http://www.petitiononline.com/PBFDQ/petition.html
YOU KNOW PBF SHOULD HAVE BEEN DQd
http://www.boxingtalk.com/video/may_...fight_1405.asx
Printable View
http://www.petitiononline.com/PBFDQ/petition.html
YOU KNOW PBF SHOULD HAVE BEEN DQd
http://www.boxingtalk.com/video/may_...fight_1405.asx
You have my name Mr King; so can you give me that £500k job for DKP in Britain now? ;)
sorry, ONLY IN AMERICA ;)
;D
Havn't seen it yet so can't really comment but to be fair it didn't have anything to do with Floyd so it would be a harsh way for him to lose his unbeaten record.
I'm just glad that for a change this debacle didn't happen in a heavyweight world title fight ::**
Shat I'd be petitioning for that knockdown to have been scored for Judah. I mean yeah, it was BS Roger jumpin in there like that, had Yoel pulled that shat he woulda gotten Judah DQ'd immediately. But Floyd is HBO's new golden boy. That was a damn knockdown though, and not countin it screwed Judah in the end. Oh one mo thing, those two fukhead judges who had it 117-111 and especially 119-109 oughta be banned from ever judging another fight period.
i agree, and i was pissed mayweather, the "defensive marvel" that he is, needed to wear winnings, and STILL got dropped
You now have my signature ;D
It pissed me off just as much that the ref turned a blind eye to a genuine knockdown
Oh Floyd was scared during that fight. Particularly in the early rounds, you could just see the fear in his eyes. He fought defenseivley the whole night. Lil beotch that he is. He did win a lot of middle rounds though, and ultimately the fight, but like I been sayin not scorin that Knockdown really screwed Judah.Quote:
Originally Posted by SalTheButcher
I Signed it I personally didn't see the fight but from what i heard if that was any other boxer than PBF they would have been DQed but no. >:mad
LOL, walked into that one! [click] :jabbing:Quote:
Originally Posted by SalTheButcher
This petition is now up in maxboxing as well ;)
NICEQuote:
Originally Posted by ross
:coolclick:
Thanks for the link Sal. I have been searching for this site for a year or two now.Quote:
Originally Posted by SalTheButcher
IMO Floyds corner had a right to be pissed, judah intentionally low blowed floyd so that he could get a breather. Dont go acting like judah is innocent when he did something worse.
a low blow is NOT worse then inciting a riot
judah was punched on top of the head while going for a body shot. not intentional imo. His follow up punch was exactly that... a follow up punch. you might as well get mad at PBF punching Gatti while he was talking to the ref if you wanna follow that logic. If this fight did anything, it proved to me that PBF is far from unbeatable and that his corner is a bunch of thugs. Did hattons corner do that against Kostya? No. Did Kostya's corner do that against hatton after Ricky knocked his nuggets out his mouth? no. DQ. Rematch. Zab wins early.
beautifull point there, he WAS hit while throwing the shot that eventually landed as a low blow, and that could have EASILY changed the trajectory of wherever it was supposed to go
CC :)
Mayweather displayed remarkable talent and composure to systematically outclassed and outboxed Zab. During the melee he remained calm, while Zab resorted to his uncontrolled and expected behavior. The only person should have been disqualified is Roger, which they did, and suspended from training, and which they did.
This is a pathetic petition and should be removed. I should start a petition to remove this stupid petition. Whoever started or signed this petition is obviously blinded by the chicken dude. No boxing sense.
>:madQuote:
Originally Posted by mrtko
do you not know the rules of boxing sir?
http://sports.espn.go.com/sports/box...ory?id=2402780
Ratner said Nevada rules don't call for an immediate disqualification.
"I read the rule with my attorney general and, to paraphrase it, it says a referee 'may' disqualify a fighter if someone from his corner enters the ring," Ratner said. "There is no automatic disqualification. It may be that way in some states, but the rule is not written like that in the Nevada statutes. Richard could have disqualified him, but he and I and my commissioners talked about it and he was not disqualified.
"There could have been points deducted because of Zab's low blow and the blow behind the head. You could have had a double disqualification because of the other side [Yoel Judah] also coming into the ring and throwing punches. But if we did that, you might have had a full-scale problem in the arena."
Steele, a veteran referee who has seen his share of ring controversies, said he didn't feel a disqualification was warranted.
"Disqualification is at our discretion and we didn't want to see the fight end like that," he said. "The fighters didn't do anything to get disqualified, and you have to think about the sport and the fans. I think we did a good job. We got the situation under control and we got the fight to its natural conclusion, and we let the fans get their money's worth."
Hey sal the butcher,Quote:
Originally Posted by SalTheButcher
do you know the rules of boxing? You do?
good points but you missed a few thingsQuote:
Originally Posted by mrtko
A) When you step into the ring if you're not a boxer, you are fair game since it is protect yourself at all times, which means from anyone.
B) If it IS true that Roger choked Zab, as much as I hate Don King's influence on things, he will win the case. What about that rule about an ungloved person attacking the boxer during or in the flow of the boxing match. if Roger choked Zab then Don will win this case as much as I hate Don King
;)
According to Bob Arum, the Nevada commision had the OPTION to DQ PBF. They elected not to, and I'm glad. Roger's jumping in the ring did not affect the fight.
Sorry, but Don King ain't winning sh@# here. Roger could have shanked Judah and the commission wouldn't overturn the victory. The only thing that will overturn a win is a positive drug test. All you have to know is the history of boxing to figure that out.Quote:
Originally Posted by Starr
didn't Don King do this before?
the Meldrick Taylor Cesar Chavez fight?
he said "There is no controversy because steele had the second option of disqualifying Taylor's corner for getting in the ring or on the apron" or something like that?
I read the real reason why this decision will never be overturned. The millions of dollars that were bet on PBF and won by bettor's has already been paid.
the 119-109 scorecard ensured that.
BABABOOEY what did you think of that scorecard?
I ain't signing SH__!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
hmmmm.... If Mayweather has a loss on his record, by disqualification.
The parrallels to Roy Jones' career are astounding. :detective:
119-109 was incorrect. Judah clearly won rds 1,2 and 4. He possibly won rd 12.
At worst the score shoulda been 116-112.
The scorecard simply shows the judges approval for Mayweather's performance and discontent with Zab. This is to say that this was not even a close fight. The score just shows that we have a clear winner. Good fight though.Quote:
Originally Posted by Starr
Say what you will, 119-109 was wrong. The fight was not that much of a blowout. Isnt 119-109 a 10 rds to 2 split? Thats wrong.
This was like Floyd's Montell Griffin fight a guy who stylistically gave him problems in a way? And I think if Jones hadn't been DQ'd the outcome would have been Jones dominating the other rounds to a decision and he would have tied Marciano's 49-0 record at Heavyweight. But think of it this way, if Jones hadn't been robbed in the Olympics, if Jones hadn't been DQ'd against Griffin, would he still have been, Roy Jones?Quote:
Originally Posted by Gyrokai
The scorecard simply shows mrtko's approval for 119 Mayweather's performance and discontent with answering the question. Good fight though. ;DQuote:
Originally Posted by mrtko
Yes. That lkoss to Griffin took nothing away from Roy, and he proved it in the rematch. But we dont need to worry about that kind of loss here. The commission aint overturning a thing about last night and we all know it.
Good win for PBF.
Maybe not. :cwm15:Quote:
Originally Posted by Starr
how about an intentional low blow followed by an intentional punch to the back of the head?Quote:
Originally Posted by SalTheButcher
worse then trampled innocents?Quote:
Originally Posted by shza
violence
[attachment deleted by admin]
Do you think that him wearing winning gloves had an effect on the outcome? If anything him wearing those gloves helped judah. Winning gloves are like pillows. So pbf wore pillows and zab wore punchers gloves. Who looked the more worst for wear?ZabQuote:
Originally Posted by SalTheButcher
About this riot and dq. Gimme a break. First off zab hit him low on purpose. Anyone looking at the tape could cleary see zab looking down at pbfs lower body then him hit him low and then rabbited punched him.Its true that roger shouldn't have came in the ring. That was stupid but it was yoel who threw the first punch. And yes roger did choke zab but only after zab tried to sneak him. Zab wasn't actin tough till his pops came in and when roger was distracted zab tried to get a cheap shot and he got choked up for his troubles.Like I said roger was wrong for coming in but to be honest the judah camp played a big part in that situation. If you wanna called it a no contest fine but what would a dq do for judah. The win would be B.S, the belt already was B.S. Anyway you look at it judah is going back to fighting contenders till he proves himself. Just get over it