Who is the man at 147???

[hackey]

I really don't know now. I thought it might have been Margarito, but now I have to conclude that it is Williams or Cotto, if Williams can make it back to 147. A valid case can also be made for Cotto now that Margarito's honour is in question with regards to wrapping. I think that biggest fight in the division is Cotto Williams at 147, although I would love to see Mosley Berto now as well.

If Margarito is proven to have been using plaster, he should have his license revoked and all fights struck from the records.

[littlebif]

Mosley has shook the division up with that win.

Cotto beat Mosley
Margarito beat Cotto
Mosley beat Margarito
its very intresting where they go from here

Then there is Berto he needs to get one of the big names to see who is the best at 147.

[Pugilistic]

Sugar Shane Mosley.

How can anyone disagree

[belakbox]

yeah. Sugar is the man at 147 right now. He lost a decision to Cotto that could have gone either way. I personally had Cotto ahead by two rounds, but understand it could have been a draw or even a ud for Mosely. After last night's domination of Margarito, he definitely gets the man status from me.

[Bomp]

There is no champion. If Shane can win a rematch with Cotto then he'd have a case, but there's also Paul Williams.

[belakbox]

I hope PW stays where he is or moves up to light heavy or heavy. His azz is way too big for this division.

[GAME]

Shane Mosley

No question. He beats Pac, Hatton, Tony and Cotto. Floyd is the fight I wana see. Its been waiting to happen for 10 years

[SalTheButcher]

clottey is the best WW in the world

[GAME]

Clottey got beat by Margarito and Baldimor.

[SalTheButcher]

Clottey got beat by Margarito and Baldimor.

neither of those were legitimate losses


clottey has never really been beaten

[ICB]

Clottey got beat by Margarito and Baldimor.

He wasn't beaten by Carlos Baldomir he got DQ, but he was way ahead in that fight at the time. And from my memory the DQ was questionable, he got a bad injury to his hand in the Antonio Margarito fight.

Which effected him badly, but Antonio Margarito also wasn't 100 percent himself so that excuse works both ways. The fact is though Joshua Clottey hasn't been beaten without some question marks.

If you really count the Carlos Baldomir loss, when he was comfortably ahead in the fight and was on his way to winning comfortably, until he got DQ with less than 2 rounds left then go ahead and count it. But then that would be the same as claiming Riddick Bowe beat Andrew Golota x2.

The only real legit loss he has is too Antonio Margarito, which also has question marks surrounding it. Because he won the first 4 rounds comfortably until that injury to his hand. Joshua Clottey deserves a shot against one of the top fighters he deserves it