Enough Talk, post your scorecards for froch-Taylor

Dont know why there arernt more threads like this. This way you can pick apart someones scoring accurately and logically rather than; I had him 3 rounds up going into ....... ok maybe in this case it aint valid seen as that was a legitimate stoppage but this way you can clearly see whether he needed the KO or not. Some of the press row scoring was wank IMO.

So here's mine feel free to rip it to pieces:

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor (close)
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Froch (close)
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Froch
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Taylor (close)
9. 10-9 Froch
10. 10-9 Froch
11. 10-10 (both men landed even amount of power punches tho Taylors more flashy)
12. Irrelevant

I had it 106-103 Taylor going into the last round, Froch needed that KO IMO. What about you guys?

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Froch
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Froch
9. 10-9 Froch
10. 10-9 Froch
11. 10-9 Taylor
12. Froch's obviously

So I had it 106-102 for Taylor going into the final round. If he'd have just taken a knee or two he would have had it.

1-10-9 JT
2-10-9 JT
3-10-8 JT
4-10-9 JT
5-10-9 JT
6-10-9 JT
7-10-9 JT
8-10-9 JT
9-10-9 CF
10-10-9 CF
11-10-9 CF

107-102 JT goin into the 12th

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Froch
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Froch
9. 10-9 Froch
10. 10-9 Froch
11. 10-9 Froch
12. Well I guess 10-8 Froch if Taylor had stayed up.

That would make it a dead draw on my card I think, which I believe is probably the appox ave opinion of most boxing analysts and media folks.

Oh the cards that I know of are as follows/


Official scores 106-102 Taylor 106-102 Taylor 106-102 Froch, not sure how Woodburn already Froch up by 4 going into the twelth though.

On the press row, Chris Givens had it 105-103 Taylor same as me, so would have been a draw

Niall Hickman already had Froch winning 105-104

Jack Obermayer had it 104-104 so Froch would have won on his card.

Al Bernstein had it also 105-103 so a draw had it gone the distance.


It's pretty clear that the one sided of the fight up until the knockout has been exaggerated a lot on this board by many imo.



This means that according the 7 known cards, Taylor wins on two, Froch wins on 3 and two draws. Close fight.

my score card is taylor got knocked the f**k out.

Completely dropped the ball on this one, caught only the last three rounds.Unfortunately Showtime does not replay,HBO does though, about 5 times.Taylor looked rigid,stiff leading to KO.His legs have always appeared ..undersized ?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bilbo

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Froch
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Froch
9. 10-9 Froch
10. 10-9 Froch
11. 10-9 Froch
12. Well I guess 10-8 Froch if Taylor had stayed up.

That would make it a dead draw on my card I think, which I believe is probably the appox ave opinion of most boxing analysts and media folks.

---

That's how I have it. Taylor wasn't that far ahead going into the last round, but Froch needed something dramatic.

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Taylor
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Taylor
9. 10-9 Taylor
10. 10-9 Taylor
11. 10-9 Even

Like I said. Taylor gave it away. He should get 2 losses for that. Only an idiot would of had Carl winning going into the 12

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Taylor
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Taylor
9. 10-9 Taylor
10. 10-9 Taylor
11. 10-9 Even

Like I said. Taylor gave it away. He should get 2 losses for that. Only an idiot would of had Carl winning going into the 12

---

That's some scorecard VD!! :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by miles

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Taylor
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Taylor
9. 10-9 Taylor
10. 10-9 Taylor
11. 10-9 Even

Like I said. Taylor gave it away. He should get 2 losses for that. Only an idiot would of had Carl winning going into the 12

---

That's some scorecard VD!! :lol:

---

VD's a bit exagerated lol but i gotta agree i didn't think the fight was very close, i had Taylor winning 1-8 and Froch take 9,10,11, and well he obiously took the 12th, so if Taylor would have survived the 12th, it would have been an 8 to 4 decision win for JT

I haven't properly scored the fight yet but watching the fight i felt Taylor was comfortably ahead.

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Froch
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Froch
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Taylor
9. 10-9 Froch
10. 10-9 Froch
11. 10-9 Froch
12.

6 rounds to Taylor and 5 for Froch, two points down for the last round.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Taylor
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Taylor
9. 10-9 Taylor
10. 10-9 Taylor
11. 10-9 Even

Like I said. Taylor gave it away. He should get 2 losses for that. Only an idiot would of had Carl winning going into the 12

---

Wow... you really are a froch hater aren't you. 11th round even?! are you taking the piss? Taylor landed zero big shots and took about 10 big shots himself. And to give Taylor the 9 rounds before... I think you must be taking the piss here surely. :-\

Anyway, I didn't keep a scorecard on paper but I kept a 'mental' scorecard.. I had it 7-4 going into the 12th round in favour of Taylor, with Taylor having the 10-8 round in the 3rd too. So on my cards Froch would of lost even if Taylor survived the 12th.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by JoeyUK

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Taylor
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Taylor
9. 10-9 Taylor
10. 10-9 Taylor
11. 10-9 Even

Like I said. Taylor gave it away. He should get 2 losses for that. Only an idiot would of had Carl winning going into the 12

---

Wow... you really are a froch hater aren't you. 11th round even?! are you taking the piss? Taylor landed zero big shots and took about 10 big shots himself. And to give Taylor the 9 rounds before... I think you must be taking the piss here surely. :-\

Anyway, I didn't keep a scorecard on paper but I kept a 'mental' scorecard.. I had it 7-4 going into the 12th round in favour of Taylor, with Taylor having the 10-8 round in the 3rd too. So on my cards Froch would of lost even if Taylor survived the 12th.

---

i had it 8-3 for Taylor but could see it being 7-4 seeing how 7th and 8th rounds were close, but i thought that Taylor was able to steal both due to how he stole the 2 rounds

Some of you are actually plane arrogant, or blind, I had Taylor winning by a round going into the 12th. but as ledsham said, my score card says Taylor got KTFO ;D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tam Seddon

Some of you are actually plane arrogant, or blind, I had Taylor winning by a round going into the 12th. but as ledsham said, my score card says Taylor got KTFO ;D

---

seems that the one who's blind is you, saying "i knew that it was going to be his strategy to get his handed to him for 7 or 8 odd rounds then pick off Taylor" :rolleyes:

I knew Taylors abilities early on in the fight would have Carl in trouble, but I knew full well that he wouldnt be able to do that for 12 rounds. If he could do you think he would have ever lost a fight? I think Taylor would currently be p4p number 1 if he could sustain what he does in the start. Im not blind at all, im just realistic that from round 6 onwards the pace of the fight was starting to turn in favour and carl won rounds 8-12 strongly on my card, with round 7 being close.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ledsham

my score card is taylor got knocked the f**k out.

---

Enough said!



But for the sake of the thread, I don't have an official card but I thought Taylor was well ahead. Had he finished the fight on his feet he would be champ.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Taylor
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Taylor
9. 10-9 Taylor
10. 10-9 Taylor
11. 10-9 Even

Like I said. Taylor gave it away. He should get 2 losses for that. Only an idiot would of had Carl winning going into the 12

---

VD... I don't actually think you're a bad poster but sometimes you just lose all credibilaty.

Fair enough there were a lot of close rounds in there and I myself had Taylor up by 4-5 rounds but come on... You don't have to be a Froch fanboy or whatever I'm sure you'll call me to see that Froch managed to win at the very least 1 round out of 11.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tam Seddon

I knew Taylors abilities early on in the fight would have Carl in trouble, but I knew full well that he wouldnt be able to do that for 12 rounds. If he could do you think he would have ever lost a fight? I think Taylor would currently be p4p number 1 if he could sustain what he does in the start. Im not blind at all, im just realistic that from round 6 onwards the pace of the fight was starting to turn in favour and carl won rounds 8-12 strongly on my card, with round 7 being close.

---

i didn't see Froch win a round CLEARLY till the 9th, and didn't start to make an impression until the 7th, IMO in both the 7th and 8th he started well but Taylor stole both rounds by basically turning up the tempo and landing everything, by the 9th Taylor looked gassed, i'm not in anyway saying Froch didn't earn his win, cause he did, just don't think he's #1 or even #2 at 168, and honestly if Taylor would go back to using his jab, he'd beat Froch in a rematch

i watched the first 3 rounds plus the 12th. The first 2 rounds neither guy deserved the round so i guess they were pickems. In the third round taylor got a 10-8 because of the knock down.

1 Taylor
2 Taylor
3 Taylor (kd)
4. Taylor
5. Froch
6. Taylor
7. Taylor
8 Taylor
9 Taylor
10. Froch
11 Taylor

1.10-9 Jt
2.10-9 Jt
3.10-8 Jt
4.10-9 Jt
5.10-9 Jt
6.10-9 Cf
7.10-9 Jt
8.10-9 Jt
9.10-9 Cf
10.10-9 Cf
11.10-9 Cf

1. 10-9 Taylor
2. 10-9 Taylor
3. 10-8 Taylor
4. 10-9 Taylor
5. 10-9 Taylor
6. 10-9 Froch
7. 10-9 Taylor
8. 10-9 Froch
9. 10-9 Taylor
10. 10-9 Froch
11. 10-9 Taylor
12. GAME OVER MANNNNNNNNNNNNN

I though taylor was in full control, was beating Froch at everything but tired. Froch hasnt experienced bixing at this level and now he has hes guna have to get some of his basics working like his jab and his defence.

If your not quick enough to slip a punch then your guna get punched. Froch isnt too fast he should defend properly.

ROUND1---

ROUND2---

ROUND3---

ROUND4---

ROUND5---

ROUND6---

ROUND7---

ROUND8---

ROUND9---

ROUND10---

ROUND11---

ROUND12 TAYLOR GOT KNOCKED THE FUCK OUT!!!! ;D Thats all that matters the scores mean nothing now.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tysonbruno

ROUND1---

ROUND2---

ROUND3---

ROUND4---

ROUND5---

ROUND6---

ROUND7---

ROUND8---

ROUND9---

ROUND10---

ROUND11---

ROUND12 TAYLOR GOT KNOCKED THE FUCK OUT!!!! ;D Thats all that matters the scores mean nothing now.

---

Hahahaha ;D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tam Seddon

Some of you are actually plane arrogant, or blind, I had Taylor winning by a round going into the 12th. but as ledsham said, my score card says Taylor got KTFO ;D

---

and that completely dispels any opinion of you being byest.

I watched the fight as a neutral having seen froch many times over and had it dead level going into the last and had taylor of managed to last 14 seconds i would of still had froch taking the round 10-7 and winning by a clear margin.


104-104 through 11
114-111 froch had taylor of taken a knee and got through the 15 secs!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tam Seddon

Some of you are actually plane arrogant, or blind, I had Taylor winning by a round going into the 12th. but as ledsham said, my score card says Taylor got KTFO ;D

---

and that completely dispels any opinion of you being byest.

I watched the fight as a neutral having seen froch many times over and had it dead level going into the last and had taylor of managed to last 14 seconds i would of still had froch taking the round 10-7 and winning by a clear margin.


104-104 through 11
114-111 froch had taylor of taken a knee and got through the 15 secs!!

---

Hammer please spell this word correctly from now on, I've seen you spell it like this 3 times now.

It's 'biased'.

Thankyou

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bilbo

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by hattonthehammer

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Tam Seddon

Some of you are actually plane arrogant, or blind, I had Taylor winning by a round going into the 12th. but as ledsham said, my score card says Taylor got KTFO ;D

---

and that completely dispels any opinion of you being byest.

I watched the fight as a neutral having seen froch many times over and had it dead level going into the last and had taylor of managed to last 14 seconds i would of still had froch taking the round 10-7 and winning by a clear margin.


104-104 through 11
114-111 froch had taylor of taken a knee and got through the 15 secs!!

---

Hammer please spell this word correctly from now on, I've seen you spell it like this 3 times now.

It's 'biased'.

Thankyou

---

nxt tym i post on ere i`ll make syure i spell corectly promiss

My scorecard has froch winning by 12th round tko. The only round worth scoring.