Yes Another Pernell Whitaker Thread But Come In And Voice Your Opinions.

Who was more exciting Floyd Mayweather or Pernell Whitaker.

Method Not Implemented

POST to /boxingforum/newreply.php not supported.

Huge fan of both... man it's a tough call, but i will go with sweet pea. He was just more physical, and was not afraid to trade a few shots every now and then.

Whitaker by a mile.

Floyd's my favorite fighter but I will have to say Whitaker.

Hands down,Sweet pea.Also faced the much better competition Imo

Whitaker by a mile, Whitaker was a combination puncher.

I still remember Whitaker throwing behind the back punches, I have to go with Whitaker on this one

sweet pea

How about who was better?

sweetpea fought against better opposition and had more style than Mayweather

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by BIG H

How about who was better?

---

I don't know it's crazy.. styles make fights... I mean look what Sweet Pea did agaisnt a prime DLH, and what PBF did with a old DLH. It's one of those fights that you can only dream of.. sort of like Ali-Marciano but let's not get into that :D.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by purtyboy

Huge fan of both... man it's a tough call, but i will go with sweet pea. He was just more physical, and was not afraid to trade a few shots every now and then.

---

Agree he did make his more exciting by tradeing shots. But who had better defense?????

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yjTHLPmfBCQ

first thing is said after watched this highlight. DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMN :o

I think they're both exciting to watch. I liked Whitaker more, but that's probably just because I was a kid when he was fighting, and we tend to idolize athletes more when we're younger.

One other thing is that I love watching the jab, and Pernell jabbed a lot more than Floyd.

I think Pernell is definitely more exciting to watch then Floyd, His style is more geared towards that, I think comparing Pernell and Floyd is like comparing Hopkins and Roy JOnes Jr.

Hopkins is a defense first fighter, who in his prime was more exciting than Roy Jones Jr to some, but as they went on Roy still had his incredible speed, while Bernard threw less and less punches.

I the same thing here, but that Floyd wasn't necessarily as exciting as Pernell, but he certianly was as exciting in plenty of fights (Ndou, Chavez, Corrales, Augustus, Corley, etc.) I think as he got bigger Floyd doesn't throw combinations or that jab like he did in his prime, but go back and watch him against Genaro Hernandez or Chavez, and you will him throwing beautiful combinations, but all in all Floyd and Bernard didn't and don't have flashy styles, They are no nonsense fighters that make fewer mistakes then anyone else.

For me it wasn't Pernell output that made him more exciting, but all that hot dogging and cocky defensive skills he used, I am sure Floyd could do most of that stuff, but he would rather not take the chance. Floyd fought within his security blanket while Pernell brashly mocked his opponents, large and small alike.