Berto-Mosley: Who Wins Now?

[amat]

What do you think?

[paddy448]

Mosley

[JonesJrMayweather]

Berto, mosley is done...

[paddy448]

I don't think mosley is totally done, he just fought the best fighter in the world, I see shanes right hand landing on more than enough occasions to stop berto. Fighting mayweather and berto r 2 completely different things

[C-Lo]

I still think Mosley beats Berto which I think is going to be their next fight. Floyd took Shane's heart, Berto will not do the same.

[blegit]

I think people are taking too much away from Mosley due to how Mayweather made him look. This is not uncommon for Mayweather opponents. JMM couldn't carry the weight, Hatton can't fight at 147, Mosley is done, etc. Nothing Mayweather did to make Mosley look old will be replicated by Berto. Berto is still not beating any of the top 3 welters.

[ElTerribleMorales]

Mosley, he showed he still has his speed, still has his power, and still has an iron beard, Berto wouldn't of taken the shot that Shane landed in the 2nd as well as Floyd did, and Berto's defense is pretty leaky border line non-existent, Mosley would probably stop Berto early or around the 5th

[gest12645]

I voted Mosley but I changed my mind. Berto would give shane problems and unless he gets caught by Mosley , I'd pick Berto tentatively

[boxingbantz]

Mosley, he showed he still has his speed, still has his power, and still has an iron beard, Berto wouldn't of taken the shot that Shane landed in the 2nd as well as Floyd did, and Berto's defense is pretty leaky border line non-existent, Mosley would probably stop Berto early or around the 5th

Spot on. You only had to watch his last fight against Carlos Quintana to see how bad his defense is. Mosley would've put him away in that fight if he'd have been in the ring instead of Quintana -despite all of the personal/emotional problems he had.

Definite stoppage for Mosley.

[Gandalf]

I would originally have said Mosley, but now I think it is much more a pick 'em. Mosley still has his chin, but in terms of output I think he is going along the old Jones Jr path. He will look good for a round or two and then you are asking "Where's Mosley gone?".

[ruthless rocco]

mosely out classes berto.

like all sports boxing needs new blood. it needs new young stars... and some of those fighters that get picked for grooming don't work out. i see that for berto. boxing also needs young potential stars to fail and i see berto will probably fill that role quite effectively.

[Boxer4life]

mosley would knock him the fuck out

[Mar]

I don't think mosley is totally done, he just fought the best fighter in the world, I see shanes right hand landing on more than enough occasions to stop berto. Fighting mayweather and berto r 2 completely different things

I agree, less than a week ago people actually belived mosley had a chance to beat the best boxer on the planet, now he's trash....lol ! I give berto the same chance i gave him before this past fight. The way these two hit and hug it would be close just a matter of who's more effective at getting away with it.

[ICB]

I think Andre Berto wins and i've said that, even before the Floyd Mayweather Jr fight. Read the thread i made when this fight was going to happen, Andre Berto is better technically. He has the better jab, he's faster.

And especially the first two things would give Shane Mosley hell, and im more convinced than ever that Andre Berto would win. Because Shane Mosley's stamina seems to not be there anymore. And he's only had 1 good performance in years.

[GAME]

I picked Shane before to beat Berto and pick Shane again. Nothings changed. Losing to Floyd on points was no surprise for most of us. What did surprise me was how close Shane came to putting Floyd on the deck.

He couldnt beat Floyd at his age but Berto is a different fight altogether. Anyone who saw Berto gassing vs Quintana and swinging away like a novice would realise he isnt ready for Shane yet. Mosley is old and probably a decade past it but he's still the same guy who destroyed Margarito. If he finds your chin regularly he puts you away. Andre is abit too hittable unlike Winky, Floyd and Forrest who were all good defensive fighters. Quintana lured him into a tear up and he abandoned his gameplan right away. Also non punchers have hurt Berto. He should wait a couple years then Id pick him but now Mosley all day long.