Top of division

[killersheep]

Who do you think is the champ of each division?

here's my list

200+: Wladimir Klitschko
200: David Haye
175: Joe Calzaghe
168: Mikkel Kessler
160: Kelly Pavlik
154: Vernon Forrest
147: Miguel Cotto
140: Ricky Hatton
135: Nate Campbell
130: Manny Pacquiao
126: Jorge Linares
122: Israel Vazquez
118: Hozumi Hasegawa
115: Cristian Mijares
112: Takefumi Sakata
108: Ulises Solis
105: Yutaka Niida

That should get some arguments going.

I should clarify. If you were to hand out fresh titles to whomever you
thought was the man in each division who would it be?

total
-------------------------------
200+: Wladimir Klitschko - 7 votes
-------------------------------
200: David Haye - 4 votes
Firat Arlsan - 1 vote
Jean Marc Mormeck - 1 vote
Steve Cunningham - 1 vote
-------------------------------
175: Joe Calzaghe - 6 votes
Bernard Hopkins - 1 vote
-------------------------------
168: Mikkel Kessler - 2 votes
Lucien Bute - 2 votes
Joe Calzaghe - 3 votes
-------------------------------
160: Kelly Pavlik - 7 votes
-------------------------------
154: Oscar de la Hoya - 2 votes
Vernon Forrest - 4 votes
-------------------------------
147: Floyd Mayweather Jr. - 5 votes
Miguel Cotto - 2 votes
-------------------------------
140: Ricky Hatton - 7 votes
-------------------------------
135: Nate Campbell - 3 votes
Juan Diaz - 1 vote
Joel Casamayor - 2 votes
David Diaz - 1 vote
-------------------------------
130: Manny Pacqiuao - 6 votes
Juan Manuel Marquez - 1 vote
-------------------------------
126: Jorge Linares - 5 votes
Chris John - 2 votes
-------------------------------
122: Israel Vazquez - 5 votes
Daniel Ponce de Leon - 1 vote
-------------------------------
118: Hozumi Hasegawa - 5 votes
-------------------------------
115: Cristian Mijares - 5 votes
-------------------------------
112: Takefumi Sakata - 4 votes
Nonito Donaire - 2 votes
-------------------------------
108: Ulises Solis - 2 votes
Ivan Calderon - 3 votes
-------------------------------
105: Yutaka Niida - 5 votes

[Phil]

heavy - Wlad
Cruiser - not including Haye as he's gone Heavy, tough one maybe
Mormeck
Light Heavy - Hopkins
S Middle - Calzaghe
Middle - Pavlik
L Middle - Forrest
Welter - Floyd
L welter - Hatton
Lightweigh - Casamayor
S feather - Pac
Feather - Chris John
Super Bantam - Ponce de Leon!

[leftylee]

Who do you think is the champ of each division?

here's my list

200+: Wladimir Klitschko
200: David Haye
175: Joe Calzaghe
168: Mikkel Kessler
160: Kelly Pavlik
154: Vernon Forrest
147: Miguel Cotto
140: Ricky Hatton
135: Nate Campbell
130: Manny Pacquiao
126: Jorge Linares
122: Israel Vazquez
118: Hozumi Hasegawa
115: Cristian Mijares
112: Takefumi Sakata
108: Ulises Solis
105: Yutaka Niida

That should get some arguments going.

I totally agree except Ivan Calderon should be in there definitely IMO.

[:::PSL:::]

At 112, it should be Nonito Donaire.

[:::PSL:::]

heavy - Wlad
Cruiser - not including Haye as he's gone Heavy, tough one maybe
Mormeck
Light Heavy - Hopkins
S Middle - Calzaghe
Middle - Pavlik
L Middle - Forrest
Welter - Floyd
L welter - Hatton
Lightweigh - Casamayor
S feather - Pac
Feather - Chris John
Super Bantam - Ponce de Leon!

Feather should be Guerrero or Linares. But difinitely not CJ imo.

[killersheep]

Who do you think is the champ of each division?

here's my list

200+: Wladimir Klitschko
200: David Haye
175: Joe Calzaghe
168: Mikkel Kessler
160: Kelly Pavlik
154: Vernon Forrest
147: Miguel Cotto
140: Ricky Hatton
135: Nate Campbell
130: Manny Pacquiao
126: Jorge Linares
122: Israel Vazquez
118: Hozumi Hasegawa
115: Cristian Mijares
112: Takefumi Sakata
108: Ulises Solis
105: Yutaka Niida

That should get some arguments going.

I totally agree except Ivan Calderon should be in there definitely IMO.

Solis has done more than Calderon at 108 IMO. I would say Calderon is closing in if he keeps up with his quality wins.

[killersheep]

At 112, it should be Nonito Donaire.

I'm sticking with Sakata, I would love to see the two of them fight.

[Violent Demise]

It should be Steve Cunningham at 200 (Haye has already left), Lucian Bute at 168 (Kessler coming off a loss), Floyd Mayweather at 147 and Joel Casamayor at 135. Everything else is fine

[Phil]

heavy - Wlad
Cruiser - not including Haye as he's gone Heavy, tough one maybe
Mormeck
Light Heavy - Hopkins
S Middle - Calzaghe
Middle - Pavlik
L Middle - Forrest
Welter - Floyd
L welter - Hatton
Lightweigh - Casamayor
S feather - Pac
Feather - Chris John
Super Bantam - Ponce de Leon!

Feather should be Guerrero or Linares. But difinitely not CJ imo.

to be honest I don't really know that much about Guerrero or Linares, both there records look fairly sound though, I hoping CJ wins his next fight though, hopefully he'll fight Valero then.

[killersheep]

heavy - Wlad
Cruiser - not including Haye as he's gone Heavy, tough one maybe
Mormeck
Light Heavy - Hopkins
S Middle - Calzaghe
Middle - Pavlik
L Middle - Forrest
Welter - Floyd
L welter - Hatton
Lightweigh - Casamayor
S feather - Pac
Feather - Chris John
Super Bantam - Ponce de Leon!

Feather should be Guerrero or Linares. But difinitely not CJ imo.

to be honest I don't really know that much about Guerrero or Linares, both there records look fairly sound though, I hoping CJ wins his next fight though, hopefully he'll fight Valero then.

Linares is awesome you should check him out on youtube he was landing 6 punch combos against Oscar Larios, simply amazing.

[Phil]

Feather should be Guerrero or Linares. But difinitely not CJ imo.

to be honest I don't really know that much about Guerrero or Linares, both there records look fairly sound though, I hoping CJ wins his next fight though, hopefully he'll fight Valero then.

Linares is awesome you should check him out on youtube he was landing 6 punch combos against Oscar Larios, simply amazing.

cheers man, will do!

[CutMeMick]

This is how I see it...

HW: Vacant
CW: Vacant
LHW: Joe
SMW: Joe
MW: Pavlik
LMW: Vacant
WW: PBF
LWW: Hatton
LW: Joel
SFW: Pac
FW: Vacant
SBW: Izzy
BW: Vacant
SFlyW: Vacant
FLYw: Vacant
LFW: Ivan
MinW: Vacant

[killersheep]

This is how I see it...

HW: Vacant
CW: Vacant
LHW: Joe
SMW: Joe
MW: Pavlik
LMW: Vacant
WW: PBF
LWW: Hatton
LW: Joel
SFW: Pac
FW: Vacant
SBW: Izzy
BW: Vacant
SFlyW: Vacant
FLYw: Vacant
LFW: Ivan
MinW: Vacant

I didn't intend for this to be lineal
Who's the man in each division in your opinion.

[Kev]

It should be Steve Cunningham at 200 (Haye has already left), Lucian Bute at 168 (Kessler coming off a loss), Floyd Mayweather at 147 and Joel Casamayor at 135. Everything else is fine

By this logic then Hatton shouldn't be champ at 140.

Not disagreeing with you, I like your logic.

[ono]

It should be Steve Cunningham at 200 (Haye has already left), Lucian Bute at 168 (Kessler coming off a loss), Floyd Mayweather at 147 and Joel Casamayor at 135. Everything else is fine

By this logic then Hatton shouldn't be champ at 140.

Not disagreeing with you, I like your logic.

Don't quite understand. Hatton lost at 147