-
What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Which one of these most made you want to slap a ref?
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Agaisnt Agustus and/or Raheem.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Robin Reid got deducted a point for 'punching' against Sven Ottke ;)
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
It was Haugen that refused to touch gloves, so Camaco decided to punch him in the head. That's why he was deducted a point.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
that fucking ref in the raheem - juarez fight took points from zahir for resting his hand behind juarez's head during clinches...not pushing his down, just resting his glove behind the head...
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
had to go with this choice also. damn turnaround, the fight would have won by barrera after that he got discouraged and you know the rest of the story..
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
had to go with this choice also. damn turnaround, the fight would have won by barrera after that he got discouraged and you know the rest of the story..
lol, :coolclick: that's exactly how I felt. I thought Barrera was in the fight until that. I didn't think anyone would agree with me.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Hey Big H, it was worse than that wasn't it? Didn't Reid knock Ottke down only to have not only the knockdown not counted, but to have a point deducted for some reason? Maybe my memory is a little jaded, but that was one of the worst officiated fights i have ever watched!
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
had to go with this choice also. damn turnaround, the fight would have won by barrera after that he got discouraged and you know the rest of the story..
lol, :coolclick: that's exactly how I felt. I thought Barrera was in the fight until that. I didn't think anyone would agree with me.
well, i fully agreed with you. CC you back mate.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
had to go with this choice also. damn turnaround, the fight would have won by barrera after that he got discouraged and you know the rest of the story..
lol, :coolclick: that's exactly how I felt. I thought Barrera was in the fight until that. I didn't think anyone would agree with me.
well, i fully agreed with you. CC you back mate.
What pissed me off just as much about that whole situation was that despite that, I felt the fight was incredibly close, but the wide points margin and the way it went against Barrera leaves me feeling he won't have the same confidence in the rematch if it was to happen.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
had to go with this choice also. damn turnaround, the fight would have won by barrera after that he got discouraged and you know the rest of the story..
lol, :coolclick: that's exactly how I felt. I thought Barrera was in the fight until that. I didn't think anyone would agree with me.
well, i fully agreed with you. CC you back mate.
What pissed me off just as much about that whole situation was that despite that, I felt the fight was incredibly close, but the wide points margin and the way it went against Barrera leaves me feeling he won't have the same confidence in the rematch if it was to happen.
yeah its sort of discouraging really, but time and time again barrera's heart is proven mate. and that ugly point deduction shouldn't be a problem to him rekindling his will to win in their future rematch as much as the horrible loss he suffered from pacquiao.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
had to go with this choice also. damn turnaround, the fight would have won by barrera after that he got discouraged and you know the rest of the story..
Wouldn't of made slight difference to winner though because judges had it so wide it didn't matter.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by BIG H
Robin Reid got deducted a point for 'punching' against Sven Ottke ;)
Yes, that referee's performance was the worst, most biased and partisan showing that I have ever seen from a referee in my entire life.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Edison Miranda got screwed so badly in Germany when he faught Abraham. That's another disgrace, that Ref was nearly as bad as...
Quote:
Originally Posted by X
Quote:
Originally Posted by BIG H
Robin Reid got deducted a point for 'punching' against Sven Ottke ;)
Yes, that referee's performance was the worst, most biased and partisan showing that I have ever seen from a referee in my entire life.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
had to go with this choice also. damn turnaround, the fight would have won by barrera after that he got discouraged and you know the rest of the story..
Wouldn't of made slight difference to winner though because judges had it so wide it didn't matter.
I completely disagree, I felt this encouraged Marquez because he knew he'd been dealt a break, thus performed better because of it.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by BIG H
Robin Reid got deducted a point for 'punching' against Sven Ottke ;)
Reid got robbed in this fight. The referee was a fucking disgrace. The IBF should have been ashamed of themselves for appointing him and the thieving judges. As Reid said after the fight "At least Dick Turpin wore a mask when he robbed people"
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted The Bull
Agaisnt Agustus and/or Raheem.
Yeah!
It seems like it was decided that Augustus has lost the fight before it even began.
Didn't Williams have an odd point deduction in his Tyson fight too?
I'll have to check my tapes again. I don't quite remember what happened, but I think he had an odd point deduction in his fight against Tyson. I just remember it seems the ref wanted Tyson to win that fight so badly.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
I would go with firstly..Jay nady deducting a point and no knockdown to barrera agaist marquez..
And secondly..What do you know..Jay Nady again..
Felix Trinidad vs Fernando Vargas when he sent trinidad to the corner and to talk to him for five minutes before finally deducting a point having spoke to him for a fair while.. Like lederman said.. You dont speak to a guy for five minutes and then decide to deduct a point..If its worthy of a point deduction then you send him to the corner and deduct a point immediately
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Out of the options, I'll have to go with Camacho. Deducting a point because someone doesn't want to touch gloves IS RETARDED.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by BIG H
Robin Reid got deducted a point for 'punching' against Sven Ottke ;)
He also got deducted a point after being floored for the first time by lacy from a blatantly ilegal shot
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather
that F****** ref in the raheem - juarez fight took points from zahir for resting his hand behind juarez's head during clinches...not pushing his down, just resting his glove behind the head...
Yes
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted The Bull
Agaisnt Agustus and/or Raheem.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted The Bull
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted The Bull
Agaisnt Agustus and/or Raheem.
For spinning out against Burton? That was a joke. The whole fight was a joke.
Didnt Burton win by a split when the judges actually had it as a majority? Jokers!
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimboogie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted The Bull
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted The Bull
Agaisnt Agustus and/or Raheem.
For spinning out against Burton? That was a joke. The whole fight was a joke.
Didnt Burton win by a split when the judges actually had it as a majority? Jokers!
YES, more of a disgrace. God awful decision. Emanual then crunched Burton in the rematch. Ah, sweet revenge.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Recently,I'd say some of the deuctions for Miranda v Abraham for supposed low blows. From what I remember,they were totally legit bodyshots.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
Quote:
Originally Posted by sleeplessrevolution
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
had to go with this choice also. damn turnaround, the fight would have won by barrera after that he got discouraged and you know the rest of the story..
lol, :coolclick: that's exactly how I felt. I thought Barrera was in the fight until that. I didn't think anyone would agree with me.
Yup . Nady has always been an awful ref but that night he was just plain ridiculous . Unfortunatley we had blind judges that night also so the whole thing was a farce
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
I wanted to slap Jay Nady for deducting Barrera a point against Marquez.
1. He didn't score the knockdown
2. I thought Barrera only hit him while he was on the floor because Nady hesitated and didn't call it fast enough, so Barrera felt he had to go and hit him again.
I felt the same way!!!!!
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Beanflicker
Out of the options, I'll have to go with Camacho. Deducting a point because someone doesn't want to touch gloves IS RETARDED.
Thats not what happened at all. Haugen would not touch Camacho's gloves. While the ref was lecturing Haugen about touching gloves, Camacho reached over an punched Haugen in the face. How is that a bad point deduction?
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
I guess Nady is noit the most popular referee here, eh?
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
[quote=Ted The Bull ]
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimboogie
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted The Bull
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ted The Bull
Agaisnt Agustus and/or Raheem.
For spinning out against Burton? That was a joke. The whole fight was a joke.
Didnt Burton win by a split when the judges actually had it as a majority? Jokers!
[/quote
YES, more of a disgrace. God awful decision. Emanual then crunched Burton in the rematch. Ah, sweet revenge.
This one always sticks out for me, the ref was shocking!!!
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
You all know which one I voted for. Fuk Spinks, Fuk that ref and FUK those judges. Mayorga fukin won that fight EASILY!!!
But for fights not on that list I feel that the worst deductions I have ever seeen came in the Zahir Raheem vs. Rocky Juarez fight. That dikhead ref kept takin points from Raheem for "holding behind the head". That was BS. By about the third deduction I was cursing the TV and hopin that motherfuker would actually DQ Raheem for it just so he would look like a complete fukin idiot and NEVER ref another fight again. I have not seen that sucker since then either.
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hulk
You all know which one I voted for. Fuk Spinks, Fuk that ref and FUK those judges. Mayorga fukin won that fight EASILY!!!
But for fights not on that list I feel that the worst deductions I have ever seeen came in the Zahir Raheem vs. Rocky Juarez fight. That dikhead ref kept takin points from Raheem for "holding behind the head". That was BS. By about the third deduction I was cursing the TV and hopin that motherfuker would actually DQ Raheem for it just so he would look like a complete fukin idiot and NEVER ref another fight again. I have not seen that sucker since then either.
you must didn't read my reply on page one..i thought i was the only that saw that fight...do you remember that they were fighting in texas, rocky's hometown, and the ref and i think one of the judges were also from texas....talk about bullshit..
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
BARRERA V MARQUEZ WHEN BARRERA GOT DEDUCTED POINTS FOR A PERFECT KNOCKDOWN??
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by leftylee
BARRERA V MARQUEZ WHEN BARRERA GOT DEDUCTED POINTS FOR A PERFECT KNOCKDOWN??
The Judges and ref were determined not to let Barrera win that night
-
Re: What Was the Worst Point Deduction Ever?
Quote:
Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hulk
You all know which one I voted for. Fuk Spinks, Fuk that ref and FUK those judges. Mayorga fukin won that fight EASILY!!!
But for fights not on that list I feel that the worst deductions I have ever seeen came in the Zahir Raheem vs. Rocky Juarez fight. That dikhead ref kept takin points from Raheem for "holding behind the head". That was BS. By about the third deduction I was cursing the TV and hopin that motherfuker would actually DQ Raheem for it just so he would look like a complete fukin idiot and NEVER ref another fight again. I have not seen that sucker since then either.
you must didn't read my reply on page one..i thought i was the only that saw that fight...do you remember that they were fighting in texas, rocky's hometown, and the ref and i think one of the judges were also from texas....talk about bullshit..
I read it now. Yeah FUK that ref, he was a complete idiot. Total bullshit.
