My P4P top 5 list!

1. Lomanchenko
2. Crawford
3. GGG
4. Canelo
5. Joshua/Wilder tied

About time we have a heavyweight in the top 5 P4P list after Wlad.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

You are back with making a whole bunch of ridiculous threads

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Crawford
Loma
after that it's like trying to order for 3 passengers in the drive thru. Safe to say it doesn't involve Wilder ;D.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Heavyweights are not allowed in the P4P list.

It’s not possible for Loma to be above Crawford.

Drug cheat Canelo?

GGG should be in the top 2.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Where is Spence?:confused:

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

No BJS??? Bullshit

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by holmcall

Where is Spence?:confused:

I honestly think that Spence beats Canelo at 154. He is definitely higher for me. I have always said that Canelo is a fringe p4p fighter. I’m not sure if he is top 10 or not. I more lean not.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

1. Lomanchenko
2. Crawford
3. GGG
4. Canelo
5. Joshua/Wilder tied

About time we have a heavyweight in the top 5 P4P list after Wlad.

Good list, except Wilder is nowhere near even the top 25.

And Usyk, Spence or Kovalev should replace Canelo if he loses to Golovkin, or if the fight is off due to him being suspended.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Thanks for mentioning Inoue, Usyk and Wangek. I'd also add Mikey.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alpha

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Thanks for mentioning Inoue, Usyk and Wangek. I'd also add Mikey.

Haha. I totally forgot Mikey. He is in the first group that is definitely better. I knew I would forget people.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Lomachenko and Crawford definately.

But also Mikey García

and Rigondeaux (I'd place him just below Lomachenko and Crawford merely because he does get knocked down sometimes).

Wilder shouldn't be there at all.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by holmcall

Where is Spence?:confused:

Spence is in my bottom 6-10. Between 6 and 8 depending on how some feel about Manny and Jacobs and Kovalev and the Usyk guy.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alpha

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Thanks for mentioning Inoue, Usyk and Wangek. I'd also add Mikey.

Haha. I totally forgot Mikey. He is in the first group that is definitely better. I knew I would forget people.

Are you saying Mikey can beat Crawford or Loma or Davis? I didn't like his performance against Broner. Yea, he won sound. But he did not dominate.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alpha

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Thanks for mentioning Inoue, Usyk and Wangek. I'd also add Mikey.

Haha. I totally forgot Mikey. He is in the first group that is definitely better. I knew I would forget people.

Are you saying Mikey can beat Crawford or Loma or Davis? I didn't like his performance against Broner. Yea, he won sound. But he did not dominate.

Crawford and Loma are #1 and 2 but I think he beats Loma but not Crawford because of size. He destroys Davis if you mean Gervonta Davis. And he dominated Broner. He easily won every round.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alpha

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Thanks for mentioning Inoue, Usyk and Wangek. I'd also add Mikey.

Haha. I totally forgot Mikey. He is in the first group that is definitely better. I knew I would forget people.

Are you saying Mikey can beat Crawford or Loma or Davis? I didn't like his performance against Broner. Yea, he won sound. But he did not dominate.

Crawford and Loma are #1 and 2 but I think he beats Loma but not Crawford because of size. He destroys Davis if you mean Gervonta Davis. And he dominated Broner. He easily won every round.

Plus he holds a win over the guy that beat Loma. Yep Davis gets wrecked by Mikey, Loma fight could go either way, Crawford maybe to big now but they did fight as amateurs.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alpha

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Thanks for mentioning Inoue, Usyk and Wangek. I'd also add Mikey.

Haha. I totally forgot Mikey. He is in the first group that is definitely better. I knew I would forget people.

Are you saying Mikey can beat Crawford or Loma or Davis? I didn't like his performance against Broner. Yea, he won sound. But he did not dominate.

Crawford and Loma are #1 and 2 but I think he beats Loma but not Crawford because of size. He destroys Davis if you mean Gervonta Davis. And he dominated Broner. He easily won every round.

I mean, he won sound. But compared to when Broner fought Maidana, Maidana dominated him from second to second. Mikey just won soundly and in good style.

Compare when Floyd beat Maidana both times= the first was a sound win. The second was a domination.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alpha

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Thanks for mentioning Inoue, Usyk and Wangek. I'd also add Mikey.

Haha. I totally forgot Mikey. He is in the first group that is definitely better. I knew I would forget people.

Are you saying Mikey can beat Crawford or Loma or Davis? I didn't like his performance against Broner. Yea, he won sound. But he did not dominate.

Crawford and Loma are #1 and 2 but I think he beats Loma but not Crawford because of size. He destroys Davis if you mean Gervonta Davis. And he dominated Broner. He easily won every round.

I mean, he won sound. But compared to when Broner fought Maidana, Maidana dominated him from second to second. Mikey just won soundly and in good style.

Compare when Floyd beat Maidana both times= the first was a sound win. The second was a domination.

You’re remembering wrong. Broner won some rounds against Maidana. Maidana was just bigger and hit harder and had an aggressive style. Mikey won every round against Broner and Broner wouldn’t fight back because he was scared.

Re: My P4P top 5 list!

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by ykdadamaja

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alpha

Quote:

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

Crawford, Loma, GGG, Kovalev, Spence, Wagnek, Usyk are all clearly better than Canelo IMO. Then you have this list who I think have a definite argument to claim they are better:

Inuoe, Bivol, Santa Cruz, Charlo Bros, Estrada, Chocolatito (depending on his comeback), and Thurman.

I know there are some I missed but I think there are easily at least five more people that at least have a decent argument to say they are better. I mean, Jacobs arguably beat GGG while Canelo did well but definitely didn’t win. Again, Canelo potentially falls outside top five in his own weight class.

Thanks for mentioning Inoue, Usyk and Wangek. I'd also add Mikey.

Haha. I totally forgot Mikey. He is in the first group that is definitely better. I knew I would forget people.

Are you saying Mikey can beat Crawford or Loma or Davis? I didn't like his performance against Broner. Yea, he won sound. But he did not dominate.

Crawford and Loma are #1 and 2 but I think he beats Loma but not Crawford because of size. He destroys Davis if you mean Gervonta Davis. And he dominated Broner. He easily won every round.

I mean, he won sound. But compared to when Broner fought Maidana, Maidana dominated him from second to second. Mikey just won soundly and in good style.

Compare when Floyd beat Maidana both times= the first was a sound win. The second was a domination.

You’re remembering wrong. Broner won some rounds against Maidana. Maidana was just bigger and hit harder and had an aggressive style. Mikey won every round against Broner and Broner wouldn’t fight back because he was scared.

Floyd struggled against Maidana too.