Does Enzo Maccarinelli remain in the pool at Cruiser? After being stopped again I vote he is removed
Printable View
Does Enzo Maccarinelli remain in the pool at Cruiser? After being stopped again I vote he is removed
He was just brutally knocked out again.Out
Put a fork in him he's done, even if he continues fighting his career has been set back years.
He said he's retired.
Done
Old Heavyweight/Cruiserweight/Light-Heavyweight Polls to be merged in here
Enzo is done not only as a CW but a fighter of worth period, Licina is tough and hasn't lost a fight in over 4 years his comp is on par with most of the other CWts in the pool I vote out with Mac in with Licina
Hi Daxx, there's already a poll about Maccarinelli, but I second Licina entering the pool
Enzo has already been dropped, but I don't think Licina should go straight in the pool, but there's no option for that. I think his next fight should be for pool entry if not against a ranked opponent
Quote:
Originally Posted by Galaxy
Dont know how I missed the Endo thread sorry
With 2 spots vacant at heavy I think we should vote on who fills the 9th spot to start with.
Who is most deserving?
Chris Arreola
Kevin Johnson
Denis Boystov
Arreola for me!
I think the Johnson/ Solis winner could be a better option for 10th
Only 2 votes so far? Arreola looks like a sure thing!
The Poll has now closed. The results are as follows:
Chris Arreola enters at the #9 position by a vote of 4 points to 0
We have four guys in the pool with two vacancies to fill, starting with the number 9 spot.
Chris Arreola 27-0-0 (24 KOs)
next fight 9/26/09 against Vitali Klitschko
last fight 4/11/09 - W KO 4 - against Jameel McCline
Kevin Johnson 22-0-1 (9 KOs)
next fight 10/10/09 against Odlanier Solis
last fight 5/15/09 - W TKO 6 - against Devin Vargas
Denis Boystov 25-0-0 (20 KOs)
next fight N/A
last fight 6/6/09 - W TKO 6 - against Taras Bidenko
Alexander Dimitrenko 29-1-0 (19 KOs)
next fight N/A
last fight 7/4/09 - L MD - against Eddie Chambers
Hey killer, we already had this poll earlier this week. Arreola has been voted in...
http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...avyweight.html
I'd like to be the one to put forward motions in my division. I mean yes we got the same result, but I didn't get to vote on this one because I missed seeing it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Galaxy
That's cool bro, no harm intended, sorry you missed it. Just like you putting up the poll with Khan & Romanov or me putting up the one with Lacy, Munoz, Parra & Quintana... was just trying to keep things moving along.Quote:
Originally Posted by killersheepI'd like to be the one to put forward motions in my division. I mean yes we got the same result, but I didn't get to vote on this one because I missed seeing it.Quote:
Originally Posted by Galaxy
I'm going to try something different with this weeks votes to help everyone keep up with the votes
Also can we please try to put all polls up for the week by the end of Tuesday night, just to keep from spilling into the next weeks votes (it also makes it easier to post updates based on the weeks votes. Most major fights end on a Saturday night so from then until the end of Tuesday night we have to put votes for that week just ended...
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...eavyweight.jpg
How far should Clinton Woods (currently #7) drop after losing to Tavoris Cloud? 1-3 spots?
I vote 3 spots
Should Victor Ramirez remain in the pool at Cruiser after losing a close, hard fought decision to our 4th ranked Marco Huck?
I vote that he is removed, although it was a close fight I think he should have to earn his way back
I say 3 spots only because I think he is basically done on the elite level...I hope he goes home and fights a few more bouts and retires with some wins he deserves it but as a serious contender I think he is done...3 spots until someone else moves up then the pool with him
Remove him from the pool there are other guys waiting to jump up
I voted two spots because he hung in there even though he clearly lost. We reserved the 3 spots option for when someone was completely blown out. He did land some meaningful punches, and saw the final bell.
Remove him, I do have a feeling he'll be back though.
3 for me.
I'm going to use my manager vote this month to adjust Sam Peter to drop. Within our rules, I can only make him drop one spot which will put Juan Carlos Gomez ahead of him. (hint I will do this again next month.)
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...eavyweight.jpg
Demote Peter, Gomez performed better against Vitali & Peter also has the loss to Chambers as well
Victor Emilio Ramirez is removed from pool, after losing to Marco Huck. By a vote of 6-1
Clinton Woods drops 3 spots to 10th. By a vote of 4-3
Bump
Definitely.Good call Killer...drop him 3 if I could
With Clinton Woods announcing his retirement following his loss to Tavoris Cloud, who should fill the vacancy his spot leaves?
EDIT: Can a MOD move this thread to the OFFICIAL RATINGS board? I've been a dunce & posted it in the wrong place.
Roy deserves a spot ;)
I voted for RJJ it was close to be honest between him and Braehmer.
Same, although I was thinking about Mack as well.Quote:
Originally Posted by killersheep
I would have voted for Mack if he had a more credible last opponent.Quote:
Originally Posted by JazMerkinSame, although I was thinking about Mack as well.Quote:
Originally Posted by killersheep
Voted for vacant.Let em fight it out.
I was leaning towards leaving it vacant, but had we known Woods was going to retire he would have been dropped altogether & Jones would have kept his ranking, so I say Roy sneaks back inQuote:
Originally Posted by Spicoli
Roy Jones Jr takes the 10th spot by a vote of 3 - 1
Sam Peter is demoted 1 position by a vote of 6 - 0