Printable View
Fight of the Year - Pacquiao vs. Marquez 4
Round of the Year - Sergio Matinez vs. Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. round 12
Prospect of the Year - David Price
KO of the Year - Marquez KO Pacquiao
Fighter of the Year - Nonito Donaire
I haven't seen who he voted for trainer of the year. Do you agree or disagree with these choices?
Note - Normally, CutmeMick presents our very own Saddo awards following a vote but for some reason this hasn't happened this year. Clearly we can't get the staff!
Id say there pretty sound choices mate. Cant disagree with much on there. Its hard to disagree with big Dan as hes been in the boxing game alot longer than myself, so his opinion must be respected.
Trainer of the year off the top of my head has to be Robert Garcia. Peace ;)
That is the trainer who you would most want to slap award.Quote:
Originally Posted by paddy448
Dan Rafael is a useless tub of goo, he deserves absolutely no respect imo. Many people who post on this site know more about the sport and are better writers. Having said that all of those picks were pretty straightforward, excepting for the round of the year. Why should it go to Martinez-Chavez Jr, just because Julio had him hurt after getting his ass whipped in all the rounds prior? It was certainly dramatic given that, but in the round itself there was barely any two way action. Off the top of my head I'd say at least a couple rounds in Rios-Alvarado were much better, or in fact the last round of Pac-Marquez as Manny was knocked out in the dying seconds after having it in the bag. The first round of that special FNF a while ago between Kim and Beltran was also great.
*why? they guy is extremily appoachable and trains kids on a daily basis. A friend of mine is frineds with him... i hear he's a total stand up guy.Quote:
Originally Posted by MasterThat is the trainer who you would most want to slap award.Quote:
Originally Posted by paddy448
I'm not crazy about Dan Rafeal and his Klitschko nut hugging either. But, he does break stories first and is a good reporter, if not a bias snobbish analyst.Quote:
Originally Posted by p4pking
Yes ! That was round of the year for me. Great round.
Rafael, first name Dan
Smells like peaches
Not from a flan
Needs a plan
The Walrus
Dry like Walnuts
Eeewww
Sorry my mistake I meant Angel, Danny Garcia's dad. Robert is cool, i enjoyed his fights and he was in Donaires corner.Quote:
Originally Posted by bigstinkybug*why? they guy is extremily appoachable and trains kids on a daily basis. A friend of mine is frineds with him... i hear he's a total stand up guy.Quote:
Originally Posted by MasterThat is the trainer who you would most want to slap award.Quote:
Originally Posted by paddy448
dan rafael gets any stories he gets because he works for espn. Not because he is a good reporter.Quote:
Originally Posted by HulkI'm not crazy about Dan Rafeal and his Klitschko nut hugging either. But, he does break stories first and is a good reporter, if not a bias snobbish analyst.Quote:
Originally Posted by p4pking
Yes ! That was round of the year for me. Great round.
He doesn't go to any gyms to see fighters spar. He has no idea about tactics and small technical things that many writers have picked up by taking time to be in the gyms and see guys spar.
He doesn't have any clue about boxing history. To him boxing began in full in the mid 1970s in general and his knowledge of boxing before the mid 90s is rather substandard.
Have you ever read the Monday Scorecard? On at least three occasions over the years I have read the scorecard and it says fighter A deserved to win the fight OR fighter A was robbed. Then on his chat on Friday with fans he says the exact opposite. Why? Because he hasn't seen the fights.
I have no problem with him not having seen the fights. But if you haven't seen the fights, you need to cite the source of the write up, as it isn't coming from you.
When the whole PED mess was occuring in May-July of this year, he was passing off information that was obviously coming from other writers as breaking news. Isn't it funny when Gabe Montoya of Maxboxing (who was spending a ton of his time chasing these stories) tweets a link to a breaking story (that isn't seen anywhere else), that Fat Dan then has a blog saying basically the same thing is breaking news within 2 hours.
Never have met the man but he is an asshole in his chats and on twitter. He loves to rate the water pressure when he goes to other cities for fights. I told him on twitter that I meant no offense, but he needed to take better care of himself, lose some weight, and water pressure wouldn't be that big an issue. He blocked me.
I don't agree, with Sergio Matinez vs. Julio Cesar Chavez Jr. round 12 being "Round of the Year", but other then that, I agree with Fat Dan.Quote:
Originally Posted by bzkfn
Hey I don't like the fucker either, I was just trying to be positive about the fat shit cat !Quote:
Originally Posted by captainanddewdan rafael gets any stories he gets because he works for espn. Not because he is a good reporter.Quote:
Originally Posted by HulkI'm not crazy about Dan Rafeal and his Klitschko nut hugging either. But, he does break stories first and is a good reporter, if not a bias snobbish analyst.Quote:
Originally Posted by p4pking
Yes ! That was round of the year for me. Great round.
He doesn't go to any gyms to see fighters spar. He has no idea about tactics and small technical things that many writers have picked up by taking time to be in the gyms and see guys spar.
He doesn't have any clue about boxing history. To him boxing began in full in the mid 1970s in general and his knowledge of boxing before the mid 90s is rather substandard.
Have you ever read the Monday Scorecard? On at least three occasions over the years I have read the scorecard and it says fighter A deserved to win the fight OR fighter A was robbed. Then on his chat on Friday with fans he says the exact opposite. Why? Because he hasn't seen the fights.
I have no problem with him not having seen the fights. But if you haven't seen the fights, you need to cite the source of the write up, as it isn't coming from you.
When the whole PED mess was occuring in May-July of this year, he was passing off information that was obviously coming from other writers as breaking news. Isn't it funny when Gabe Montoya of Maxboxing (who was spending a ton of his time chasing these stories) tweets a link to a breaking story (that isn't seen anywhere else), that Fat Dan then has a blog saying basically the same thing is breaking news within 2 hours.
Never have met the man but he is an asshole in his chats and on twitter. He loves to rate the water pressure when he goes to other cities for fights. I told him on twitter that I meant no offense, but he needed to take better care of himself, lose some weight, and water pressure wouldn't be that big an issue. He blocked me.
Your one man jihad against him is hilarious, but sounds pretty warranted if all you say is true. ;D
The guy sounds like a lazy, thieving, miserable fat slob.
Have never thought much of him either. Always struck me as a soap reporter. He gets cred cause he works for ESPN.Quote:
Originally Posted by p4pking
Having said that I'd give Manny/Marquez ko of the year and probably Rios/Alvarado foty. Salido/Lopez 2 rd 9 roty and I dont really like the way the mainstream anoints Donaire fighter of the year. It almost seems fixed as he's an Hbo/Arum guy. I also think Shields should get the trainer of the year.
I always find myself on the wrong side of something, that's life I guess. I like Dan Rafael and I don't see anything wrong with his picks.Quote:
Originally Posted by p4pking
The last half of the 12th round of the Martinez v Chavez had me out of my seat, it was truely gripping. Pac-Marquez 4's last round did not affect me like that, all the excitiment of that round was in the last seconds of the round.
I like Rafael's pick for round of the year.
Trainer of the Year has to go to Rob McCracken.
It's easy to overlook him because Carl was already a world class fighter, but he turned into a scarry KO artist this year and you have to say that this must and can really only be attributed to the training.
Also coached GB Olympic team to 3 golds ;-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Vendettos
Yupp, for which he gained an MBE, but I don't believe Dan's choices include amateur achievements.Quote:
Originally Posted by BIG HAlso coached GB Olympic team to 3 golds ;-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Vendettos
Fuck Dan Rafael :-)Quote:
Originally Posted by VendettosYupp, for which he gained an MBE, but I don't believe Dan's choices include amateur achievements.Quote:
Originally Posted by BIG HAlso coached GB Olympic team to 3 golds ;-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Vendettos
Never a truer spoken sentence.Quote:
Originally Posted by BIG HFuck Dan Rafael :-)Quote:
Originally Posted by VendettosYupp, for which he gained an MBE, but I don't believe Dan's choices include amateur achievements.Quote:
Originally Posted by BIG HAlso coached GB Olympic team to 3 golds ;-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Vendettos
Fight of the year has to Alvarado - Rios for me