What was the worse scorecard of alltime ????

[Jerry Rice]

I watched the first Paul Williams vs Sergio Martinez fight again tonight, one judge scored the fight 119 - 110 for Williams.

[gest12645]

Watch Casamoyer vs Santa Cruz. Every scorecard was terrible as most had it close to a shut out for Santa Cruz

[Violent Demise]

Watch Casamoyer vs Santa Cruz. Every scorecard was terrible as most had it close to a shut out for Santa Cruz

I had Santa Cruz winning the fight. But watch it again and you'll a lot of punches by Santa Cruz. And a lot of missing by Santa Cruz. It was a lot of sloppy, ineffective aggression. While I think he still won the fight, he only won it by a couple of points.

[gest12645]

Watch Casamoyer vs Santa Cruz. Every scorecard was terrible as most had it close to a shut out for Santa Cruz

I had Santa Cruz winning the fight. But watch it again and you'll a lot of punches by Santa Cruz. And a lot of missing by Santa Cruz. It was a lot of sloppy, ineffective aggression. While I think he still won the fight, he only won it by a couple of points.

I gotta disagree, I see what you are saying, but Casamayor did nothing in the fight. He was dominated.

[Violent Demise]

Watch Casamoyer vs Santa Cruz. Every scorecard was terrible as most had it close to a shut out for Santa Cruz

I had Santa Cruz winning the fight. But watch it again and you'll a lot of punches by Santa Cruz. And a lot of missing by Santa Cruz. It was a lot of sloppy, ineffective aggression. While I think he still won the fight, he only won it by a couple of points.

I gotta disagree, I see what you are saying, but Casamayor did nothing in the fight. He was dominated.

I think he lost. I just don't see it as a dominating performance by Cruz. That's giving his performance way to much credit

[bradlee180]

When James Buster Douglas basically spent evry rd knocking the $#!t out of a prime Mike Tyson and knocked him out in rd 10, two judges' scorecards didn't reflect what was going on in the ring.

Judge: Larry Rozadilla 82-88, Douglas ahead.
Judge: Ken Morita 87-86, Mike Tyson ahead ?!
Judge: Masakazu Uchida 86-86, a draw?!

[bzkfn]

Watch Casamoyer vs Santa Cruz. Every scorecard was terrible as most had it close to a shut out for Santa Cruz

I was there for that one and Casamayor was poor. It wasn't a shutout in my eyes, as there were rounds were neither guy did much, but I still had Santa Cruz winning it.

The worse scorecards I've seen were in the David Diaz-Erik Morales fight. People are probably sick of me bringing this up, but that was one of the worst decisions I've ever seen. I gave Diaz 3 rounds at most, it was utter bullshit to setup a Pac fight.

[Britkid]

Hardy/BelcastroI: European title fight, in Italy; one judge scored the bout 2-0 Belcastro with 10 even rounds...

[Chomsky Acolyte]

Doug Tucker in Mijares-Navarro. Mijares clearly won the fight but Tucker somehow has Navarro winning ... a shut-out. He had the clear loser winning every single round. I've never seen anything like that before or since. I remember the commentators assuming that the announcer must've mixed up the scores and he actually had Mijares winning every round. Unfortunately not.

[Jerry Rice]

Hardy/BelcastroI: European title fight, in Italy; one judge scored the bout 2-0 Belcastro with 10 even rounds...

Lmfao

[Master]

Leonard judge score against Hagler was like 10 rounds to Ray and 2 to Hagler.

[bradlee180]

Hagler vs Leonard in 1987, very controversial scoring.

Years later, because of ongoing arguments between Boxing fans as to who really won the fight, I decided to score it myself just to work out for myself who I thought won.
Gotta take off the fan-hat and put on the judge's hat, become as impartial as possible and score it rd by rd under the scoring criteria of Boxing.

I had Hagler winning 8 rds and Leonard winning 4 rds. Wasn't a close fight at all, but watching it live on ppv, it seemed a much closer fight.
There was a close rd which scored the other way would've been 9 rds to 3 rds.


Classic fight anyway...

[Vendettos]

When James Buster Douglas basically spent evry rd knocking the $#!t out of a prime Mike Tyson and knocked him out in rd 10, two judges' scorecards didn't reflect what was going on in the ring.

Judge: Larry Rozadilla 82-88, Douglas ahead.
Judge: Ken Morita 87-86, Mike Tyson ahead ?!
Judge: Masakazu Uchida 86-86, a draw?!

Unbeaten doesn't mean prime, that was not a Prime Mike Tyson.

[Jerry Rice]

Leonard judge score against Hagler was like 10 rounds to Ray and 2 to Hagler.

This is why De La Hoya took the Hopkins fight, he thought it would be the same, a late flurry after each round would steal it, NOT.

[FinitoElDinamita]

Oscar-Sturm was pretty bad.

Lewis-Holyfield 1 was disgusting

Hopkins-Taylor 1.. I dont even like Hopkins but I thought he was done wrong. Hops was the defending undisputed champ and no way Taylor did enough to take that away from him. Fuckin bullshit.

Oscar-Tito

BTW, i agree with Santa Cruz-Casa.. Funny that Gest mentioned this robbery cuz this was the first fight that popped into my head when i saw this thread. Yea it was bad.