Scorecards for Cotto vs Margarito II

[Mars_ax]

The fight was stopped 3 seconds into the 10th round, before any action took place. All 3 judges had Cotto ahead 89-82, or up 8-1 in rounds at the end of 9. Which means Margarito won only 1 round. Cotto probably would have won all 9 rounds if he didn't "hit like a girl", it makes me think Tony must hang around some tough girls.

judge: Julie Lederman 89-82 | judge: Steve Weisfeld 89-82 | judge: John Poturaj 89-82

Anyway you wanna look at it, this was a professional, world class, dominate performance by Cotto and the stoppage was just icing on the cake.

Thoughts?

[CFH]

Cards seem right to me. I don't think I gave Margarito a single round, but there were one or two close ones towards the end of the fight.

[Manos de Piedra]

I didn't give margarito any rounds but there was a close round somewhere in the fight that could have been given to margarito as a comparative round by the judges.

[Master]

Marg won 2 rounds 4 and 5, close 6th.

[Mars_ax]

Marg won 2 rounds 4 and 5, close 6th.

I watched the fight on a surprisingly good stream, but it was still hard for me to score some of the rounds. All the judges for this fight had it: Cotto 8-1 in rounds, when I watch the replay Saturday in HD on my big screen, i'll try to score it and see if I agree. It seems like most people only had Margarito winning a round or 2 before the stoppage.

From what I could tell, even though Margarito was losing most of the rounds, he was making the fight competitive by being the aggressor and/or continuing to come forward. It didn't seem however, like Margo's punches were all that effective, and Cotto was able to avoid most of his power punches. I also thought Margo's punches looked much weaker then they usually do, even more so in the later rounds.

[captainanddew]

the most telling thing to me was Cotto did stand and trade a little bit with Margo during the last couple of rounds. He did it, but then went back to boxing. It wasn't him stopping to throw flurries, he actually stood there and willingly traded a few times.

Makes me think Cotto was comfortable enough in his belief that Margarito wasn't the same puncher.