernandez

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...tFlyweight.jpg

How far should Edgar Sosa (currently #3) drop after being stopped by Rodel Mayol? 1-3 spots?
Edgar Sosa
1 spot to 4th
2 spots to 5th
3 spots to 6th

As the stoppage was controversial, if the result is changed our ratings will be adjusted accordingly & Mayol will be returned to the pool

1 spot for the controversy and the still good performance.

Naito/ Kameda will be for our championship by a vote of 6 - 0

Julio Cesar Miranda remains 9th by a vote of 3 - 0

Alejandro Henandez enters the pool by a vote of 3 - 2

Edgar Sosa drops 1 spot by a vote of 6 - 0

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18.../Flyweight.jpg

How far should Daisuke Naito (currently #1) drop after losing a decision to Koki Kameda (entered at 5th, now our new champion)? 1-3 spots?
Daisuke Naito

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...trawweight.jpg

How far should Juan Palacios (currently #7) drop after losing a close decision to current #3 Oleydong Sithsamerchai?
Juan Palacios
Remain 7th
1 spot to 8th
2 spots to 9th
3 spots to 10th
Straight to the pool

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18.../Flyweight.jpg

With Koki Kameda claiming our vacant championship we now have 2 vacancies in this division now. With that in mind:

Should Cesar Seda Jr. vs Juan Esquer on December 4th be for the vacant #8 spot at 112?
Cesar Seda Jr
Juan Esquer

Fight did not occur. Seda Jr. fought Daniel Reyes in a fight above the flyweight limit so this vote becomes void

Juan Palacios remains 7th by a vote of 4 - 0

Daisuke Naito drops 2 spots by a vote of 3 - 2

http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...tFlyweight.jpg

How far should Cesar Canchila (currently #7) drop after being stopped in the 11th by undefeated but unrated Johnriel Casimero?
Cesar Canchila
1 spot to 8th
2 spots to 9th
3 spots to 10th
Straight to the pool

Should Alejandro Valdez remain in the pool at 115 after being stopped in 11 rounds in a Bantamweight fight with current #10 Nehomar Cermeno?
Alejandro Valdez

Should Hernan Marquez (currently in the pool at 115) earn the vacant #9 position at 112 after his recent win at this weight?
Hernan Marquez

Marquez is a good fighter & I'm all in favour of him filling the vacancy. It would be good to fill some of these up properly by the new year.

Hernan Marquez earns the vacant #9 spot by a vote of 5 - 0

Alejandro Hernandez is removed from the pool by a vote of 3 - 2

Cesar Canchila drops 3 spots by a vote of 4 - 1