-
The Ring's top 10 p4p list
You guys see that JT got dropped to 10th he was at 6th before?
1 FLOYD MAYWEATHER Welterweight/Jr. Middleweight
2 MANNY PACQUIAO Jr. Lightweight
3 RAFAEL MARQUEZ Jr. Featherweight
4 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ Jr. Lightweight
5 WINKY WRIGHT Middleweight
6 BERNARD HOPKINS Lt. Heavyweight
7 JOE CALZAGHE Super Middleweight
8 MARCO ANTONIO BARRERA Jr. Lightweight
9 RICKY HATTON Jr. Welterweight
10 JERMAIN TAYLOR Middleweight
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by killersheep
You guys see that JT got dropped to 10th he was at 6th before?
1 FLOYD MAYWEATHER Welterweight/Jr. Middleweight
2 MANNY PACQUIAO Jr. Lightweight
3 RAFAEL MARQUEZ Jr. Featherweight
4 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ Jr. Lightweight
5 WINKY WRIGHT Middleweight
6 BERNARD HOPKINS Lt. Heavyweight
7 JOE CALZAGHE Super Middleweight
8 MARCO ANTONIO BARRERA Jr. Lightweight
9 RICKY HATTON Jr. Welterweight
10 JERMAIN TAYLOR Middleweight
Wright is hideously low. I'm a big Rafael Marquez fan, but Wright has the 3 spot on lock and he could be number 2. P4P lists are starting to turn me off. P4P number 1 means something but after that...eh...it's too subjective.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by amat
Quote:
Originally Posted by killersheep
You guys see that JT got dropped to 10th he was at 6th before?
1 FLOYD MAYWEATHER Welterweight/Jr. Middleweight
2 MANNY PACQUIAO Jr. Lightweight
3 RAFAEL MARQUEZ Jr. Featherweight
4 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ Jr. Lightweight
5 WINKY WRIGHT Middleweight
6 BERNARD HOPKINS Lt. Heavyweight
7 JOE CALZAGHE Super Middleweight
8 MARCO ANTONIO BARRERA Jr. Lightweight
9 RICKY HATTON Jr. Welterweight
10 JERMAIN TAYLOR Middleweight
Wright is hideously low. I'm a big Rafael Marquez fan, but Wright has the 3 spot on lock and he could be number 2. P4P lists are starting to turn me off. P4P number 1 means something but after that...eh...it's too subjective.
Agreed. I don't even try to formulate a top 10 P4P because its way too subjective and there is soo much to take into consideration. The only thing that I think is 100% concrete is PBF at #1, and still there are even some who (foolishly IMO) try to argue that he isn't.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by amat
Quote:
Originally Posted by killersheep
You guys see that JT got dropped to 10th he was at 6th before?
1 FLOYD MAYWEATHER Welterweight/Jr. Middleweight
2 MANNY PACQUIAO Jr. Lightweight
3 RAFAEL MARQUEZ Jr. Featherweight
4 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ Jr. Lightweight
5 WINKY WRIGHT Middleweight
6 BERNARD HOPKINS Lt. Heavyweight
7 JOE CALZAGHE Super Middleweight
8 MARCO ANTONIO BARRERA Jr. Lightweight
9 RICKY HATTON Jr. Welterweight
10 JERMAIN TAYLOR Middleweight
Wright is hideously low. I'm a big Rafael Marquez fan, but Wright has the 3 spot on lock and he could be number 2. P4P lists are starting to turn me off. P4P number 1 means something but after that...eh...it's too subjective.
Agreed that these lists are subjective, but I do take into account THE RING'S list in particular.
Specifically I was curious to see what happened to Taylor after his last fight.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
I agree pretty much with the top 3, would swop JMM with winky tho have barrera behinde JMM @ 6 calzaghe @ 7 mosley coming in at 8 de la hoya at 9 and klit at 10
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
I'd swap Barrera and Calzaghe
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
I think Wright should be 2nd, with Pac third, and then RM 4th and JMM 5th. I wouldn't put Taylor below Calzaghe. I don't care how bad Taylor looked, he still has more quality wins on his resume than Calzaghe.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Calzaghe is too high he hasn't done a damn thing since Lacy fight he shouldn't be top 10 and Hatton well im not sure about him either but we will see after the Castillo fight.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
CC#893 ICE i was going to say that earlier but went for a nicer approach ;)
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Not sure if you guys know this BUT this is the 1st time in boxing history that 2 brothers are in the Rings top 10 P4P list.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by TYSONBRUNO
CC#893 ICE i was going to say that earlier but went for a nicer approach ;)
Already clicked you early.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
CC#1540 Mick interesting fact ;)
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMicK
Not sure if you guys know this BUT this is the 1st time in boxing history that 2 brothers are in the Rings top 10 P4P list.
No i didn't know that :coolclick: for the info.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by TYSONBRUNO
CC#1540 Mick interesting fact ;)
Thanks. :) Heres #128
Quote:
Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING
Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMicK
Not sure if you guys know this BUT this is the 1st time in boxing history that 2 brothers are in the Rings top 10 P4P list.
No i didn't know that :coolclick: for the info.
Thanks. Heres CC#894
I think it's great I mean to be the 1st brother duo to do this.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
I have big respect for PBF, he's very skilled fighter and all...
But I still gotta go for mah myn, mah boi Manny Pac as no.1 p4p.
Mabuhay Ka Pacman!
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
They are the best boxing brothers in history! :D
Rafa Marqeuez deserves top 3 imo,he's done so much in his career and keeps achieving more and more. Not sure about MAB being there anymore. Why does it feel as if someone is missing?? ???
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Any room for Kessler, Chris John, Mijares, Mosely, Cotto?
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by eagle
Any room for Kessler, Chris John, Mijares, Mosely, Cotto?
Kessler needs another big win, but he's on his way
Chris John has had his share of hometown decisions
Mijares again one more big win
Mosley is not active enough on the championship level
Cotto, we'll talk about that after the Judah fight.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
I no longer take any notcie of P4P lists, in the real world all they do is protect fighters. Fighters can say "How can I not be the champ of this divison if I'm #X P4P?
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by killersheep
Quote:
Originally Posted by eagle
Any room for Kessler, Chris John, Mijares, Mosely, Cotto?
Kessler needs another big win, but he's on his way
Chris John has had his share of hometown decisions
Mijares again one more big win
Mosley is not active enough on the championship level
Cotto, we'll talk about that after the Judah fight.
Fair points. cc for you.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by yoitsdan
I no longer take any notcie of P4P lists, in the real world all they do is protect fighters. Fighters can say "How can I not be the champ of this divison if I'm #X P4P?
CC. I pretty much agree with this statement. Being considered the #1 P4P like Floyd Mayweather is certainly significant, but beyond the top 2 or 3 spots it doesn't carry a whole lot a weight and is far too subjective.
Edit: Well, I'll try and give you a another CC in 24 anyways, seems I already gave you one today...
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
No way Wright is lower than second on any honest ranking. Hell his resume is without question the best in the whole damn thing. He is great, he hasn't lost in like 7 years. he fights the best anytime anywhere. Yet they still hate him. I just subscribed to the Ring. Never!
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by CFH
Quote:
Originally Posted by yoitsdan
I no longer take any notcie of P4P lists, in the real world all they do is protect fighters. Fighters can say "How can I not be the champ of this divison if I'm #X P4P?
CC. I pretty much agree with this statement. Being considered the #1 P4P like Floyd Mayweather is certainly significant, but beyond the top 2 or 3 spots it doesn't carry a whole lot a weight and is far too subjective.
Edit: Well, I'll try and give you a another CC in 24 anyways, seems I already gave you one today...
I have the same problem my man with the CC's. I think p4p (and by that I mean post for post) your my #1 pick at the minute ;)
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by yoitsdan
Quote:
Originally Posted by CFH
Quote:
Originally Posted by yoitsdan
I no longer take any notcie of P4P lists, in the real world all they do is protect fighters. Fighters can say "How can I not be the champ of this divison if I'm #X P4P?
CC. I pretty much agree with this statement. Being considered the #1 P4P like Floyd Mayweather is certainly significant, but beyond the top 2 or 3 spots it doesn't carry a whole lot a weight and is far too subjective.
Edit: Well, I'll try and give you a another CC in 24 anyways, seems I already gave you one today...
I have the same problem my man with the CC's. I think p4p (and by that I mean post for post) your my #1 pick at the minute ;)
that was pretty corny.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by boozeboxer
Quote:
Originally Posted by yoitsdan
Quote:
Originally Posted by CFH
Quote:
Originally Posted by yoitsdan
I no longer take any notcie of P4P lists, in the real world all they do is protect fighters. Fighters can say "How can I not be the champ of this divison if I'm #X P4P?
CC. I pretty much agree with this statement. Being considered the #1 P4P like Floyd Mayweather is certainly significant, but beyond the top 2 or 3 spots it doesn't carry a whole lot a weight and is far too subjective.
Edit: Well, I'll try and give you a another CC in 24 anyways, seems I already gave you one today...
I have the same problem my man with the CC's. I think p4p (and by that I mean post for post) your my #1 pick at the minute ;)
that was pretty corny.
I've just re-read it... I whole heartedly agree :drinker: :puke:
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
CC . MAn. When I read it I laughed very hard out loud. Maybe it is the beer. But it was just so lame it was really funny.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
P4P list are too subjective. there more of a popularity contest if you ask me.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by yoitsdan
Quote:
Originally Posted by CFH
Quote:
Originally Posted by yoitsdan
I no longer take any notcie of P4P lists, in the real world all they do is protect fighters. Fighters can say "How can I not be the champ of this divison if I'm #X P4P?
CC. I pretty much agree with this statement. Being considered the #1 P4P like Floyd Mayweather is certainly significant, but beyond the top 2 or 3 spots it doesn't carry a whole lot a weight and is far too subjective.
Edit: Well, I'll try and give you a another CC in 24 anyways, seems I already gave you one today...
I have the same problem my man with the CC's. I think p4p (and by that I mean post for post) your my #1 pick at the minute ;)
Awwww shucks... but to be fair, I've made more than a few dumbassed posts recently... but on that note, is this not the best boxing forum in existence? Shit, even when I disagree with people on here I can, for the most part, understand their reasoning... I like it here.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING
Calzaghe is too high he hasn't done a damn thing since Lacy fight he shouldn't be top 10 and Hatton well im not sure about him either but we will see after the Castillo fight.
Thing is Hatton's situation is similar to Taylors. So unless you throw Taylor out of the top 10, Hatton should still be in it. He aint looked as bad as Taylor, but Taylor's opposition has been stronger. I agree that the p4p ratings are way to subjective though. It really does depend on what your looking for. I agree with Calzaghe being in.....but only just. He needs a big fight.
-
Re: The Ring's top 10 p4p list
Quote:
Originally Posted by 'The Boxer'
P4P list are too subjective. there more of a popularity contest if you ask me.
Totally disagree,i that was the case,Oscar,Shane and Miguel Cotto would all be in there and NO WAY in hell would B Hop,Floyd or Winky!
