Ok i want to start off with the Quartey one, because thats the one im watching right now. And i will give my scorecard in about 20 mins.
Printable View
Ok i want to start off with the Quartey one, because thats the one im watching right now. And i will give my scorecard in about 20 mins.
1 Oscar 10-9
2 Quartey 10-9
3 Oscar 10-9
4 Oscar 10-9
5 Quartey 10-9
6 Quartey 10-9
7 Quartey 10-9
8 Quartey 10-9
9 Quartey 10-9
10 Oscar 10-9
11 Quartey 10-9
12 Oscar 10-8
114-113 Quartey
Get involved people because im bit bored at the moment i would like to hear your thoughts.
1 oscar tito---8 rounds to 4 for dlh
2 oscar-mosly II --8-4 dlh
it's been some time since I watched it. I do remember this as the flat footed plodder period of his career. Dunno what was going on in training to come up with that idea ::**
It's been a long time since I see the fight but if I remember correctly I felt DLH needed to knock him down in the 12th to draw at least.
I couldn't believe he won.
112-116 113-116 115-114Quote:
Originally Posted by The Rookie Fan
The first two scorecards are ridiculous.
Yes they are. I could see the fight going one point eather way though. Scoring is so subjective you have to give it a 1 - 2 point margin of error.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pernell "Sweet Pea" Whitaker
What about De La Hoya vs Whitaker
I'll do that one tomorrow or later last time i watched it, i had it a draw i think.Quote:
Originally Posted by MAYWEATHER P4P#1
I've always felt that DLH clearly lost to Quartey. Usually a close fight has a lot of close rounds, but this was the rare close fight where the rounds were one-sided. Quartey clearly won 7 rounds, and Oscar clearly won 5 rounds.
I had Whitaker beating Oscar 7 rounds to 5, although that fight had a lot of close rounds that were tough to score. I don't think that fight was a robbery, but the fact that the scorecards were so lopsided made the decision look bad.
I thought Oscar-Tito was a draw. Oscar was clearly winning thru 8-9 rounds, but he wasn't winning by as a wide of a margin as he thought. He gave up the last several rounds and that allowed Tito to tie it up. This fight was more of a case of Oscar blowing the fight than Tito winning it.
I know I am going against the grain on this but I actually felt DLH edged that one out. Whitaker just didn't make him pay enough.Quote:
Originally Posted by MAYWEATHER P4P#1
I thought I was the only one that thought the same. Also, the Mayweather fight seems questionable. Can't really say ODLH was completely dominated and totally punished like many hardcore Mayweather fans say and vice versa.Quote:
Originally Posted by LawHoops
Ok im just about to watch Tito vs Oscar i will give my scorecard in a little while.
I saw the Quartey fight as a 115-114 for OLDH, but it just as easily could have gone the other way. The fact is, that fight could have been stopped in the 12th and Quartey was hurt and in trouble much more than Oscar that fight.
However, I feel that Whitaker got a raw shake in his fight, as that knockdown should have gotten him a 1 point win
Tito Vs Oscar was easily Oscar, complete domination for 7 rounds, regardless of what happened at the end h should have won
And the 2nd Mosley fight was an Oscar win, 7-5 in terms of round IMO
However, the fight he most clearly shold have lost was the Sturm fight....should have been a 115-113 UD for Sturm
Tito vs Oscar
1 Oscar
2 Oscar
3 Oscar
4 Tito
5 Oscar
6 Oscar
7 Oscar
8 Oscar
9 Tito
10 Tito
11Tito
12 Tito
115-113 Oscar De La Hoya
The best Tito could of done was a draw im shocked so many people thought Tito won, because the rounds wern't really hard to score.
I have that same score card cept for the first two rounds. I think the seccond was clearly Tito's and the first was even. So I had Tito by 1.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pernell "Sweet Pea" Whitaker
Nothing happend in the first round and Tito landed the more meaningful blows in the seccond. DLH just jabbed.
But like I said, this is just my opinion. It really bothers me though when people call this a robbery. It was pretty damn close and Oscar only has himself to blame for what happend.
This fight is often reffered to as the night Tito got exposed like if he wasn't that good or overrrated. Fact is Oscar did a hell of a job and fought a nearly perfect fight for the better part of 9 rounds. It was the best of Oscar we had ever seen and it's a real shame that he didn't follow through and win the fight. But it also shows alot that Tito cooly weathered the storm and kept the fight close enought to pull out the W in the end. Nobody got exposed that night. It was just two great fighters that fought to a stalemate. And it's a black eye for boxing that the rematch never got made.
I'll re watch the 1st two rounds now.
Re watched the 1st round you could make an argument that the round was a draw but i still thought Oscar did land the better quality punches.
2nd round was close but Oscar edged it with his work in the final 15 seconds.
Well we could go back and forth on this all day long. That's why it was so controversial. Only one thing would've settled this argument and that was a rematch.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pernell "Sweet Pea" Whitaker
Oscar has been in a lot of great fights but most of his big matches,he has won narrowly and could hve gone either way.Quartey,Pernell. The same could be said of his losses,Tito,Shane. I change everytime I see the fight but for whats it worth,I thought he beat Quartey,drew with Pernell and drew/lost to Tito. He blew the Tito fight himself,that was the VERY definition of running and to do it in the biggest fight of your life was shocking and embaressing.
Floyd Mayweather Jr vs Oscar De La Hoya
1 Mayweather
2 Oscar
3 Mayweather
4 Mayweather
5 Mayweather
6 Oscar
7 Oscar
8 Mayweather
9 Mayweather
10 Mayweather
11 Mayweather
12 Oscar
I gave Oscar De La Hoya the benefit of the doubt and gave him the 12th but Mayweather won this fight easily.
116-112 Floyd Mayweather Jr.
I agree, for the life of me I don't know what that judge was thinking. I can see maybe given DLH one more round but that is it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pernell "Sweet Pea" Whitaker
DLH was doing alright though and if he had kept jabbing he might've pulled it off.