Greatest Heavyweight of All-Time, Final: Muhammed Ali vs. George Foreman

First to 20 votes

Ali again.

Yea i think Ali aswell because Ali had the speed in his prime and Foreman did always struggle with movers Tommy Morrison, Jimmy Younng, ect.

Ali beat him past his own prime. If Ali was in top form, the fight would've been easier to deal with.

I hink a prime Ali wouldn't use the rope-a-dope strategy, he would think he'd need it. Foreman by KO in 4.

ali wins

Ali all the way for me, if a past his peak Ali could beat a peak George, you got to believe the peak version may have done better.. :beerchug:

Ali.....but I still don't think he's the "greatest of all time"....in boxing that title should belong to Joe Louis and in music a tie between Elvis and James Brown

Lets not forget Ali had his peak years taken away from him, as he had no problem with no Viet Cong, and to still be talked about as the poss greatest speakes massive about how good the guy was. :badass:

This is almost unfair because Ali beat George already when Foreman was prime...

Really it's the best BOXER vs the best SLUGGER....IMO Joe Louis was the happy medium between the two and is therefore THE GREATEST OF ALL TIME

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lyle

Ali.....but I still don't think he's the "greatest of all time"....in boxing that title should belong to Joe Louis and in music a tie between Elvis and James Brown

---

I sort of agree but Louis's opposition wern't that great i think it was probably worse than Holmes opposition in his reign im not taking anything away from Louis but you know Lyle Louis reign wern't filled with greats but to be fair to Louis he didn't duck anyone and you can only beat the guys in front of you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Yea i think Ali aswell because Ali had the speed in his prime and Foreman did always struggle with movers Tommy Morrison, Jimmy Younng, ect.

---

I hope to God your joking about Tommy Morrison being a "mover" lol ;D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sugar_Shaw

First to 20 votes

---

#19

Had to say Foreman. Ive always thought he'd crush Ali if they had a rematch

Can we combine the smarts of the 45 year old Foreman with the body of the 25 year old version? If so, I gotta pick ol' George by late stoppage.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WelshDevilRob

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Yea i think Ali aswell because Ali had the speed in his prime and Foreman did always struggle with movers Tommy Morrison, Jimmy Younng, ect.

---

I hope to God your joking about Tommy Morrison being a "mover" lol ;D

---

Sorry my mistake i should of made it cleaer what im saying is Morrison didn't stand in front of Foreman he constantly stayed on outside thats what i mean by mover meaning thats type of style that troubles Foreman and thats what Morrison done in that fight moving all the time it was pretty boring fight aswell.

Ali

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by WelshDevilRob

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Yea i think Ali aswell because Ali had the speed in his prime and Foreman did always struggle with movers Tommy Morrison, Jimmy Younng, ect.

---

I hope to God your joking about Tommy Morrison being a "mover" lol ;D

---

Sorry my mistake i should of made it cleaer what im saying is Morrison didn't stand in front of Foreman he constantly stayed on outside thats what i mean by mover meaning thats type of style that troubles Foreman and thats what Morrison done in that fight moving all the time it was pretty boring fight aswell.

---

After reading quite a few of your posts you seem to have great knowledge of fighter's that's why the 'mover' comment shocked me a little ;)
Your spot on about Morrison during the Foreman fight he boxed great that night.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lyle

Ali.....but I still don't think he's the "greatest of all time"....in boxing that title should belong to Joe Louis and in music a tie between Elvis and James Brown

---

I sort of agree but Louis's opposition wern't that great i think it was probably worse than Holmes opposition in his reign im not taking anything away from Louis but you know Lyle Louis reign wern't filled with greats but to be fair to Louis he didn't duck anyone and you can only beat the guys in front of you.

---

That's also why I rate Marciano highly as well.

Joe Louis did what he did so easily and it sort of makes everyone forget that he did fight some good boxers: Max Baer, Max Schmelling, Joe Walcott, Billy Conn, Jim Braddock, Jimmy Bivins, Jack Sharkey.....that's not too shabby right there.

Joe fought often and he fought consistently and he holds actual records....Ali does not.


As I said before this match between Ali and Foreman pits the best BOXER vs the best SLUGGER....on talent alone I am more amazed by Foreman, not to say Ali didn't do amazing things.

Ali wins and is the greatest heavyweight and Joe Louis is second. Holmes third?

How is Joe Louis not in the final four?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by No Contest

How is Joe Louis not in the final four?

---

Good question....methinks people voted for him to be beat by Larry Holmes.

My list won't change until someone tremendously good comes along
1. Joe Louis
2. Rocky Marciano
3. Muhammed Ali

That is the way it'll always line up for me....no offense to Ali but of course the Ali fans will want my head on a spit because of it.

I really enjoyed this 'competition' ...... and agree that Ali is the Greatest heavyweight if all time.

BUt, I do also think that Joe Louis was the BEST heavyweight of all time.

Ali was better at publicity, came along at the right time, got hooked into social issues, plugged into the huge media expansion at the time, heralded the golden age of heavyweight boxing - and Louis didn't ....... but I still think he was a better fighter (IMO)

lol it's not really up for voting is it? ali whooped big george when ali was on the slide...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by No Contest

How is Joe Louis not in the final four?

---

Because it stops the same old Louis vs Ali in the final and because Holmes would beat Louis imo and alot of people favored that idea aswell.

Joe Louis had weaknesses such as starting slowly, or getting knocked down early, weighing under 200lb, vulnerable to the right hand, could be out boxed by very good fighters, which could have been exploited by other great fighters but he was a great champion nonetheless.

Don't let me get started on Rocky Marciano.

Ali would have beaten both the fact that he beat 3 great fighter in their primes in his era just cements the argument.

Looks like Ali is the 'Greatest' :)

Thanks Sugar Shaw for running this competition CC+ from me.

Great debating and knowledge all round.