Who is up in the JMM-Pac trilogy?

[gest12645]

These are my scorecards

1st fight :114-111 pacman
2nd fight : 114-113 Pacman
3rd fight : 115-114 Marquez

18-17-1 in rounds for Marquez
The knockdowns made the difference for me

IMO, it should be 2-1 in fights in favour od Pac

[ElTerribleMorales]

3-0 for Marquez, at worst it's 2-0-1 in Marquez' favor

[J_C]

113-113 Draw
114-113 Marquez
117-114 Marquez

20-12-4 Marquez.

If you wana give Pac all 4 draw rounds (I think most tend to in the pick em rounds between these 2) then including the knockdowns, thats a stalemate.

[gest12645]

many close rounds between these fighters. That's why , anyone calling a robbery in any of these fights is crazy. It depends what you look at in fights, when you're a judge.

[InTheNeutralCorner]

I am happy for the Pac wins but I consider them both as equal. Draw on all three.

And kudos to Marquez for maintaining equal status with Pacquiao in the third fight given his age.

[ICB]

These are my scorecards after rewatching each fight.

1st fight

1 Pacquiao 10-6
2 Pacquiao 10-9
3 Marquez 10-9
4 Marquez 10-9
5 Marquez 10-9
6 Marquez 10-9
7 Pacquiao 10-9
8 Marquez 10-9
9 Marquez 10-9
10 Pacquiao 10-9
11 Marquez 10-9
12 Marquez 10-9


113-112 JMM

2nd fight

1 Pacquiao 10-9
2 Marquez 10-9
3 Pacquiao 10-8
4 Pacquiao 10-9
5 Marquez 10-9
6 Marquez 10-9
7 Marquez 10-9
8 Marquez 10-9
9 Pacquiao 10-9
10 Pacquiao 10-9
11 Marquez 10-9
12 Marquez 10-9

114-113 JMM

3rd fight

1 Even 10-10
2 Marquez 10-9
3 Marquez 10-9
4 Pacquiao 10-9
5 Marquez 10-9
6 Pacquiao 10-9
7 Marquez 10-9
8 Marquez 10-9
9 Marquez 10-9
10 Marquez 10-9
11 Pacquiao 10-9
12 Pacquiao 10-9

116-113 JMM