Tony still stands by saying he was robbed. (Quotes taken from the post fight)

[SigmaMu]

I just finished watching the post fight press interview.
Tony is bitter. Tony said he was robbed.

Comments by Tony:

"I think some one told Paul Williams that all he had to do was go the distance with me and you will become the new champion."

"Goosen must have a lot power in this business."

He really said some very negative things about Goosen.

More..

"You people saw the fight, he was not landing every shot. I blocked a lot of those punches. Look at my face and look at his. All those lies he said that occured in the gym, never happend. Look at his face. Who is the one that got cut?"

Margarito said he would like a rematch but not under Dan Goosen promotions.

Paul Williams had nothing but nice things to say about Margarito.

[Purist]

I just finished watching the post fight press interview.
Tony is bitter. Tony said he was robbed.

Comments by Tony:

"I think some one told Paul Williams that all he had to do was go the distance with me and you will become the new champion."

"Goosen must have a lot power in this business."

He really said some very negative things about Goosen.

More..

"You people saw the fight, he was not landing every shot. I blocked a lot of those punches. Look at my face and look at his. All those lies he said that occured in the gym, never happend. Look at his face. Who is the one that got cut?"

Margarito said he would like a rematch but not under Dan Goosen promotions.

Paul Williams had nothing but nice things to say about Margarito.

Whats your opinion about it?

[amat]

That's ridiculous. Goosen is a fine promoter and while I still haven't seen it, all indications are that Tony lost. Tony's fans accepted it now it's time for Tony to man the fuck up and not underhand Williams and the event. It was a great card by all accounts, a great show and for him to say that is bullshit.

I hope Arum gets on his ass for that. Arum and Goosen work well with each other all the time.

[SigmaMu]

I just finished watching the post fight press interview.
Tony is bitter. Tony said he was robbed.

Comments by Tony:

"I think some one told Paul Williams that all he had to do was go the distance with me and you will become the new champion."

"Goosen must have a lot power in this business."

He really said some very negative things about Goosen.

More..

"You people saw the fight, he was not landing every shot. I blocked a lot of those punches. Look at my face and look at his. All those lies he said that occured in the gym, never happend. Look at his face. Who is the one that got cut?"

Margarito said he would like a rematch but not under Dan Goosen promotions.

Paul Williams had nothing but nice things to say about Margarito.

Whats your opinion about it?

I have not watched the fight in a larger format other than the SopCast so I would never honestly try and judge a fight by simply watching it on such a poor resolution but from what I saw, Paul was out hustling Tony. Paul is like a giant Kassim Ouma. I will have to watch the fight later on tonight but, again from what I saw, Tony was not active enough in the early rounds and just gave them away. Different judges look for different things.
We assume most follow this:

Ring generalship
Clean punching
Effective aggressiveness
Defense

Clearly, the ring generalship goes to Paul he dictated the pace of the fight (IMO)
The Cleaner punches came from Tony.
Who was the aggressor? I don't know. (I will get back to you on that) What do you say? Does throwing a lot of punches make Paul the aggressor? Who was moving forwards more? Like I said I have to watch the fight in a better format.
Defense? Judging from all the punches that Paul threw, and then looking at Tony's face, you would have to think Tony was more defensive. Agian, we also have to take into consideration, power shots and body shots.

The one thing that does stick to the back of mind is that Paul basicly took Tony out of his personal punches in bunches routine. What were that punch stats for Tony? I know they were lower than usual. I am sure someone will post the numbers here for us to debate this even further.

PS. Remember that anything I said is based on a poor resolution of a fight so anything I said might change after I watch the fight on a better format.

[SigmaMu]

That's ridiculous. Goosen is a fine promoter and while I still haven't seen it, all indications are that Tony lost. Tony's fans accepted it now it's time for Tony to man the fuck up and not underhand Williams and the event. It was a great card by all accounts, a great show and for him to say that is bullshit.

I hope Arum gets on his ass for that. Arum and Goosen work well with each other all the time.

Well at the end of this all, Tony continued to bash Goosen and Arum did put a stop to it. He said that Tony was not being fair and that his comments were un-called for. So yes, Arum did step in.

[Dorfmeister]

Guys, please leave it aside, it seems you don't know how it works! Tony tryin to get that rematch alleging he was robbed because he lost the opportunity to make big dough with Top Rank's other Champ Miguel Cotto and Paul is tryin to get in his shoes and make that fight Williams-Cotto happen... As simple as that, Williams won fair and square, it was tough though and Tony still is a force at 147 pounds but no longer a titlist - I don't think we have a rat in the kitchen in Williams as well as I never thought Margarito to be a boogie man or an underrated welter constantly ducked by the name fighters. Paul Williams-Tony Margarito II would only emphasize more that Williams is a real force to be reckoned with in the days to come and at 147!

[Beanflicker]

Tony should man up and take his loss like a true warrior. Sorry Tony, but this decision wasn't even controversial, EVERYONE knows that Paul William won. Not even the biggest die hard Margarito supporters are debating the decision (from what I have seen).

He can say he landed the cleaner punches or that he cut Williams, but all it comes down to is who won more rounds. Margarito had a few good rounds but Paul Williams won the vast majority of the rounds, anyone can see that.

[VictorCharlie]

Its fights like these that really make me wish we still had 15 round championship bouts...I had Williams 7 rounds to 5 and I think I was more generous to Tony than most...I think alot of finesse/boxers can stay on their toes and out work a grinder like Margarito over 12 rounds, but if they had to go 15 would run out of gas...If you go back and look at 70s-80s title fights there were a number that were won from 12-15...SRL over Hearns comes to mind as a good example

[Mar]

I miss those 15 rounders at times as well...but it may or may not have helped tony on sat. I don't feel anything has to change a lot of guys reguardless find a way to win and tony should have also. He came on a little more midway through the fight which gave him plenty of time to turn things around and still didn't and didn't have enough in him to at least win the 12th and make it closer and didn't. Him waiting 20 rounds for williams to tire or whatever was going through his mind just plain didn't work but please don't start with the i was robbed, poisioned, molested as a child stuff. He had 12 rounds to do what he needed to do and didn't. He needs to man up and face that.

[Bigsexy]

What a piece of shit sore loser he is, as much as i wanted to see Margarito/Cotto, Paul did beat him convincingly enough. I beleive Cotto will beat Paul Williams easy while Margarito would be alot tougher for Cotto to beat.

[BoomBoom]

I scored it a draw, but Tony wasnt "robbed"

[Howlin Mad Missy]

I scored it a draw, but Tony wasnt "robbed"

Let's hope you never become a judge.....maybe you are and that's why we've been getting some bad scores?

No way a draw, no way a robbery. I agree with him that plenty of shots did not land clean on him but plenty did, more than he landed on Williams.

[LEGION]

If it would have been 15 rounds it would have been even worse for Tony; I mean the 12 th round he didn't do jack-squat in. I thought he would have come out blazing in the 12th, but that was his least active round. He looked fatigued to me so I doubt 15 would have helped him. He should have done more early, simple as that.

[BoomBoom]

I scored it a draw, but Tony wasnt "robbed"

Let's hope you never become a judge.....maybe you are and that's why we've been getting some bad scores?

No way a draw, no way a robbery. I agree with him that plenty of shots did not land clean on him but plenty did, more than he landed on Williams.

Well thats what I had it but Ill go back and watch it. Im a fan of Williams style but Im not really a big fan of either guy so i watched it without bias. Like I said though it wasnt a robbert and I can see how it went Williams way.

[Joerod]

It's kind of sad that he's so adamant about being robbed because that was about as far from a robbery as you can get. I scored it 7-5 with at least one or two rounds that I gave to Margarito on benefit of the doubt that could have EASILY been Williams rounds and most likely were. He had his chance in the 12th to get a gift draw, but couldn't come through. He needs to man up and go back to the drawing board.