Re: Who Is Most Underrated Heavyweight Of All Time Come And Vote
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lyle
I'm just saying Ike's PRIME was spent in jail....we all know how a boxer can be the hottest thing one minute and then flat on his back the next.
In boxing you don't judge greatness solely on POTENTIAL, that's all I am saying.
Sam Langford was a GREAT fighter he didn't get a title because of racism......Ike has no one to blame for not getting a title but himself......in my opinion there is a HUGE difference
Yes, but don't forget that three years of Ali's PRIME were also spent out of boxing, so he technically could be underrated as we never really saw the best of him.
Also (nothwithstanding my own opinion) he was banned from boxing for refusung to be inducted into the Army as he was, essentially, part of a radical muslim 'terrorist' group at the time. Today's political climate would probably also actually jail someone who did that today?
I agree that it's dangerous to make our own judgements about people's lives when we should be purely judging them on their technical prowess in the ring?
Re: Who Is Most Underrated Heavyweight Of All Time Come And Vote
Quote:
Originally Posted by X
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lyle
I'm just saying Ike's PRIME was spent in jail....we all know how a boxer can be the hottest thing one minute and then flat on his back the next.
In boxing you don't judge greatness solely on POTENTIAL, that's all I am saying.
Sam Langford was a GREAT fighter he didn't get a title because of racism......Ike has no one to blame for not getting a title but himself......in my opinion there is a HUGE difference
Yes, but don't forget that three years of Ali's PRIME were also spent out of boxing, so he technically could be underrated as we never really saw the best of him.
Also (nothwithstanding my own opinion) he was banned from boxing for refusung to be inducted into the Army as he was, essentially, part of a radical muslim 'terrorist' group at the time. Today's political climate would probably also actually jail someone who did that today?
I agree that it's dangerous to make our own judgements about people's lives when we should be purely judging them on their technical prowess in the ring?
there werent terrorist groups back then they were more or less radical pro black groups. But good point all the same :coolclick:
