Paul Malignaggi vs Juan Diaz My Scorecard.

[ICB]

Didn't watch it live because i was asleep, but here's my scorecard after just watching it.

1 Malignaggi 10-9
2 Diaz 10-9
3 Malignaggi 10-9
4 Diaz 10-9
5 Diaz 10-9
6 Malignaggi 10-9
7 Diaz 10-9
8 Malignaggi 10-9
9 Malignaggi 10-9
10 Malignaggi 10-9
11 Malignaggi 10-9
12 Diaz 10-9

Paul Malignaggi 115-113.

Quite suprised Paul Malignaggi handled Juan Diaz, as good as he did. And im quite suprised he was able to keep up such a good workrate, i felt the fight was close in the first 6 rounds or so.

Then after the 8th round, Paul Malignaggi i felt totally outboxed. Juan Diaz for 4 rounds IMO, he kept his distance well rolled with the punches. And landed some good jabs with Juan Diaz struggling to get any offense going.

I didn't think the rounds were that hard to score, the 8th round was the only swing round IMO. And the 12th round although closish i felt that was clearly Juan Diaz's. I have no problem's with a draw and i'll have to watch the 8th round again sometime, but for me Paul Malignaggi won the fight based on the later rounds.

[The Fightfan]

I've already forgotten my scorecard but I had Diaz ahead 7 rounds to 5. I don't think it was an outright robbery. I felt it could have easily gone either way but 118-110 is just god awful.

[Beanflicker]

Not sure of my round by round, but I remember I scored it 116-112 for Malignaggi, I thought he did a beautiful job of boxing and moving, and Juan just couldn't keep up.

Good fight, after seeing Hatton maul Paulie, I thought Diaz would be all over him but Paulie put on a great show.

[jokaleras]

I didn't score the fight but Paulie seemed to me the better fight that night. Juan Diaz definitely had his moments though. Overall an entertaining scrap.

[Violent Demise]

I scored it draw

[ICB]

I scored it draw

You must of scored the 8th round for Juan Diaz then ? that to me was the only real round. That could of gone either way, i thought the best Juan Diaz could of done was a draw.

[ICB]

I didn't score the fight but Paulie seemed to me the better fight that night. Juan Diaz definitely had his moments though. Overall an entertaining scrap.

Agreed i thought Juan Diaz couldn't really get his workrate, going after the 7th round. Until he picked it up again in the 12th round.

[Truth]

10 - 9 Malignaggi
10 - 9 Diaz
10 - 9 Malignaggi
10 - 10
10 - 9 Diaz
10 - 10
10 - 9 Diaz
10 - 9 Diaz
10 - 9 Diaz
10 -9 Malignaggi
10 -9 Malignaggi
10 -10

Scored it 116-115 for Diaz but it could've gone either way depends on you're preference more accurate crisper punches or less crisp but higher quantity of punches. However this was NOT a robbery. The scorecards were bad not the decision.