how many times has the reigning undisputed P4P No 1. been dominated...

[Dark Lord Al]

Peter Manfredo was p4p the best when CalzAghe beat him / dominated him RIGHT ?

[Tito BHB]

Pernell Whitaker vs Julio Cesar Chavez.

that was a draw

Put down the boxrecord

That was a screwjob..Pernell won the fight

[ICB]

Buster Douglas beating Tyson ??

[Tito BHB]

Buster Douglas beating Tyson ??

Thats a fair one

[The Rookie Fan]

Trinidad was considered by many the P4P king when he fought B-Hop. I know, I know, some people here will say that Jones Jr was always #1 until he lost. You know that old hind sight is 20/20 thing but the fact is that at that time Jones was being seriously criticized by his level of opposition and Tito's big run to the MW division had placed him #1 in many boxing fans P4P lists.....

And then he was dominated

tito was never number 1...he only beat joppy and that no way would have had him leap shane mosley who was still undefeated and ranked no 2...

The very day of the fight against B-Hop HBO posted their P4P list and Tito was their #1. I understand Jones being ranked higher than him but whatever Mosley did to be placed #1 I never understood.

I see alot of confusion on who was #1 when...Was Chavez #1 when he fought Sweet Pea?, was Toney #1 when he fought Jones. Guys THERE IS NO OFFICIAL P4P LIST. It is a mithical rating. P4P lists are entirely subjective. My point is that there is no such thing as "The reigning undisputed p4p number 1".

[amat]

Lloyd Honeyghan dominated Don Curry.

CC for that one, one of the more forgotten upsets in history.

[JonesJrMayweather]

Trinidad was considered by many the P4P king when he fought B-Hop. I know, I know, some people here will say that Jones Jr was always #1 until he lost. You know that old hind sight is 20/20 thing but the fact is that at that time Jones was being seriously criticized by his level of opposition and Tito's big run to the MW division had placed him #1 in many boxing fans P4P lists.....

And then he was dominated

tito was never number 1...he only beat joppy and that no way would have had him leap shane mosley who was still undefeated and ranked no 2...

The very day of the fight against B-Hop HBO posted their P4P list and Tito was their #1. I understand Jones being ranked higher than him but whatever Mosley did to be placed #1 I never understood.

I see alot of confusion on who was #1 when...Was Chavez #1 when he fought Sweet Pea?, was Toney #1 when he fought Jones. Guys THERE IS NO OFFICIAL P4P LIST. It is a mithical rating. P4P lists are entirely subjective. My point is that there is no such thing as "The reigning undisputed p4p number 1".

i know, but like now...marquez and pacman both have cases, but floyd would be the general no 1. and until he loses pacman and marquez will be 2 and 3..or even winky for that matter..who would be no in my book if he beat bhop..seeing as he was robbed against taylor

[ICB]

Ali beating Foreman

[ElTerribleMorales]

Buster Douglas beating Tyson ??

Thats a fair one

the only fight in which the rematch happens in the same 12 rnds lol, Tyson Ko's Douglas (the delayed count), and giving Douglas all the credit in the world, he got up after what should have been 10 and recollects himself and finishes beating up Tyson badly