Calzaghe P4P list

[gudnite vienna]

If JC beats Kessler in November, where would you rate him on the P4P list, at the moment i think he's at number 8. I honestly think he should go into the top 5, and if he then beat Hopkins or Taylor in his next fight, he could be into the top 3 next year withoutout doubt.

Also if Mayweather gets beat by hatton they have both got a case to be number one next year.

[Nium]

These 'p4p' lists are nonsense.

I agree with Roy Jones - there's a pound-for-pound best and then everyone else.

[gudnite vienna]

why whats nonsense, all these alphabet tittles are nonesense pal. i find it interesting judging fighters in different weight classes

[Dark Lord Al]

If he beats Kessler then he goes from 10 to 8 for me

[Tins06]

Id put him at NO1 Joe rules.....but in reality if he beats kess 6 sounds about right and then if he beats bernard top 3 or 4 depending how the other fighters in the the top 10 perform obviusly

[bambamdaddio]

How does Joe get to fight Hopkins, when he has allegedly (Hopkins that is) in the past been pricing himself out of that fight, Joe should be top 5 now on what hes done and maintained already,

Had he been American and not Welsh, he would be top 3 already, controversial may be but in reality its probably true...no offence meant to anyone out there,

[Julius Rain]

come on guys don't stress yourselves with where to put joe.C at the p4p list, it'll be out of the top ten because Kessler is going to k.o him. Now the real issue here is where to put kessler in the top 10 p4p list

[Dark Lord Al]

come on guys don't stress yourselves with where to put joe.C at the p4p list, it'll be out of the top ten because Kessler is going to k.o him. Now the real issue here is where to put kessler in the top 10 p4p list

I hope you are right im banking on Kessler shutting the Welsh tosser up once and for all

[leftylee]

WTF Joe C p4p number 1 and even if he does beat Kessler it's in HIS backyard like every other fighter and the only others he's fought was a overrated Lacy and Eubank years ago.
Joe will never be p4p number 1 unless he moves to america and fight Hopkins,Taylor and beat them

[superheavyrhun]

come on guys don't stress yourselves with where to put joe.C at the p4p list, it'll be out of the top ten because Kessler is going to k.o him. Now the real issue here is where to put kessler in the top 10 p4p list

I hope you are right im banking on Kessler shutting the Welsh tosser up once and for all

Shutting him up....? In a sport with bigmouths such as James Toney, Zab Judah, Floyd Mayweather Jr, Carl Froch, Roy Jones, Evander Holyfield, Audley Harrison, David Haye, Junior Witter, etc etc etc ad infinitaeum, why is Calzaghe the one you want to shut up? He conducts himself fairly well and respectfully for a boxer, especially when you consider our cousins across the pond.

In my opinion, there are a lot more very big mouths that need to be shut before we get on to Joe.

[Mr140]

why does ever bag on joe i know he hasn't fought in america but i cant blam him for that because americans dont seem to leave the states to fight so why should we just point out joe i mean i not sure of the pound for pound rating but i just sick of every bagging on the guy he has defended his title for 10 years undefeated and has beat the guys who were rated in the top 10 in the wbo which was his title and those are the people he fought but to be high on a pound for pound list i think he would hav to move up and beat bernard

[GAME]

If Calzaghe was born in America he would be currently in Rings top 3 p4p . No doubt about it

[frozensolid_702]

If Calzaghe was born in America he would be currently in Rings top 3 p4p . No doubt about it

You mean like Manny Pacquio #2 and Juan Manuel Marquez #3??



Another well thought out post by GAME







(I had to edit this due to me quoting the wrong guy, but it's fixed now. Sorry for any bs this may have caused to anybody who actually knows wtf they're talking about)

[GAME]

If Calzaghe was born in America he would be currently in Rings top 3 p4p . No doubt about it

You mean like Manny Pacquio #2 and Juan Manuel Marquez #3??



Another well thought post by Julius Rain

Those two fighters arent british so I dont get your point . Why esle isnt Calazghe rated then ? It cant be on ring achievements cuz he is the longests reigning champion in the sport . Beaten everyone they put infront of him , undefeated too. Pac and Marquez lost recently but they are 2 and 3 ? Its BS ! But then again its just an opinion

[superheavyrhun]

If Calzaghe was born in America he would be currently in Rings top 3 p4p . No doubt about it

You mean like Manny Pacquio #2 and Juan Manuel Marquez #3??



Another well thought post by Julius Rain

Those two fighters arent Vritish so I dont get your point . Why esle isnt Calazghe rated then ? It cant be on ring achievements cuz he is the longests reigning champion in the sport . Beaten everyone they put infront of him , undefeated too. Pac and Marquez lost recently but they are 2 and 3 ? Its BS ! But then again its just an opinion

I'm with you bro, have a CC.