who would win a winky-taylor rematch?

[amat]

Depends if the judges base their opinions on punches landing on gloves and elbows rather than punches actually scoring.

Also I don't care how hard the shots are, unless they knock the guy across the ring a clean his is a clean hit.

Fair enough give a guy around if he lands 4 mega shots that nearly get the guy down and the other guy lands 8 weak shots, but Taylor was doing no such thing.

CC. I think that Winky wins a rematch because he had no answer when Winky was walking him down. When the fight got in the middle of the ring, it was at Winky's discression. He COMPLETELY controlled the ring that fight. Not saying that Taylor didn't win any rounds, it was a close fight but one that Winky won imo. And in the fight, he was the ring general so I have to give him the nod in the rematch.

[lb4lb]

I would cheer for Taylor. Winky is a boring fighter.

[AdamGB]

Very good boxer though.