-
Most Pointless Rematches
Bernard Hopkins vs Robert Allen 3
Julio Cesar Chavez vs Roger Mayweather 2
Joe Calzaghe vs Mario Veit 2
Paul Malignaggi vs Lovemore Ndou 2
Carlo Olson vs Sugar Ray Robinson 4
Theres few examples.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Hatton -Mayweather if it ever happens.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Matt Marsh - Rocky Dean
They're having a triology :o
Also the Sam Soliman-Anthony Mundine triology was a joke.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
leftylee
Matt Marsh - Rocky Dean
They're having a triology :o
Also the Sam Soliman-Anthony Mundine triology was a joke.
Good call on Mundine vs Soliman that indeed was a joke.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ICB
Bernard Hopkins vs Robert Allen 3
Julio Cesar Chavez vs Roger Mayweather 2
Joe Calzaghe vs Mario Veit 2
Paul Malignaggi vs Lovemore Ndou 2
Carlo Olson vs Sugar Ray Robinson 4
Theres few examples.
Boxrec says that in the first Hopkins vs Allen fight, the fight had to be stopped after Mills Lane Pushed Hopkins out of the ring. I never heard of this. What happened?
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
As I recall Hopkins was winning and Mills was trying to get in between them to stop the fight and mistakenly pushed Hopkins down, injuring him.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Mosley-Mayorga. Oh wait, that's not a rematch.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Danny Williams v Sprott v Audley v Skelton
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
azumah nelson-jeff fenech 3. why?
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
lance Uppercut
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ICB
Bernard Hopkins vs Robert Allen 3
Julio Cesar Chavez vs Roger Mayweather 2
Joe Calzaghe vs Mario Veit 2
Paul Malignaggi vs Lovemore Ndou 2
Carlo Olson vs Sugar Ray Robinson 4
Theres few examples.
Boxrec says that in the first Hopkins vs Allen fight, the fight had to be stopped after Mills Lane Pushed Hopkins out of the ring. I never heard of this. What happened?
The fight was starting to get rough and Mills lane went to break a clinch and accientally sent Hopkins through the ropes.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
kingfrnk
vargas and mosley 2
Why was that pointless? At the time of the first stoppage Vargas was on top and looking like the most likely to win, it was a close fight. In hindsight you say that cos the second fight was so one sided but at the time a rematch was defintly needed.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Scott22
azumah nelson-jeff fenech 3. why?
Fenech needed the money. He didn't feel like stealing another watch
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
skel1983
Quote:
Originally Posted by
kingfrnk
vargas and mosley 2
Why was that pointless? At the time of the first stoppage Vargas was on top and looking like the most likely to win, it was a close fight. In hindsight you say that cos the second fight was so one sided but at the time a rematch was defintly needed.
I agree with Skel.. Kingfrnk is a complete idiot
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Trainer Monkey
Ruiz anyone
Indeed Valuev - Ruiz.. Not because it was not competitive or anything but really WHO gives a fock lol..
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Winky and Mckart trilogy, ugh
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Preme
Arce hussein 2
The first fight was competetive.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
barrera vs pacquiao 2... :confused: sad thing is i was rootin for barrera :(
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
snakey
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Preme
Arce hussein 2
The first fight was competetive.
I think some of these fights look stupid in retrospect......but sometimes they don't look that bad whenever they are made.
Only when the guy who lost a decent fight the first time, gets his ass kicked again. Then they look stupid.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
snakey
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Preme
Arce hussein 2
The first fight was competetive.
Look at the idiot you quoted.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pugilistic
Quote:
Originally Posted by
lance Uppercut
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ICB
Bernard Hopkins vs Robert Allen 3
Julio Cesar Chavez vs Roger Mayweather 2
Joe Calzaghe vs Mario Veit 2
Paul Malignaggi vs Lovemore Ndou 2
Carlo Olson vs Sugar Ray Robinson 4
Theres few examples.
Boxrec says that in the first Hopkins vs Allen fight, the fight had to be stopped after Mills Lane Pushed Hopkins out of the ring. I never heard of this. What happened?
The fight was starting to get rough and Mills lane went to break a clinch and accientally sent Hopkins through the ropes.
Some people think Hopkins faked the injury to the knee. Because Allen was actually wining the fight and was begining to gain momentum.
I haven't seen the fight in a long time but I think that's how the fight was going. I have about 30 Hopkins fights and I know I haven't seen them all but I've seen the Allen trilogy for sure...
Going through this just now Hopkins had a couple of rematches he shouldn't have what the hell did he fight Echols twice for?
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ICB
Julio Cesar Chavez vs Roger Mayweather 2
It might seem pointless now but not at that time.
When JCC sparked him out in 2 it was a shocker. Especially cause he had just stepped into world class as opposed to Roger who was a former Champ. and had been on the world stage for a couple of yrs.
Leading up to the fight Roger was just like his nephew. Talking loud and saying he was gonna destroy JCC. He was gonna do this and that....
Well, JCC gets him out fast. Then came the whole weight talk from Roger saying he had issues and blah! blah! blah!
Roger went flew up to 140 where years later it happened that JCC was highly ranked by his good from Sulaiman in the WBC ranks and Roger was the champ. A rematch because of the shocking win by JCC and the weight excuse.
While Roger lasted longer the outcome was the same, JCC won.
I don't think it was pointless especially because it wasn't an imidiate rematch and because it just happened years later. JCC was highly ranked and Roger happened to be the champ. The outcome of fight #1 was just the topping on the cake.
You know which JCC rematch was pointless?
vs. ODLH.
Now that was a pointless rematch.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CutMeMick
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pugilistic
Quote:
Originally Posted by
lance Uppercut
Boxrec says that in the first Hopkins vs Allen fight, the fight had to be stopped after Mills Lane Pushed Hopkins out of the ring. I never heard of this. What happened?
The fight was starting to get rough and Mills lane went to break a clinch and accientally sent Hopkins through the ropes.
Some people think Hopkins faked the injury to the knee. Because Allen was actually wining the fight and was begining to gain momentum.
I haven't seen the fight in a long time but I think that's how the fight was going. I have about 30 Hopkins fights and I know I haven't seen them all but I've seen the Allen trilogy for sure...
Going through this just now Hopkins had a couple of rematches he shouldn't have what the hell did he fight Echols twice for?
The fight was even up till Hopkins fell out of the ring, I don't think it was his knee that he hurt. Could of been but i think it was his shoulder, i will have to check it out later.
Elchols became number 1 IBF contender making Hopkins fight him a second time, both fights were actually quite good. Second one was a dirty fight though.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pugilistic
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CutMeMick
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pugilistic
The fight was starting to get rough and Mills lane went to break a clinch and accientally sent Hopkins through the ropes.
Some people think Hopkins faked the injury to the knee. Because Allen was actually wining the fight and was begining to gain momentum.
I haven't seen the fight in a long time but I think that's how the fight was going. I have about 30 Hopkins fights and I know I haven't seen them all but I've seen the Allen trilogy for sure...
Going through this just now Hopkins had a couple of rematches he shouldn't have what the hell did he fight Echols twice for?
The fight was even up till Hopkins fell out of the ring, I don't think it was his knee that he hurt. Could of been but i think it was his shoulder, i will have to check it out later.
Elchols became number 1 IBF contender making Hopkins fight him a second time, both fights were actually quite good. Second one was a dirty fight though.
Yeah! for some reason I pic. him on the floor holding his leg.
Can't remember...
That makes sense about the Echols fight.
Those damn! Mandatorys...
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quite a few of the fights mentioned were mandatories. Others made MONEY sense.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Not sure if this has been covered because im simply above back tracking through threads (new members game) but for me i just knew that Lennox would Smash Rahman down like a bag of shit tied up with string in the middle as soon as the rematch was announced and f*ck me he hit him hard..."One..Two...BANG"
Do miss Lennox
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=AI8bBY...eature=related
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Calzaghe-Veit was the definition of pointless.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Some of these fight could be considered stay busy fights. .....in keeping ring rust off, no fight is pointless.
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
No Winky fight is pointless :p
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
boozeboxer
No Winky fight is pointless :p
Winky vs. Anthony Ivory rematch......pointless;D;D
-
Re: Most Pointless Rematches
Quote:
Originally Posted by
CutMeMick
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pugilistic
Quote:
Originally Posted by
lance Uppercut
Boxrec says that in the first Hopkins vs Allen fight, the fight had to be stopped after Mills Lane Pushed Hopkins out of the ring. I never heard of this. What happened?
The fight was starting to get rough and Mills lane went to break a clinch and accientally sent Hopkins through the ropes.
Some people think Hopkins faked the injury to the knee. Because Allen was actually wining the fight and was begining to gain momentum.
I haven't seen the fight in a long time but I think that's how the fight was going. I have about 30 Hopkins fights and I know I haven't seen them all but I've seen the Allen trilogy for sure...
Going through this just now Hopkins had a couple of rematches he shouldn't have what the hell did he fight Echols twice for?
Well Hopkins vs Echols 1 was competitive as i remember it i only had Hopkins winning by a few points because Echols tired in the later stages, i remember Echols being unlucky aswell not having a knockdown scored over Hopkins in the 1st round, but yes your right there was no real need for the rematch it wasn't controversial win the first time, and while were on the subject. Hopkins vs Echols 2 was one of the dirtiest fights i've ever seen.