Pac/Floyd vs Golovkin

[gest12645]

At 154 or a catchweight of 156 , how does Golovkin do against Pac and Floyd ? I say he ko's Pacman and outpoints Floyd.
Thoughts?

[imp]

Pac would never take that risk.

He wouldnt even fight canelo.

Floyd schooled canelo.

[gest12645]

So you say Pacman wouldn't beat Canelo?

[imp]

So you say Pacman wouldn't beat Canelo?

We will never know because he didn't take the risk...floyd did.

[p4pking]

I think Floyd of five or so years ago would have had a good chance at 154, especially if Golovkin was any worse for wear having to cut the weight. Manny is even smaller than Floyd and with such a physical style I don't think it would have been realistic for him to fight someone as big as Golovkin. Look at Manny against Margarito, he was basically fighting the size difference all night, in what was in every other way a total mismatch and beat down.

[La Cucaracha]

GGG knocks them both out

[Primo Carnera]

So you say Pacman wouldn't beat Canelo?

I don't think he would. He's too small. Canelo wouldn't fight him at anything less than 154.

[0james0]

Neither would want to fight him and to be honest I can't blame them!

[gest12645]

I agree, but let's say the fight happens. Who do you pick?

[Ron Swanson]

Saying GGG beats them says absolutely nothing.

Floyd started at 130, that is 30lbs short of 160 or 23% of total body mass. Pac started even smaller.

To look at an equal situation for GGG

He would be fighting someone weighing in at 197.

Looking at someone fighting as high as they can fight vs someone fighting as low as they can fight is absurd.

[Lineal]

Saying GGG beats them says absolutely nothing.

Floyd started at 130, that is 30lbs short of 160 or 23% of total body mass. Pac started even smaller.

To look at an equal situation for GGG

He would be fighting someone weighing in at 197.

Looking at someone fighting as high as they can fight vs someone fighting as low as they can fight is absurd.

Armstrong fought at featherweight, Gavilan and Napoles were at 122 and 126, Duran turned pro at 119, so why whine that it isn't fair when former greats have done it? Seems only appropriate that someone claiming to be TBE would also attempt it

[imp]

Saying GGG beats them says absolutely nothing.

Floyd started at 130, that is 30lbs short of 160 or 23% of total body mass. Pac started even smaller.

To look at an equal situation for GGG

He would be fighting someone weighing in at 197.

Looking at someone fighting as high as they can fight vs someone fighting as low as they can fight is absurd.

Armstrong fought at featherweight, Gavilan and Napoles were at 122 and 126, Duran turned pro at 119, so why whine that it isn't fair when former greats have done it? Seems only appropriate that someone claiming to be TBE would also attempt it

Is GGG the next one to be groomed for mayweather after he beats pacman.?

I think this is the early stages of mayweather being accused of ducking GGG.

[Lineal]

Saying GGG beats them says absolutely nothing.

Floyd started at 130, that is 30lbs short of 160 or 23% of total body mass. Pac started even smaller.

To look at an equal situation for GGG

He would be fighting someone weighing in at 197.

Looking at someone fighting as high as they can fight vs someone fighting as low as they can fight is absurd.

Armstrong fought at featherweight, Gavilan and Napoles were at 122 and 126, Duran turned pro at 119, so why whine that it isn't fair when former greats have done it? Seems only appropriate that someone claiming to be TBE would also attempt it

Is GGG the next one to be groomed for mayweather after he beats pacman.?

I think this is the early stages of mayweather being accused of ducking GGG.

I'm just pointing out the fact that former greats who started at lighter weights than Mayweather challenged themselves at middlweight. Fans didn't whine about it being unfair. I remember being excited about Duran taking on Hagler, not complaining that Duran didn't belong at 160 or fighting Barkley (the man who knocked out the man who knocked him the f__k out, Tommy Hearns).

[Master]

GGG would beat them both.

Manny did fight Margarito when he was hot but even he said 154 was too high for him.

[Beanflicker]

Both of them would get killed. Neither has the legs at this point to outmaneuver GGG. I have no doubt both of them could win a few rounds, but GGG is just too strong and imposing and that would wear out the smaller men. GGG stops both guys.