P4P

[neverbeendown]

I feel like I have to reconsider my top twelve fighters on a weekly basis these days, but here's my current crop.

1.) Floyd M
2.) Winky W
3.) Marco B
4.) Ricky Hatton
5.) Rafael M
6.) Jorge A
7.) Antonio T
8.) Joe C
9.) Jermaine T
10.)Manny P
11.) Jose Luis C
12.) Antonio M
Almost there
13.) Juan Diaz
14.) Miguel Cotto
15.) James Toney

[briggs]

miguel cotto will be up near the top in a few more years i reckon.classy fighter.

[albsur2006]

Here's mine:
1.) PBF
2.) Winky
3.) Manny Pacquiao (I don't see how anyone in their right mind could put MAB ahead of Pac)
4.) JoeCal
5.) Taylor
6.) Tarver
7.) Hatton
8.) Jose Luis Castillo
9.) MAB
10.) R. Marquez
11.) Corrales
12.) Calderon
Almost there
13.) Arce
14.) Hopkins
15.) Tszyu
[/quote]

[briggs]

even though kostya is past his prime,if he trains really hard like we know he can he can still be a very dangerous boxer to come up against.

[bgordon]

1.) PBF
2.) Pacquiao
3.) Barrera
4.) Winky
5.) Hatton
6.) Jose Luis Castillo
7.) Calzaghe
8.) R. Marquez
9.) Tarver
10.) Taylor
honorable mention:
Corrales, M. Castillo, Morales, Raheem, JM Marquez, Chris John, Wonjongkam, Arce, Cotto, Margarito, Sturm

[albsur2006]

What has Margarito done to be considered P4P?

[gally]

exactly my thoughts.
Margarito may b up there one day but i wouldnt say hes in the top 25 yet.

[B@rr3r@]

1) Winky Wright
2) Pretty Boy Flloyd Mayweather
3) Joe Calzaghe
4) Ricky Hatton
5) Manny Paquaio
6) Marco Antonio Barrera
7) Jose Luis Castillo
Jermain Taylor
9) Oscar Dela Hoya
10) Diego Corrales

[AdamGB]

Whats tarver done to be on any bodys list?

[TyBuff]

Whats tarver done to be on any bodys list?

That is what I was wondering! Who has he beaten? RJJ? Glen Johnson? RJJ was past it in their second fight. He is not a top 15 p4p fighter, I wouldnt rate himtop 20.

[skel1983]

1) Winky Wright
2) Pretty Boy Flloyd Mayweather
3) Joe Calzaghe
4) Ricky Hatton
5) Manny Paquaio
6) Marco Antonio Barrera
7) Jose Luis Castillo
Jermain Taylor
9) Oscar Dela Hoya
10) Diego Corrales

Oscar Delay Hoya

He hasnt looked good for three years, how can he be top 10 he isnt even top 100.

[miron_lang]

1. PBF
2. PACMAN
3. WINKY
4. Castillo
5. Arce
6. Hatton
7. Rafael M
8. MAB
9. Taylor J.
10. Calz

[AdamGB]

Whats tarver done to be on any bodys list?

That is what I was wondering! Who has he beaten? RJJ? Glen Johnson? RJJ was past it in their second fight. He is not a top 15 p4p fighter, I wouldnt rate himtop 20.

As far as I'm conserned he caught an aging RJJ with a lucky punch and then chased after a scared old man the 3rd time they fought...

[Snakey]

Whats tarver done to be on any bodys list?

That is what I was wondering! Who has he beaten? RJJ? Glen Johnson? RJJ was past it in their second fight. He is not a top 15 p4p fighter, I wouldnt rate himtop 20.

As far as I'm conserned he caught an aging RJJ with a lucky punch and then chased after a scared old man the 3rd time they fought...

I agree

[AdamGB]

Back at you snakey... I'll need it... every time I talk about tarver a disgruntled fanboy gives me a sadclick but won't own up to it