Nice thread. The names that come to mind are:
Zab Judah-spoilt B******. Gets title shots after title shots.Loses,takes a warm up,gets another title shot. Nearly all his title shots at 147 were undeserved and he does not deserve any for a long time.
Rocky Juarez- same as Judah. Almost as delusional. Got his a** handed to him by Humberto Soto. Soto STILL has not had a shot. Juarez got a shot at a horrible version of MAB and still lost(most had MAB by 2,myself included). Then he gets an undeserved rematch,loses every round getting his ears boxed off and then says MAB ran>

The he looks lackluster,and,lo,behold,gets another title shot v JMM.
Bernard hopkins- a wonderful fighter,incredible work ethic but lucky in the sense that when he was 160 champ there were not that many big challenges around,so when you look at his title defences,you think is ram packed filled with good/great opponents.It's not. Careful match making or genuine lack of opponents? I don't know.
I'll think of more later. I think you should add unlucky to the thread title too,makes it more interesting.
Bookmarks