Printable View
It's quite humorous when this subject comes up and then people mention a decision where one guy who lost the decision won on most of the fans scorecards by a grand total of 7-5 or 6-5-1.
The worst robbery I have ever witnessed, and can't imagine anything being much worse than, was Juan Coggi-Eder Gonzalez I.
Here's an article about this travesty of a prize fight.
Boxing Coverage updated 24/7 at MaxBoxing.com
Whitaker vs Ramirez 1 I believe i had it 118-110.Quote:
Originally Posted by Thread Stealer
Mayorga vs. Spinks.
Hands down the WORST robber I've ever seen. I had Mayorga winning 10/12 rounds, plus he got screwed outta at least 2 knockdowns. And those FUCKERS gave it to Spinks. Total BS!
I just saw the Kid Diamond v Huerta.
The decision almost made me puke.
Can't remember the fight but i remember CutMeMick putting up a video of the ref talking to officials at ringside that has to be one of the biggest robberies.
Holyfield vs Lewis I
What fight was the chick judge (Washington, right?) watching?
Danny Green claims that in his first fight with Beyer that the ref said the headbutt he landed on Markus was accidental and it had to go to the cards. Ten minutes later he was DQ'd when it was revealed he was ahead.
Almost all robberies are clearly NOT.
One that springs to mind is - Jorrin-Brodie. Everyman and his dog had Brodie the winner. But obviously he didn't get it (with memory loss, i'm not certain how much of a "robbery" it really was :-\).
Eagle, the cut to Beyer in the 2nd round came from no headbutt, ( I have watched that round many times and Beyer was cut from a punch) but Green did indeed deliberately headbutt Beyer out of frustration in the 5th round and was rightly DQ'd.Quote:
Originally Posted by eagle
Quote:
Originally Posted by Chino
Agreed. That fight and Toney/Tiberi comes to mind.
Rep on that one.I remember watching this on Sunday afternoon replay on Univision way back when and yelling in loudest tone "WTF" at least 10 times.This was without a doubt and ALL fights Ive seen over the past 20 years being considererd...THE WORST SHOWING BY A REFEREE.....EVER!!Plain and simple bought & payed for favoritism nearing criminality.Literally holding a limp Coggi up and letting corner revive him among other crap!!Forget scoring...A literal robbery !Quote:
Originally Posted by Thread Stealer
rjj not winning the gold metal was by far the biggest robbery of all, it was a no contest rjj beat the fuck out of that chump, but beacuse he was a hometown boy they gave it to him!
Like i said Green claims the ref said the headbutt was accidental then changed his mind. I wasnt there but if htat happened it is a robbery.Quote:
Originally Posted by THE THIRD MANEagle, the cut to Beyer in the 2nd round came from no headbutt, ( I have watched that round many times and Beyer was cut from a punch) but Green did indeed deliberately headbutt Beyer out of frustration in the 5th round and was rightly DQ'd.Quote:
Originally Posted by eagle
On the robbery note the first fight i ever watched was Fenech v Nelson 1, now that was a robbery. Poor Jeff was never the same afterwards.
Yep Fenech V Nelson I is a bad one alright.
I gave Nelson 3 rounds.Quote:
Originally Posted by bikersk
Likewise for Holyfield against Lewis the first time around.
Chavez-Whitaker was bad, but not as bad a draw as those two. I had that one 8-4 for Pea.
i know what ur saying, this could be, turly. the best topic ever! but what makes boxing the greatest sport ever is the fact EVERYTHING is subjective!Quote:
Originally Posted by Thread Stealer
i'll gie you an example... so, marco is my all time fav fighter, the #1 love every single thing about the guy, his skill his attitude, the dirty tacs...
so i have seen the marco morales 3 a million times, and i mean a stupid a mount of times, every time in my eyes marco, wins, yet i still see on this forums, peole erik nicked it or it was a draw, so i watch it again, i still see no way erik wins it? but other people whom ia respect, i know they post from beliefe and not love. so i know everything in boxing is subjective... so to me there is no such thing as a rovvery in boxing full stop.
best case for anyont is oscar vs sturm, 99% always say sturm won, but oscer got the nod sp he could fight hopkins. but there will always be one person who can give u a legit reason for the luckt cunt to have won, always.
btw, i hope u read what i said and can make sense of it, but if u are wondring what the flying fuck i am on aboutm i dont know? we are closing in on 5am and i am to fucked up to sleep so i am on this forum lol :D
Posting drunk is always fun.Quote:
Originally Posted by Preme
Actually doing a lot of things drunk is fun.