Printable View
Which would be more impressive?
(1) Pacman beating floyd then JMM in a third match,
(2) JMM beating floyd then beating pacman in a third match,
(3) PBF beating both Pacman and JMM @ catch weight , or lastly
(4) PBF beating Cotto and mosley @147...
IMO...I'd say victories over cotto and shane would be more impressive..
difinitely #4
WHAT?!
Pacquiao beating Floyd and Marquez would be huge. But he would be the favorite against Marquez.
PBF would be the favorite against JMM and the favorite or damn well be even according to fight odds against Pacquiao.
PBF would also be the favorite against Mosley and Cotto. Plus, he's already settled in the welterweight division.
Marquez beating Pacquiao and Mayweather TRUMPS all those other options by a long shot. Marquez is moving up two weight classes to fight a prime (but somewhat inactive) Mayweather. Marquez drew and lost to Pacquiao so a win would be HUGE for him, especially after having beaten Mayweather to get there. All this, plus he 35-36 years old!!! This is a no brainer IMO...
Pacman beating floyd then JMM in a third match,
Pacman beating Floyd of course:). Imagine facing the guy who didn't show any flaw/weakness at all only to be beaten by Pac clearly and not with a JMM-like decision. There would be lots of big fights along the road after that: Cotto, Mosley, Williams, Wright, etc. If Pac beat them all.....whoa! Wouldn't that be quite a nice resume.
Where's the poll? :sd:
I kid. :)
#1 would be super ultra hard to achieve, but it's not impossible.
Marquez beating both Mayweather and Pacquiao hands down.Cancel the corination of the two kings.Do we mean that in addition to JMM beating Pac here,that he actually gets the official decision this time around;D
Dont see Mayweather wanting Cotto or Mosley,just not going to happen Imo.
Marquez is getting on a bit now so I think Manny has a chance of a clearer win if they had a third fight (especially at a higher weight) also Floyd coming back after a lay off means nothing to me he is always in tip top shape from what I see.
So for me, Marquez beating both Mayweather and Pac would be astonishing.
I agreeQuote:
Originally Posted by Master
That's my second choice. I believe either of those guys can whoop Floyd's butt.Quote:
Originally Posted by ASIAN SENSATION
From all the names mentioned I think Floyd would have the less trouble with Cotto. Sure, he can pack a punch but its slow compared to Floyd in defense and ofense.Quote:
Dont see Mayweather wanting Cotto
JMM beating floyd then beating pacman in a third match,
Two back to back P4P victories against these men in their prime years.....I mean hell you cant even call what Floyd did a legit retirement, there are champions who take longer hiatus between defending their titles...so the ring rust factor realoly is nullified
Spot on, you worded that much better though.Quote:
Originally Posted by DaxxKahn
I'll co-sign this post.Quote:
Originally Posted by C-Lo
JMM is the undedog vs. Both Men it's that simple end of...
What more do you need.
Any welterweight or less beating Cotto and Mosley would be the trump card. They are big welterweights and Cotto is basically undefeated having taking on all comers. Mosley, well he needs no explanation.
Marquez beating Mayweather and Pacquiao easily is the most impressive.
Number 3- Pretty Boy ending his layoff and beating the number 2 and 1 p4p fighters and then going to 147 and beating Cotto vs Sugar Shane if it ever happens.
[quote=CutMeMick;727910]I'll co-sign this post.[/quote]Quote:
Originally Posted by C-Lo
Busted as a BoxingScene boy ;D dammit I busted myself too:-\
option 3. JMM underdog at 35 beating no's 1 & 2 on many people P4P lists.