Hypothetical - Judah v. Hatton at 140

[killersheep]

I know I'm gonna get a lot of shit for this but, I think this would be a decent match up style-wise I'd watch it................

[bigragu]

I know I'm gonna get a lot of S*** for this but, I think this would be a decent match up style-wise I'd watch it................

if it's in the USA I think Judah has a tremendous shot at beating Hatton...In Britian I think Hatton would be allowed to roughhouse way too much and you know Judah can't hold it together when the going gets tough.

[Galaxy]

Judah comes in at the best he can be he takes a decision, anything less & he gets KTFO!!!

[killersheep]

I think going back down to 140 is the best decision either of these guys can make, They would be great for matchin up against JLC and D-hop and Witter and Maussa.

[TyBuff]

I think Hatton would wear Zab out. Once Judah gets a taste of a few of Hattons body shots he will start running trying to avoid them like the plague. Hatton by decision.

[Cortez The Killer]

I hate this one cause I think Judah has loads more talent than Hatton, but I see Hatton winning by KO.

I'm not even sure if it would be that good of a match up. I'm not sure how much I like Hatton, but I feel he would be way too much for Judah to handle. The questionably weak mentality of Judah would crumble under Hatton's pressure!

[Wacko3205]

I hate this one cause I think Judah has loads more talent than Hatton, but I see Hatton winning by KO.

I'm not even sure if it would be that good of a match up. I'm not sure how much I like Hatton, but I feel he would be way too much for Judah to handle. The questionably weak mentality of Judah would crumble under Hatton's pressure!

Agreed.

[p4pking]

I hate this one cause I think Judah has loads more talent than Hatton, but I see Hatton winning by KO.

I'm not even sure if it would be that good of a match up. I'm not sure how much I like Hatton, but I feel he would be way too much for Judah to handle. The questionably weak mentality of Judah would crumble under Hatton's pressure!

Agreed.

Yea I will agree for the most part, but I think Judah would have a better shot than you give him credit for.. I don't agree with Hatton being way to much to handle, Judah is much faster and I believe would hit harder, he would have a chance to score and early KO or stoppage.. But if the fight got tough and past 5 or 6 I agree Judah would crumble.

[CutMeMick]

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ......

Hatton KO inside of 4 rds.

[amat]

Guy has talent, but Zab Judah is not a smart enough fighter to beat Ricky Hatton. Plain and simple. Hatton stoppage.

[Violent Bob]

To repeat what others have said--if Judah can catch Ricky early on, he could win by KO or cuts stoppage. He'd win at least 4 out of the first 6 rounds no matter what. If he couldn't end it--or significantly slow down Hatton--in those rounds, he'd likely give up and give up a lot of later rounds, and possibly get KO'd. So either guy could win by some kind of stoppage--Zab early or Hatton late. But if it went to the cards, I think it's a very close fight (Zab, as the more skilled boxer, dominates early and fades late).

[BrooklyniteQueen]

Judah. Hatton can't fight southpaws very well. And Judah hits harder then Magee and Collazo.

[El Gamo]

Judah. Hatton can't fight southpaws very well. And Judah hits harder then Magee and Collazo.

Collazo had more natural power,I don't know how it works but I think Hatton could take Judah's shots. He took Tszyu's and Tszyu probably hits harder than Collazo too,it's the natural strength and natural weight factor. Judah can't take preussre,at 140,Hatton is a muachine,he would smother Judah,and eventually KO him,by banging his body,Hatton TKO/KO 8 at the latest. If it is stateside,Hatton again,1 round later.

[BrooklyniteQueen]

Judah. Hatton can't fight southpaws very well. And Judah hits harder then Magee and Collazo.

Collazo had more natural power,I don't know how it works but I think Hatton could take Judah's shots. He took Tszyu's and Tszyu probably hits harder than Collazo too,it's the natural strength and natural weight factor. Judah can't take preussre,at 140,Hatton is a muachine,he would smother Judah,and eventually KO him,by banging his body,Hatton TKO/KO 8 at the latest. If it is stateside,Hatton again,1 round later.

I don't think Hatton has the one punch power to knock out Judah, and I think that Judah's shots would wear on Hatton as well. I don't think it matters he went through Tszyu's shots. Different leverage and everything else. A fighter can not be hurt by a bigger puncher and be out on his feet by a lighter puncher in my opinion. So I don't think you can compare two punchers like that. After all Joe Morales nearly knocked Juarez out and Barerra never had him hurt.

[El Gamo]

MAB scenario is a different weight,no relevance. There maybe balance issues with punching power etc but whichever way you look at it,Tszyu was and probably now hits harder than anyone at 140 and Hatton took it. I didn't say one shots(or didn't mean to),he would wear Zab out,there's no way if a lion like Kostya cannot take the punishment dished out by Hatton that a mentally unstable Zab can. He'll look good for a few rounds,then Hatton will take over. Zab can't take pressure,Hatton has too much.And Zab does not have one punch power imo. How do you propose he wins?