Ice Colds's Look Back At Controversial Decisions Michael Spinks vs Larry Holmes

[The Rookie Fan]

Man, there were a lot of close rounds in that one. I'm gonna take one more look at it and actually wright down the scores (No pun intended).

I will say this. Vargas did a hell of a job on that fight. I was REALLY impressed.

[ICB]

Man, there were a lot of close rounds in that one. I'm gonna take one more look at it and actually wright down the scores (No pun intended).

I will say this. Vargas did a hell of a job on that fight. I was REALLY impressed.

Vargas best performance imo.

[ICB]

Bump wana get some new comments + scorecards from other members.

[Eli_jr24]

There are plenty that I could think of. This one was tough to score. I had it Vargas.

1. Trinidad v.s. DLH (i saw De La Hoya)
2. Mosley v.s. DLH II (saw DLH win)
3. Barrera v.s. Morales (saw Barrera win)
4. Barrera v.s. Morales II (saw Morales win)
5. Mayweather v.s. Castillo I (had Castillo up on scorecard)
6. Wright v.s. Taylor (had Wright winning that fight).
7. Whitaker v.s. De La Hoya (had Whitaker winning that one).
8. Quartey v.s. Forrest (Quartey wupped his a**)

plenty more!!!

I'll do a new one every week i want some more people to do there scorecards.

oh ok. my bad. Make sure you include these!

[Althugz]

Vargas was a great boxer/puncher make no mistake. Very smart and could adapt to his opponents style. I just always felt he couldn't maintain it down the stretch. He had a fantastic chance of scoring a huge upset comeback victory against Trinidad when they fought. His fight back from the 3 first round knock downs was inspiring especially for an undefeated 22 year old. He showed what he was made of to come back and actually take control of the match for a period. He did well against De La Hoya as well in the beginning but faded down the stretch again. I think he was done after the De La Hoya fight.

Another fight I would love people to score is the 2nd Nigel Benn vs Chris Eubank match. I saw that match when I was little and havn't seen it since. I don't think i've seen it anywhere on the internet either. Would love people to score that fight as it was an exact split down the middle. One vote for Eubank, one for Benn and the other even.

[Spicoli]

Vargas was a great boxer/puncher make no mistake. Very smart and could adapt to his opponents style. I just always felt he couldn't maintain it down the stretch. He had a fantastic chance of scoring a huge upset comeback victory against Trinidad when they fought. His fight back from the 3 first round knock downs was inspiring especially for an undefeated 22 year old. He showed what he was made of to come back and actually take control of the match for a period. He did well against De La Hoya as well in the beginning but faded down the stretch again. I think he was done after the De La Hoya fight.

Another fight I would love people to score is the 2nd Nigel Benn vs Chris Eubank match. I saw that match when I was little and havn't seen it since. I don't think i've seen it anywhere on the internet either. Would love people to score that fight as it was an exact split down the middle. One vote for Eubank, one for Benn and the other even.

I had benn up By 3 Points in The rematch.Could Have Done With Out That Nasty shaved Head But Benn actually Using a strong Jab and always Brutal Power was scary.Put Eubank On His arss To .like he said the draw was "rubish"

[ICB]

Vargas was a great boxer/puncher make no mistake. Very smart and could adapt to his opponents style. I just always felt he couldn't maintain it down the stretch. He had a fantastic chance of scoring a huge upset comeback victory against Trinidad when they fought. His fight back from the 3 first round knock downs was inspiring especially for an undefeated 22 year old. He showed what he was made of to come back and actually take control of the match for a period. He did well against De La Hoya as well in the beginning but faded down the stretch again. I think he was done after the De La Hoya fight.

Another fight I would love people to score is the 2nd Nigel Benn vs Chris Eubank match. I saw that match when I was little and havn't seen it since. I don't think i've seen it anywhere on the internet either. Would love people to score that fight as it was an exact split down the middle. One vote for Eubank, one for Benn and the other even.

I had benn up By 3 Points in The rematch.Could Have Done With Out That Nasty shaved Head But Benn actually Using a strong Jab and always Brutal Power was scary.Put Eubank On His arss To .like he said the draw was "rubish"

I had Benn up by 2 rounds but it wasn't good fight didn't live up to the hype Eubank had alot of gift decisions in his career.

[Julius Rain]

I want to know how you guys scored williams margarito.

[ICB]

I want to know how you guys scored williams margarito.

That fight wasn't controversial Williams clearly won.

[Spicoli]

I want to know how you guys scored williams margarito.

I Did Not Do A Sit Down Score,But Unfortuantly IThink Williams Was Up By About 2 or 3.And I Think He's Pretty Over Hyped Still,I Say He Gets Beaten Very Soon (clottey,Cintron,and Hopefully margarito In Rematch)

[Julius Rain]

I want to know how you guys scored williams margarito.

That fight wasn't controversial Williams clearly won.

well compare to the others, yes its not as controversial but I still want to know how others scored it. It was pretty close to me, but I gave the edge to williams becuase he did what all challengers should and thats take the belt fromt the champion, and margarito is a true champion.

It was a great classic fight for me, becuase for the first time in ages we had a great example of how a challenger vs a champion should really look like in boxing.

[Julius Rain]

I want to know how you guys scored williams margarito.

I Did Not Do A Sit Down Score,But Unfortuantly IThink Williams Was Up By About 2 or 3.And I Think He's Pretty Over Hyped Still,I Say He Gets Beaten Very Soon (clottey,Cintron,and Hopefully margarito In Rematch)

I dont' understand why you think williams is overhyped, his the only challenger that had actually took the belt from a champion in a very very physical battle. Williams could of settle down to cruise to a u.d but he continued until the final bell to give it all he had.

[Spicoli]

I want to know how you guys scored williams margarito.

I Did Not Do A Sit Down Score,But Unfortuantly IThink Williams Was Up By About 2 or 3.And I Think He's Pretty Over Hyped Still,I Say He Gets Beaten Very Soon (clottey,Cintron,and Hopefully margarito In Rematch)

I dont' understand why you think williams is overhyped, his the only challenger that had actually took the belt from a champion in a very very physical battle. Williams could of settle down to cruise to a u.d but he continued until the final bell to give it all he had.

He Did Just That,And I am ABig Margarito Fan,Williams won.But thats My Point,Maybe It Was 1St Big Fight Jitters But He Has T Settle Down And Utilize That Height And Long Power .And For God sakes That Head Cant Be Any higher up at times.He Just Seems a little Unfocused and reading His Own Headlines.He's taken a big step to respect but he has to fight smarter or he WILL be KO'D.

[THE THIRD MAN]

Good thing i kept my scorecard book!

Whitaker V Chavez 117-111 Whitaker

DLH V Quartey 115-113 DLH

DLH V Trinidad 117-111 DLH

Lewis V Holyfield 1 116-112 Lewis

Lewis V Holyfield 2 117-111 Holyfield

Mosley V DLH 1 115-113 Mosley

Mosley V DLH 2 115-113 DLH

Whitaker V DLH 115-113 DLH

Mayweather V Castillo 1 115-113 Castillo

Fenech V Nelson 1 116-112 Fenech

Vargas V Wright 115-113 Vargas

Wright V Taylor 116-112 Wright

Couldn't find Barerra V Morales.

[ICB]

Good thing i kept my scorecard book!

Whitaker V Chavez 117-111 Whitaker

DLH V Quartey 115-113 DLH

DLH V Trinidad 117-111 DLH

Lewis V Holyfield 1 116-112 Lewis

Lewis V Holyfield 2 117-111 Holyfield

Mosley V DLH 1 115-113 Mosley

Mosley V DLH 2 115-113 DLH

Whitaker V DLH 115-113 DLH

Mayweather V Castillo 1 115-113 Castillo

Fenech V Nelson 1 116-112 Fenech

Vargas V Wright 115-113 Vargas

Wright V Taylor 116-112 Wright

Couldn't find Barerra V Morales.

You had Vargas winning aswell why did people say Wright got robbed is beyond me.