Hopkins/RJJ/Calzaghe/Toney

[njackets]

If all at there prime,not sure what weight 2 go 4 here,lets say SMW would have fought each other (and Toney was'nt weight drained either) outcomes? Who would u of liked 2 see fight most? Or in unification box off,who comes away the Champ?

[p4pking]

Jones>Toney>Hopkins(close)>Calzaghe. Imo.

[eagle]

RJJ by a long way.

[wbcheavywieght]

1.Jones
2. Hopkins
3.Toney
4.Calzaghe

[BIG H]

What Calzaghe ever have lost to Drake Thadzi?

[Fenster]

Roy
Calzaghe
Toney
Hokpins

Fact.

[p4pking]

What Calzaghe ever have lost to Drake Thadzi?

The thread implied that they were all in their prime on their best form. Do you think that any Calzaghe would have beat say the Toney that beat Barkley? I can't see what Calzaghe was capable of doing so.

[Beanflicker]

What Calzaghe ever have lost to Drake Thadzi?

Would Calzaghe have fought the best from middleweight to HEAVYWEIGHT and still had success?

IMO...

1. Jones
2. James Toney
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Calzaghe

I know it seems like Im being hard on Calzaghe, but IMO Jones, Toney and Hopkins are on a different level, these guys are some of the best our generation has produced.

[SalTheButcher]

If all at there prime,not sure what weight 2 go 4 here,lets say SMW would have fought each other (and Toney was'nt weight drained either) outcomes? Who would u of liked 2 see fight most? Or in unification box off,who comes away the Champ?

jones > hopkins > toney > * > calzaghe

[njackets]

Its a shame these 4 all fought mostly in diffrent weights,there all more or less natualy the same size,Can u imagine them all in the same weight class about 6 or 7 years ago?!

[Dark Lord Al]

RJJ - Toney - Hopkins Calzaghe

the reason they didnt fight a SM is simple all except Calzaghe move on to bigger thingsin the case of RJJ AND TONEY) , and used Sm as stepping stone earlier in their careers , and Calzaghe stayed there way to long .