James Toney VS Nicolai Valuev

[landmine950]

I posted this becaude Tito BHB said that Toney would beat EVERY heavyweight out there except Klitschko and Peter.
Really who agrees? how would he do against the current WBA champion
The Toney vs Klitschko post was so ridiculous I just had to follow it up with this!

[rvk1331]

toney would have to jump in the air to hit him in the head.

valuev would win.

[p4pking]

I think Toney could pull it off, he'd need to be fairly active but if he could still stick and move for 12 he should win, Valuev isn't as much to deal with as PEter, imo.

[Klitsfan]

I would love to see Toney deal with a fighter who has a 13inch reach advantage and a 14inch height atvantage not to mention he weighs 100lbs more.I would pay to see that fight.

[cockey cockney]

I think Toney could pull it off, he'd need to be fairly active but if he could still stick and move for 12 he should win, Valuev isn't as much to deal with as PEter, imo.

Agreed. I dont think Toney is anything like he used to be but its a testament to how little i rate Valuev. I really think he is that poor and that Toney could get under his SLOOWWWW jab and get in enough punches to decision him.

[SEANIE]

Valuev is slow and predictable, but Toney is a smal heavyweight and would take a one sided beating

[Big_Deuce]

not sure about this one... at first glance the size advantage for the Mongrel would make it seem toney would be laid to rest the same night, however, if toney moved a lot, and went to town on the body, i think he could pull it out.

[SEANIE]

not sure about this one... at first glance the size advantage for the Mongrel would make it seem toney would be laid to rest the same night, however, if toney moved a lot, and went to town on the body, i think he could pull it out.

no toney for years has relied on his natural boxing abiilty to win, but now he's getting on his reflexes are going.

[ICB]

toney would have to jump in the air to hit him in the head.

valuev would win.

lol agreed even though valuev isnt great by any means he is too tall and too strong for toney and he would wear toney out by leaning on him it would take affect imo anyway

[Purist]

Toney can't fight Valuev for another year the WBA is still suspending him.

[SEANIE]

Toney can't fight Valuev for another year the WBA is still suspending him.

I'm sure they could come to some sort of financial settlement to allow the fight to happen.

[BIG H]

Toney can't fight Valuev for another year the WBA is still suspending him.

Yeh that's the reason this fight won't happen

[killersheep]

I honestly think Toney could still chop down Valuev.

[Tito BHB]

Its the hardest fight out there for Toney but i can see him winning...
Nic is far too innactive to take the points...Toney is known for sitting on the ropes to get energy back but he can do that all fight as far as this one is concerned.. Val is asking to be countered and Isnt busy enough to land enougb scoring punches..Thats toneys only down fall..Even toney at his least busy is a threat to scoring against big val.. And if peter can stop toney even after so many rabbit punches..especially with lethal shots like overhand rights..From a mentally heavy puncher.. Then no way valuev stops toney..
Toney can work the body too ..Just watch toney-holyfield and look at how well james uses the left hook to body then head..I see toney emabarrassing and doing big val on points..
Peace

[landmine950]

Well I am amazed.
Had no idea that people thought after the Peter fight that Toney was really still in the mix!
Maskaev i can see, but anyone else.. mind you Briggs looked like sh1t last time out.
I'm sure hoping the big ogre proves all you guys wrong.....VERY wrong.
NOW....no think of a title for my next post...

maybe...."VALUEV worlds best technical boxer".....naa

or "VALUEV the next Ali only better"... maybe.....hey I know

"Valuev....obvious world's greatest P4P!" ya that's it!