If Calzaghe Won Why????

[ICB]

HBO is the most biased of ALL commentary teams

Didn't they have Castillo winning the 1st Mayweather fight by 115-111 ?? what a joke.

Castillo did win the fight...and you must be kidding me about reid..

You missed the point completely i had Castillo winning by 1 point but it was very close fight that could of gone either way so you agree with that 115-111 scoring ??

As for Reid no im not kidding why would i be ?? that was highly controversial fight and many people thought Calzaghe lost that fight, seeing how you use punch stats for Hopkins vs Calzaghe why don't you pull out punch stats for Reid vs Calzaghe, they both landed exactly same amount of punches, the difference is Reid had a higher percentage of punches landed, and he also landed the much harder shots, he rocked Calzaghe many times with right hand leads.

[bikersk]

Yep he was. Much to bernards chagrin.

[Gandalf]

Hopkins was worked out and has never been as outworked as that down the stretch. Calzaghe won convincingly, I still think that he could have dominated old Hopkins something rotten if it hadnt had been for that flash knockdown.

If Hopkins is really so upset then he should demand a rematch. I doubt he wants any part of JC again though.

[JLAQ]

Why did setanta have him needing a KO really enough said Calzaghe should be 44-1 we know it he knows it the whole world knows it.

It would've been a schooling had Cortez prevented Hopkins from headbutting, lowblowing, holding, rabbit-punching, and resting from a punch that was called a low blow. It would've been Calzaghe 120-108 or Calzaghe KO9 Hopkins. The referee just sucked big time.

[Gandalf]

Why did setanta have him needing a KO really enough said Calzaghe should be 44-1 we know it he knows it the whole world knows it.

It would've been a schooling had Cortez prevented Hopkins from headbutting, lowblowing, holding, rabbit-punching, and resting from a punch that was called a low blow. It would've been Calzaghe 120-108 or Calzaghe KO9 Hopkins. The referee just sucked big time.

Cortez was awful again. Hopkins had him around his little finger. There should be stronger actions against fighters who hold excessively. The low blow thing was absurd. Hopkins should have been forced to fight. Pathetic.

[JLAQ]

Cortez is the worst referee of all time, along with Nady.

[bambamdaddio]

Calzaghe won because:-

He outlanded Hopkins comprehensively.
He outworked him and had him looking very ragged down the stretch.
He came forward and made the fight.
Hopkins was so tired he resorted to questionable tactics to get himself a break.


Aside from the first third, Calzaghe really was in control IMO.

Hopkins should be sponsored by Reebok with the amount of running he does.

Brilliantly honest and true post, may I add that along with Reebok, they may get Lonsdale on board too, as he really should wear a third boxing glove on his head ...

Joe won clear, even allowing for the knockdown, I had him 3 rounds in front even tho it was messy at times,

But in honesty Flopkins was not interested in fighting the fight, just thieving and being dodgy, are crap tactics at this level, and I really expected more from B.Flop,

I'll even go further by adding Flopkins even robbed Joe of a spectacular win by use of his dodgy tactics, eg sneaking rests on pretense of serious foul,

I'm not disagreeing with the foul, but he milked it that much I thought they was gonna hang a cow bell around his neck and start calling him Daisy,

Also the butting, the holding, the just being a pain in the ass who would not get involved in fighting at all unless he got lucky throwing his single random shots.....poor indeed.

[LondonBB]

I give hopkins credit for his fighting ability.

I was worried when calzaghe went down, it was on his nose and not chin and he got up immeadiately but it was a great test for joe.

Hopkins showed that he is a great counter puncher with probably his best performance in a long time.

However the dirtyness from hopkins was a joke, the claiming of low blows was pathetic when everyone saw it wasnt a low blow. The use of the head was pathetic, immense clinching made for an ugly fight...he really did try everything in the book (or, not allowed in the book, to win). I didnt like this aspect of it AT ALL!

However as a true champ, calzaghes class came through at the end, bar the 9th, the last 6 rounds were all calzaghe, hopkins only took the 9th because of the rest he forced (by cheating) when it clearly was not a low blow.

I dont like cortez' referring though, it was too leanient towards hopkins who constantly broke the rules by use of the head. BUT I MUST SAY that i have respect for cortez in that he saw that hopkins was cheating and did not deduct a point for the 'pretend low blow'.

All in all on my scorecard it was as follows.

1. hop 10,8
2. hop
3. hop
4. calz
5. calz
6. calz
7. draw
8. calz
9. hop
10. calz
11. calz
12. calz

Giving the overall decission to calzaghe by 115, 113

The judges decissions were all over the place, only 1 got it right i thought, 115, 113 to calzaghe.

Dont know how the others gave it 114,113 bhop and 116,11 calzaghe.

In summary calzaghe showed his champ ability to work out hopkins (something very very difficult to do), he went down in first round from some great boxing by bernard but claz forced his way back into the fight by workrate and managing to plant the most punches on bhop that anyone has ever done before.

Of course there will be doubters but any legitimate boxing fan knows that calzaghe is the real deal, he got knocked down in the first only to come back and start dicatating against the great hopkins.

Respect to both fighters, but the champ won on the day. It was in the later rounds where i knew bhop was gone because calzaghe rocked him with a good combo, i thought bhop was gonna go down if joe hit him a few more times, probably stay down, but bhop managed to clinch (suprise suprise lol)...it was clear that whilst his philly style and defense/counter was top class, joe started dicatating the fight and adaopted later on to bring his game in, hopkins trid every dirty trick but calzaghe was just too good for him.

Calzaghe to fight jones next and beat him (either in millenium stadium, madison square or vegas), then in his final fight beat pavlik (in vegas) and then retire totally unbeaten 47, 0 A true cut above the rest

[bambamdaddio]

Why did setanta have him needing a KO really enough said Calzaghe should be 44-1 we know it he knows it the whole world knows it.

It would've been a schooling had Cortez prevented Hopkins from headbutting, lowblowing, holding, rabbit-punching, and resting from a punch that was called a low blow. It would've been Calzaghe 120-108 or Calzaghe KO9 Hopkins. The referee just sucked big time.

Cortez was awful again. Hopkins had him around his little finger. There should be stronger actions against fighters who hold excessively. The low blow thing was absurd. Hopkins should have been forced to fight. Pathetic.

Well said, not forgetting B.Flop should in future be made to wear a boxing glove on his head, as he throws a lovely straight skull into your face, as good as any Ive seen.