I dont think one fighter in any class stands out more than any other besides Floyd who needs to face better comp. before he can prove that to me
Printable View
I dont think one fighter in any class stands out more than any other besides Floyd who needs to face better comp. before he can prove that to me
  PBF.     Â
  Who in the world is James Tayler ???
Who's James Taylor?And also as much as it kills me to say this I would say
that Winky is my #1 P4P.Just has more experience and ring generalship
than PBF.
Who is James Tayler?
you mean Jermain Taylor?
I would say James Tayler for sure.......
Honestly tho i think it could be PBF. If he wins another fight against a top guy eg Hatton then it will definitly be him. Winky is close, and (jermain) Taylor, Morales, Hatton have to be in the mix.
Its hard to say tho cos so many of the top P4P guys have lost this year.
Hopkins
Trinidad
Tszyu
I still think B-hop is 1 p4p
I think hes great old but great Tayler beat him but he wont in the rematch
how can taylor possibly be no.1??
ok he got the decision over hopkins but thats it maybe he's in the top 10 but 1 good win does not make u no.1 p4p! No disrespect but before the fight a lot of people were saying he did not have much chance after fighting light middles.
I admit i havent seen the hopkins fight but that does not matter too much in this discussion. He still has to establish himself we will know more after the rematch.
if u can make an argument for taylor after beating hopkins then you can make an equally as strong argument for hatton if not stronger.
James Taylor is a famous singer and guitarist from the 70's and 80's. So between the two, I'd have to say PBF, as Taylor is pretty old by now. Then again, he's pretty tall and lanky, so he might have a decent jab.Quote:
Originally Posted by silent assassin
Was trying to do top ten p4p this morning looking at last Ring magazine list - not so easy now Tszyu (3) and Hopkins (1) have been beaten, especially as the guys that beat them don't really warrant a top berth in the p4p rankings just yet.
BUT
if they have beaten these guys then they HAVE TO be ranked above them, though I can't put Hatton any higher than #9 or #10 and Taylor no higher than #7 (at the moment)
I have it between Winky and PBF for #1 now I guess - just pipping John Ruiz who will have to settle for #3
alot of people hate him but PBF's skills and athleticism is undeniable. PBF handsdown 8)
Skill wise Winky doesn't compare to PBFQuote:
Originally Posted by Humble
hes just a tough bloke with arms too big for his body
lets face it if Winky had normal size arms he'd be shit
Winky's awessome to Bro IMO, regardless of the disproportionate arm ;DQuote:
Originally Posted by PunchDrunkHighOn_?
GENETIC FREAK HE SHOULD BE CULLED!Quote:
Originally Posted by Humble
pbf is definetly up there p4p. Also zab judah , morrales , hopkins still up there too.
He's a singer/songwriter. You know,"Fire and Rain","You've Got a Friend." Was married once to Carly Simon. Didn't know he boxed too though. Always seemed like a laidback kinda fellow to me. ;)
Quote:
Originally Posted by silent assassin
It's hard to figure where Hopkins and Taylor go- but without a doubt it leaves Mayweather, Winky, Barrera, and Morales way up there.
James Taylor is some morph of Jermain Taylor and James Toney.
Still PBF
OTHER:
ZAB "super" JUDAH!!!
Floyd Mayweather is a great technician and probably number 2 p4p. However the clear p4p king currently is none other than Carlos Maussa who would destroy Mayweather if he ever set foot in the same ring as him.
Since that was just your 1st post here I can't say I know whether you're the sarcastic type.Quote:
Originally Posted by birch
For all I know you can really be one of those rare Maussa fans. Which would be strange.
Ok I like him too, but only because he's got such a funny style. Mayweather could probably beat him quicker than Bernard Hopkins once beat a fella by the name of Steve Frank.
I think winkys p4p no 1, but pbf only a lil bit behind. taylors good but i dont think he should be higher than 8th at the best
This is why I dont understand alot of people you only have acknoledged Taylor and PBF. Wheres Morales he has given us way more exiting fights than those 2 and has ducked no one. He has fought hard contenders back to back and has kept people at the edge of their seats. Example when he went toe toe with pac on the 12 round he dint need to but he did it for the fight fans. What else does he have to do to get his props. Thats a P4P 1.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bond007
That is a good arguement.However if he is the #1 P4P then what about
Barrera since he has beat Morales twice.
styles makes fights and morales beat up the guy who blew out barrera.Quote:
Originally Posted by AbnerMares
floyd should be p4p #1.
Who's James Taylor? Where the hell do we get these boxing fans!?!Quote:
Originally Posted by silent assassin
Who's James Taylor?! :P ;) ;D :D jk
Have your first cool click for adding a some common sense to the argument ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by birch