Poll:Who Should Have Won The Fight?

[shza]

A draw at best.
Floyd did not do enough to win this fight.

Stop talking out of your ass and post your scorecard. Show me how you legitimize giving De la Hoya more than 4 rounds. I find it hard to give him more than 3.

[El Gamo]

116-112 for PBF,no doubt in my mind BUT Oscar let that fight go.Had he jabbed 30-40 times a round like Roach taught him to,the doubles and triples,he would have won.The rounds he was jabbing in,he controlled,it set up his other shots. Really stupid for a veteran like him to just stop using a winning formula.

[Mayweatherpfp]

i had floyd 115-113 i gave oscar a few close rounds too merely for his work rate and aggression. has anyone else noticed that anyone who has voted oscar hasn't commented lol.

[ICB]

Mayweather

[spanky-banky]

yall want score cards huh! well check it out yall
rd1#PBF
rd2#ODH
rd3#ODH
rd4#ODH
rd5#even....to close for me to call,it could have gone either way
rd6#PBF
rd7#ODH
rd8#ODH
rd9#ODH
rd10#PBF
rd11#PBF
rd12#ODH
final score DE LA HOYA 116 - 113

some of those rds were close and i could understand if some of u gave them to PBF but in that case the fight would be a draw at worse....the fight i saw ODLH won

[spanky-banky]

i had floyd 115-113 i gave oscar a few close rounds too merely for his work rate and aggression. has anyone else noticed that anyone who has voted oscar hasn't commented lol.

why dont those who gave it to mayweather repectivly give ur rd by rd score
id be interested to see which rds you all scord for mayweather cause in my opinion he didnt do much for the first 2/3rds of the fight

[LegendBoxing65]

yall want score cards huh! well check it out yall
rd1#PBF
rd2#ODH
rd3#ODH
rd4#ODH
rd5#even....to close for me to call,it could have gone either way
rd6#PBF
rd7#ODH
rd8#ODH
rd9#ODH
rd10#PBF
rd11#PBF
rd12#ODH
final score DE LA HOYA 116 - 113

some of those rds were close and i could understand if some of u gave them to PBF but in that case the fight would be a draw at worse....the fight i saw ODLH won

Punch stats say it all. Floyd won. Hagler always said it was best not to leave it in the hands of the judges. He was right. For two reasons. One , he could be on the bad end of a decision, and he wouldn't have to hear arguments about who won for years and years. But Floyd does not have the power at 154 to knock people out. At 147 either.

[p4pking]

116-112 for PBF,no doubt in my mind BUT Oscar let that fight go.Had he jabbed 30-40 times a round like Roach taught him to,the doubles and triples,he would have won.The rounds he was jabbing in,he controlled,it set up his other shots. Really stupid for a veteran like him to just stop using a winning formula.

Yeah it did seem very odd that he abandoned the jab... But at the same time he obviously had a reason to do so... Either he was too wary of being countered or he knew that he couldn't keep it up over 12 rounds is my guess.. I mean Oscar had a very low output in most rounds and yet expended a lot of energy with flurries that missed their mark.. The fact that he gassed out after the 7th as it was tells me that had he thrown anywhere near that many punches he just would have hit empty by the championship rounds and been ripe for the picking.

[Tysonbruno]

Ive voted Mayweather

[killersheep]

Round 1 PBF 10-9
Round 2 ODLH 9-10
Round 3 Draw 10-10
Round 4 ODLH 9-10
Round 5 PBF 10-9
Round 6 PBF 10-9
Round 7 ODLH 9-10
Round 8 PBF 10-9
Round 9 PBF 10-9
Round 10 PBF 10-9
Round 11 PBF 10-9
Round 12 PBF 10-9

8 rounds Mayweather, 3 rounds de la Hoya, 1 round even.
117-112 Mayweather.

There are 4 categories that I base it on
Ring Generalship.
Effective Aggression.
Clean Punching.
Defense.

PBF owned in all except Effective Agression in most of the rounds.

[Tysonbruno]

Round 1 PBF 10-9
Round 2 ODLH 9-10
Round 3 Draw 10-10
Round 4 ODLH 9-10
Round 5 PBF 10-9
Round 6 PBF 10-9
Round 7 ODLH 9-10
Round 8 PBF 10-9
Round 9 PBF 10-9
Round 10 PBF 10-9
Round 11 PBF 10-9
Round 12 PBF 10-9

8 rounds Mayweather, 3 rounds de la Hoya, 1 round even.
117-112 Mayweather.

There are 4 categories that I base it on
Ring Generalship.
Effective Aggression.
Clean Punching.
Defense.

PBF owned in all except Effective Agression in most of the rounds.

Similar to me i had it 117-113 Mayweather CC mate

[Daim]

I had it just like the Judah fight 8 rnds to 4 in favor of Mayweather.......You just can't expect to win a round that you're opponent just set the pace and tagged you all over and made you look silly by just throwing a flurry that landed on thin air.Oscar was fighting Floyd's fight,he had the good jab going on,haven't seen no one tag PBF with a jab so many times,but like everyone knows he abandoned it.

[Gandalf]

116-112 for PBF,no doubt in my mind BUT Oscar let that fight go.Had he jabbed 30-40 times a round like Roach taught him to,the doubles and triples,he would have won.The rounds he was jabbing in,he controlled,it set up his other shots. Really stupid for a veteran like him to just stop using a winning formula.

Exactly the way I score it too. Oscar had the slight edge at the end of the seventh. Thereafter Floyd won the championship rounds with relative ease. Oscar completely let go of the jab and it was odd. Where was the advice from Roach?? It was a seriously peculiar approach on the Oscar side.

All credit to Mayweather though, he did what he had to do. Oscar didnt.

[albsur2006]

Round 1: 10 - 9 PBF
Round 2: 10 - 9 ODLH
Round 3: 10 - 10 Even
Round 4: 10 - 9 ODLH
Round 5: 10 - 9 PBF
Round 6: 10 - 9 PBF
Round 7: 10 - 9 ODLH
Round 8: 10 - 9 PBF
Round 9: 10 - 9 PBF
Round 10: 10 - 9 PBF
Round 11: 10 - 9 PBF
Round 12: 10 - 9 ODLH

116-113 Floyd Mayweather Jr. This was my scorecard after watching the fight the second time.
On my original scorecard I had Oscar winning round 3 and Floyd winning round 12. My first scorecard was 116-112 Floyd. Either way, Floyd won this fight. The people that think Oscar won this fight need to really watch the fight closely. In the "close" rounds, Oscar would throw flurries while Floyd was on the ropes and the crowd would get excited and then Oscar wouldn't really do anything for a whole another minute and a half while Floyd used his jab and right hand to dictate the action. Let's be honest, Oscar only fought in spurts, Floyd boxed the whole fight. At the end of the day, this fight kinda reminded me of RJJ - Tarver I, RJJ would dictate the action but Tarver put in work while RJJ was on the ropes. People are saying that Floyd shouldn't be able to win a fight moving away, but I don't think that you can win a fight on throwing a couple of flurries a round either. The thing that really struck me is that Floyd landed the harder and more effective punches and the guy was at 148 in the ring.

[Junior Stego]

I thought 116-112 in favor of Mayweather, people are never happy unless they see a knockout, or a slug fest. Floyd had the gameplan working, i don't like him much, but he got the job done, thats all that matters.