Printable View
I'm doing an experiment. Don't worry you are not the subject. I am not Benjamin Linus.
Tell me if you disagree with this list. And if so why
Fat Plodders - Wlad Klitschko
C - Hayemaker
LH - Gimpy Executioner
SM - Joey boyo
M - Moby
LM - Floyd
W - Floyd
LW - Witter dodger
L - Campbell
SF - Pac
F - Linares
SB - Vazquez
B - Hasegawa
SF - Montiel
FL - Narvaez
LF -Calderon
CC's for all replies.:cool:
Sorry mate but at 154 Spinks is the Champion....Even when DLH held a version of the titiles Cory was still the Champ at 154...PBF beating DLH does not make him the 154 champion...And you can argue who is better then who all you want but until Cory is dethroned or PBF beats him he will stay champion....Hell before PBF Forrest would get honors he has a defense under his belt....
Can't come to a division beat the guy who is not considered the best in the division (or active enough to be considered)...then be the Main man....Don't care who you are...
Hopkins beat the man who held the ring title;)...or same would be said for him
Jmm @ Sf ;)
Naito beat the man at Fly, so he's probably the flyweight champ, altho I think Donaire would cream him.
Straw I would give to Condes.
Oh, and Butterbean is the true Heavyweight Champion ;D
Pac @ SF CURRENTLY :pQuote:
Originally Posted by BIG H
Casamayor beat Diego Corrals for the universially recognized light weight title. Casamayor still has not officially lost: so how did Campbell become the champion?Quote:
Originally Posted by Fenster
The list looks pretty good to me though would have Spinks at LM.
Taggin on to Daxx......Welterweight I would have Cotto. PBF beating Hatton at 147 and ODLH at any weight and Gatti and Baldo doesn't get you a belt, unless it is green. There is no argument that Cotto has had much better opposition at 147.
I think by far PBF is the best in both of those weights, but it is comparable to putting Edwin Valero are Erdei as the one champion. Stretched for effect. CC for the topic.
Floyd beat Baldo who beat Zab who unified all the titles.Quote:
Originally Posted by boozeboxer
Cotto is defending at belt that was won by Baldo but taken from him using alphabet logic.
Beating the guy plodding man that Beat Zab....that is nice.
Beating Mosley is better. Sorry, that is how I see it. 2 guys fought recently who were in the top 3 as far as welters go, one of them won (Cotto) . I think he is the best man for carrying the Welter belt.
So, at what point in time did Floyd lose the WW title?Quote:
Originally Posted by boozeboxer
Actually would have Mijares rather than Montiel and porobably Spinks at Light Middle
Wladdy
Haye
Hopkins
Joe
Pavlik
Spinks
PBF
Hatton
Joel
Pac
John
Izzy
Hasegawa
Mijares
Daisuke
Calderon
Condes
Repped Mick, I agree with this whole list.Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMick
Or rather, you agree with my list, as my opinion is more important ;)
Easy there Ginger! ;) At the point when he decided to quit fighting welters at all! As far as I am concerned he has retired from boxing and is involved in exhibition boxing.Quote:
Originally Posted by lance UppercutSo, at what point in time did Floyd lose the WW title?Quote:
Originally Posted by boozeboxer
Sorry booze, but it was lance who said that, not the one and only ginger. ;DQuote:
Originally Posted by boozeboxerEasy there Ginger! ;) At the point when he decided to quit fighting welters at all! As far as I am concerned he has retired from boxing and is involved in exhibition boxing.Quote:
Originally Posted by lance UppercutSo, at what point in time did Floyd lose the WW title?Quote:
Originally Posted by boozeboxer
mijares and spinks should be on the list apart from that i agree. good list
The list isn't my opinion it's part of a cunning plan.
I purposely threw in - what i thought were - some ringers ;)
Spinks, Casamayor and Mijares are the ONLY changes so far... and Mickyshades, Daisuke :-\
Sorry bro I don't with all your list, heres what mine are:Quote:
Originally Posted by Fenster
H - Vacant
C - Haye
LH - Hopkins
SM - Calzaghe
M - Pavlik
JM - Vacant
W - Mayweather
JW - Hatton
L - Casamayor
JL - Pacquiao
F - Vacant
JF - Vasquez
B - Vacant
JB - Vacant
Fly - Vacant
JFly - Calderon
S - Vacant