Five Star Ratings

[Alpha]

On a rating system out of 5; what are some of your top rated fighters?

For example guys like Mikey Garcia & Lomachenko I'd rated up there, something like 4.7 maybe 4.8. Sort of like a P4P rating but out of 5.

[Master]

You are a tough marker Garcia was flawless in his last fight and I would have given him 5.

Loma would be the same.

[Primo Carnera]

You are a tough marker Garcia was flawless in his last fight and I would have given him 5.

Loma would be the same.

So they're unbeatable and perfect are they? No. So you can't give them a 5!
Out of curiosity, what would you have given Floyd?

[Master]

You are a tough marker Garcia was flawless in his last fight and I would have given him 5.

Loma would be the same.

So they're unbeatable and perfect are they? No. So you can't give them a 5!
Out of curiosity, what would you have given Floyd?

Yes they are unbeatable based on their performances and Loma at least dominate at his weight.

[Primo Carnera]

You are a tough marker Garcia was flawless in his last fight and I would have given him 5.

Loma would be the same.

So they're unbeatable and perfect are they? No. So you can't give them a 5!
Out of curiosity, what would you have given Floyd?

Yes they are unbeatable based on their performances and Loma at least dominate at his weight.

Firstly, Loma (and I like him a lot) HAS ALREADY LOST, therefore he's not unbeatable.
Secondly, what about answering my question on Floyd? 😄

[Master]

You are a tough marker Garcia was flawless in his last fight and I would have given him 5.

Loma would be the same.

So they're unbeatable and perfect are they? No. So you can't give them a 5!
Out of curiosity, what would you have given Floyd?

Yes they are unbeatable based on their performances and Loma at least dominate at his weight.

Firstly, Loma (and I like him a lot) HAS ALREADY LOST, therefore he's not unbeatable.
Secondly, what about answering my question on Floyd? 😄

0's should not matter on a record and far too much is made of them which answers both your questions.

[Alpha]

You are a tough marker Garcia was flawless in his last fight and I would have given him 5.

Loma would be the same.

Garcia has been dropped before. And Loma has lost. He was beaten by another fighter. I can totally understand giving both Garcia & Loma 5. Does everyone around P4P get an automatic 5 star or are their degrees?

[Batman]

On behalf of Ross I would like to nominate Tyson Fury

[Batman]

As far as I'm concerned unless there is a fighter who's attack, power defense, footwork, head movement, punch variety etc etc etc is 100% perfect then they can't be a 5 star fighter in the way that we are talking.

On the same note the fact that Loma for example has been beaten shouldn't stop him from achieving the ever impressive 5 star rating as boxers can improve, on that basis you would have to say that Wilder (who has obvious flaws) is a 5 star fighter because he has stopped all but one of his opponents.

I want to hear what PK has to say about this 5 star business, I agree with him.

[Alpha]

I was thinking like old boxing video games that had an overall rating for a fighter out of 100.

[Primo Carnera]

The way I see it , only 1 fighter, or at best one fighter per division can get a 5 star rating . A loss doesn't stop someone getting the 5 star rating, BUT a loss does mean that a fighter could NEVER be called unbeatable.
That's more about facts and the English language rather than boxing opinion.