Was Stiverne worse of a HW Champ than Spinks and Buster?

[brocktonblockbust]

I think we can nominate Stiverne as rivaling the caliber of Leon Neon Spinks and Buster Douglas as a HW Champ.

No excuses, I like Stiverne, but he did seem a bit "out of it" (maybe because of eating so many straight rights from the big punching Wilder) but did you see his non-existent footwork after round 6? He stood squared-up, no head movement, never even tried to duck under any shots that I saw, didn't make a fuck of a lotta sense to me.

The fat shit looked woefully out of shape to me as well, pudgy, sluggish, waddling like a duck.

Pudgy, sluggish, waddling like a duck. Seriously, wtf? happened to him? he's right he was "flat"----
though I would say more like "fat" bwahaha

How hard did this dude train for Wilder? You're going in against a chiseled 29 year old Adonis with a big cock and a small head, shoulders like Atlas, 32 KOs------ Stiverne looked like he was in the shape to fight a buffet table at an all-you-can-eat Mexican restaurant.

bad conditioning, and even WORSE FIGHT PLAN.

[ross]

He looked in better shape on the scales for this fight than he did against Arreola. Exactly the same weight as the Arreola rematch but about 10lbs lighter than the first fight!

I have a feeling you backed Stiverne because he reminded you of older days fighters (bat the skill) but you have been backing the wrong horse.

He fought and looked no different in this fight than any other. He just happened to fight someone who could jab and move.

[X]

I think it's fair to say that Bermane is not going to go down as an all time great heavyweight champion, he seems to me to be a decent solid journeyman who (to some extent) lucked out by being in the right place at the right time to benefit from some boxing politics and a shocking lack of depth in the division. None of that is his fault, of course.

If you look back through boxing history, he is not the only solid pro who found himself in a position beyond his wildest dreams.

You can make an argument that several tough journeymen found themselves as 'champions', such as James J Braddock, Tim Witherspoon, Trevor Berbick and others.

I think these guys, and Stiverne, are slightly different from Leon Spinks and Buster Douglas. They were fighters who produced one (and only one) magnificent career defining performance at just the right time, and against someone who was ready to be taken. You might add Gene Tunney and Bonecrusher Smith etc to that list.

There is another category of fighter, such as Primo Carnera, Nikolai Valuev but I won't go into that here!.

[ross]

I think it's fair to say that Bermane is not going to go down as an all time great heavyweight champion, he seems to me to be a decent solid journeyman who (to some extent) lucked out by being in the right place at the right time to benefit from some boxing politics and a shocking lack of depth in the division. None of that is his fault, of course.

If you look back through boxing history, he is not the only solid pro who found himself in a position beyond his wildest dreams.

You can make an argument that several tough journeymen found themselves as 'champions', such as James J Braddock, Tim Witherspoon, Trevor Berbick and others.

I think these guys, and Stiverne, are slightly different from Leon Spinks and Buster Douglas. They were fighters who produced one (and only one) magnificent career defining performance at just the right time, and against someone who was ready to be taken. You might add Gene Tunney and Bonecrusher Smith etc to that list.

There is another category of fighter, such as Primo Carnera, Nikolai Valuev but I won't go into that here!.

Good post!

[erics44]

I think it's fair to say that Bermane is not going to go down as an all time great heavyweight champion, he seems to me to be a decent solid journeyman who (to some extent) lucked out by being in the right place at the right time to benefit from some boxing politics and a shocking lack of depth in the division. None of that is his fault, of course.

If you look back through boxing history, he is not the only solid pro who found himself in a position beyond his wildest dreams.

You can make an argument that several tough journeymen found themselves as 'champions', such as James J Braddock, Tim Witherspoon, Trevor Berbick and others.

I think these guys, and Stiverne, are slightly different from Leon Spinks and Buster Douglas. They were fighters who produced one (and only one) magnificent career defining performance at just the right time, and against someone who was ready to be taken. You might add Gene Tunney and Bonecrusher Smith etc to that list.

There is another category of fighter, such as Primo Carnera, Nikolai Valuev but I won't go into that here!.

Good post!

witherspoon wasnt a jouneyman

thing is with so many titles stiverne has the opportunity to be "world champ"

theres been worse champions tho

[Beanflicker]

Well I think you have to automatically put those guys above Stiverne because Leon beat Ali, Buster beat Tyson and Stiverne beat Chris Arreola HAHAHA

[X]

I can see why you would say Witherspoon wasn't a journeyman. I'm not insulting these guys at all, but I do wonder whether Tim would have risen quite as far as he did if he was fighting in the 30s or the 70s. The early 1980s weren't halcyon days for the heavyweight division.

[IamInuit]

Does the man make the belt or the belt make the man? It really makes no difference who would have won Saturday. Stiverne was a paperweight and that's what the WBC has been since Vitali vacated. Wilder is now that paperweight. You guys may have that American heavyweight title holder but he's not the heavyweight champion. Lets see if he makes it real. Take Fury as the optional he is entitled to and then make the Wlad fight. Beat Wlad and then you can call yourself heavyweight champion.

[beenKOed]

Compare who they beat to get the belt to who Stiverne beat.
Compare who beat them to who beat Stiverne.

[porkypara]

I think we can nominate Stiverne as rivaling the caliber of Leon Neon Spinks and Buster Douglas as a HW Champ.

No excuses, I like Stiverne, but he did seem a bit "out of it" (maybe because of eating so many straight rights from the big punching Wilder) but did you see his non-existent footwork after round 6? He stood squared-up, no head movement, never even tried to duck under any shots that I saw, didn't make a fuck of a lotta sense to me.

The fat shit looked woefully out of shape to me as well, pudgy, sluggish, waddling like a duck.

Pudgy, sluggish, waddling like a duck. Seriously, wtf? happened to him? he's right he was "flat"----
though I would say more like "fat" bwahaha

How hard did this dude train for Wilder? You're going in against a chiseled 29 year old Adonis with a big cock and a small head, shoulders like Atlas, 32 KOs------ Stiverne looked like he was in the shape to fight a buffet table at an all-you-can-eat Mexican restaurant.

bad conditioning, and even WORSE FIGHT PLAN.

At least Spinks and Douglas were in shape for at least 1 fight and both beat legends.