Printable View
Julie Lederman 115-112 Corrales in the 2nd Casa fight.
Adalaide Byrd 114-113 Hopkins in the Calzaghe fight.
Eugine Williamd 115-113 Holyfield in the 1st Lewis bout.
They happen to be women, not being stupid but those 3 scores stick out for me in the modern era.
Glen Hamada 117-111 Jones v Tarver I
Byrd's scorecard in the Hopkins - Calzaghe is not questionable.Quote:
Originally Posted by Markusdarkus
You will find many fans who have that score for Hopkins including me.
Diaz - Katsidis one judge scored it for Katsidis 115-113. I have no idea where he got that scorecard from. ;D
I scored the fight for Calzaghe but there were plenty that could go either way so I wouldn't argue with byrds scoring
Quote:
Originally Posted by rjj tszyu
I thought it was terrible.
Mind you she is black, is a muslim, is a women and wears glasses so she wasnt going to favour Hopkins was she :p
Harry Davis' 117-111 on the Luevano/ Santiago fight was a recent one
116-111 all three judges had that in the Joe Calzaghe vs Robin Reid fight.
Carlos Zarate vs Lupe Pintor judge: Bob Martin 145-133 what the hell seriously ?
And is this some sort of wind up ? i had Bernard Hopkins winning by 1 point aswell and so did many people just because your hardcore Joe Calzaghe fan doesn't mean we are all biased Hopkins landed the much more effective shots just name me one good hard punch Joe Calzaghe really landed on Bernard Hopkins in the entire fight ?
Cristian Mijares/Jose Navarro - Some judge had it 120-108 Navarro. I really don't know how you couldn't give Mijares less than 7 rounds.
Some other fool gave Jermain Taylor 117-111 over Cory Spinks when Taylor got took to school.
Glen Hamada 115-113 for Kats against Juan Diaz. Glen Hamada is a disgrace and should be banned from judging. Tony Paolilo 96-93 Forrest over Quartey. Jose Juan Guerra 118-110 Leonard over Hagler.Quote:
Originally Posted by Markusdarkus
Hopkins v Calzaghe was a close fight that could have gone either way.Some rounds were very close and hard to score.
The 2 judges that gave Casamayor the fight against Santa Cruz was bad.
The 3 fucking judges who screwed Morales out of his 4th weight title against David Diaz. I had him win that fight by four rounds plus a knockdown. How the hell anyone scored that for David Diaz I will never know.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Markusdarkus
How about Glen Hamada scoring Diaz/Katsidis 115-113 for Katsidis?
Kats won 3 rounds TOPS and this clown GIVES the fight to Katsidis? I nearly shit when they annouced that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MarkusdarkusQuote:
Originally Posted by rjj tszyu
I thought it was terrible.
Mind you she is black, is a muslim, is a women and wears glasses so she wasnt going to favour Hopkins was she :p
Dude Hopkins/Calzaghe was close as hell, so someone giving it to Bhop by 1 point really doesn't qualify as "most questionable scoring" IMO.
Fight could have gone either way.
Yes the glasses might have had something to do with it. There was a rumour going around that she actually switched the rose tinted Joe Calzaghe lenses you mailed to her and wore her regular presciption.:rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by MarkusdarkusQuote:
Originally Posted by rjj tszyu
I thought it was terrible.
Mind you she is black, is a muslim, is a women and wears glasses so she wasnt going to favour Hopkins was she :p
I hate to break it to Joe fans,he won it on work rate,not connections.
The arm isnt a pointing target,and thats mainly what he hit.
Its hard to see that as the actions going on,but go back and check the tape,he hit nothing but bicep all through the fight.
But even that being said,I wasnt crying about a bad decision,Joe DID out work Bernard,as a fighter you have to consider that as well
I'm a fan of Calzaghe, but I would've loved to see him in against a prime B-Hop. No doubt B-Hop would've taken it by a fairly wide margin. Of course, I guess the point could be made that Calzaghe wasn't in his prime either...Quote:
Originally Posted by Trainer Monkey
Prime Hopkins vs Prime Calzaghe would look like Bika vs Calzaghe but Hopkins would win Hopkins had amazing workrate in his prime like Marvin HaglerQuote:
Originally Posted by CFHI'm a fan of Calzaghe, but I would've loved to see him in against a prime B-Hop. No doubt B-Hop would've taken it by a fairly wide margin. Of course, I guess the point could be made that Calzaghe wasn't in his prime either...Quote:
Originally Posted by Trainer Monkey
This is true,he didnt start to pick his shots as much until TrinidadQuote:
Originally Posted by ICBPrime Hopkins vs Prime Calzaghe would look like Bika vs Calzaghe but Hopkins would win Hopkins had amazing workrate in his prime like Marvin HaglerQuote:
Originally Posted by CFHI'm a fan of Calzaghe, but I would've loved to see him in against a prime B-Hop. No doubt B-Hop would've taken it by a fairly wide margin. Of course, I guess the point could be made that Calzaghe wasn't in his prime either...Quote:
Originally Posted by Trainer Monkey
Emanuel augustus/Courtney Burton.......Robert "Tard" Pagnalli 99-00 Courtney !! Criminal
Leonard/Duran 1......Angelo Prletti 147-148 Just making TEN rounds even is bad enough.Teddy Atlas would be proud :bucktooth:
Wayne Mccullough/Victor Rabanales.....117-110 McCullough some clueless clown :twak: