114-114 was odd, I mean 10-9 in a round with a knock down in itself is not right, surely that should be a 9-9 and a judge should never been scoring a round 10-10.
edit: is a 10 point score a must?
Printable View
114-114 was odd, I mean 10-9 in a round with a knock down in itself is not right, surely that should be a 9-9 and a judge should never been scoring a round 10-10.
edit: is a 10 point score a must?
Seeing how Mosley performed on the juice and then off the juice. Seeing how Hopkins preformed against Jones, I can't believe he doesn't have something in his system at 45 after watching that fight. He had stamina as if he was 30. What is up with that? Someone going to say he was on a new nutrition plan? Or he had a new conditioning trainer to revive his body?
It's a 10-point must system. That is the master scorecard, not what the judges write on (check the identical handwriting). The judges scores are collected at the end of each round.
As I said in another thread - for all the moaning and groaning Van De Wiele did Hopkins a big favour by scoring round one 10-9.
Is it just me, or does it look like 1 person filled that out, handwriting looks very similar on all cards. Weird.Quote:
Originally Posted by Spicoli
That 3rd card. Is that actually a 9 written over an 8 in the 1st round. Changed his mind I suppose :pQuote:
Originally Posted by killersheep
Not really, if you win a round and get a flash knockdown at the end, it's alright to score a 10-9. Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by Fenster
???Quote:
Originally Posted by No ContestNot really, if you win a round and get a flash knockdown at the end, it's alright to score a 10-9. Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by Fenster
Says who? Based on what??
Well if its not someone better call up Pascal and tell him he actually won.:p Go look up the rules I'm not doing it for you.
NM it would have still been a draw.
I never said it wasn't alright. Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by No ContestNot really, if you win a round and get a flash knockdown at the end, it's alright to score a 10-9. Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by Fenster
I haven't seen one single scorecard that has round one anything other than 10-8 for Pascal. And yet i've read tons about incompetent judges "robbing" Hopkins. If Van De Wiele had scored like all the internet "experts" Hopkins would have LOST on his card. Fact.
Happens alot. KD's fortunately do not mean mandatory 10-8 rounds, especially flash ones resulting in little to no damage in an otherwise even or uneventful round.Quote:
Originally Posted by The Grinch???Quote:
Originally Posted by No ContestNot really, if you win a round and get a flash knockdown at the end, it's alright to score a 10-9. Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by Fenster
Says who? Based on what??
Damn there goes my conspiracy theory. Fact. B-Hop>Calzaghe. Fact. :p.Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by FensterI never said it wasn't alright. Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by No ContestNot really, if you win a round and get a flash knockdown at the end, it's alright to score a 10-9. Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by Fenster
I haven't seen one single scorecard that has round one anything other than 10-8 for Pascal. And yet i've read tons about incompetent judges "robbing" Hopkins. If Van De Wiele had scored like all the internet "experts" Hopkins would have LOST on his card. Fact.
The old veteran educated the young talent. :cool: I think the X-Bad Boy showed Pascal the true strength of hardened experience and shocked him into exhaustion in the later half; B-Hop really looked like he was in his prime again. Great fights in December.
Oh well, you learn something new everyday! ;DQuote:
Originally Posted by SpicoliHappens alot. KD's fortunately do not mean mandatory 10-8 rounds, especially flash ones resulting in little to no damage in an otherwise even or uneventful round.Quote:
Originally Posted by The Grinch???Quote:
Originally Posted by No ContestNot really, if you win a round and get a flash knockdown at the end, it's alright to score a 10-9. Fact.Quote:
Originally Posted by Fenster
Says who? Based on what??
I wonder how that little gem has affected fights with multiple flash knockdowns from both fighters..?
I mean, in those circumstances, I wonder if the judges look at each KD seperately or if after the 1st one or two KD's they then reconsider the validity of each one there after?
Surprised at this result, Hopkins is a top fighter, really thought he was going to be convincingly beat.