Did Joe just take away the p4p throne from Manny?

[SweetPea]

Before last night, I had Calzaghe 4th PFP, behind Floyd, Pac and JMM. Maybe I'd move him up to 3rd now, but no higher than that.

[TitoFan]

Discuss.

You're fairly new to this boxing stuff, now aren't you...

[getupkid2004]

I didn't think B-Hop got the bejeesus his face looked a little better after the fight... yea he won but p4p number 1? no

[GodofBoxing]

Oh dear the same crap as always...if he won then the other guy was too old.....same old same old

[Taeth]

P4P Floyd would destroy Joe... Mayweather besides power does everything this version of B-Hop does, but better, and a lot faster. Joe wouldn't be able to keep up with PBF, and he wouldn't be able to land a thing against Mayweather. Joe is a great fighter, but speed would destroy him... Roy Jones Jr. in his prime also would have dismantled Calzaghe badly.

[piye]

I'd put Calzhage third behind Mayweather and Manny.

[XaduBoxer]

Nope... Joe's performance not enough to take the throne away from "Manny Mayweather" ...

[Puya]

Good bye B-Hop no more I have to hear form you BYEEEE!!!
http://a669.ac-images.myspacecdn.com...5bc7041f4c.gif

[Pugilistic]

JLAQ

as for joe taking away the number two spot from pacquaio ............HELL NO !!!!!

[sonny78]

I have PBF still no 1, but if he fights De la hoya and continues wrestling and dancing then he shoud be classed as retired and fighting exhibitions, therefore moved out of the rankings

1.PBF
2.Pac
3.JC

This is how it stood at the start of the year and after Manny scrapped a win past JMM and JC scrapped a win past BHop all stays the same

I dont see any argument in this at all

[donnydarkoIRL]

Pound for pound list are highly subjective and vary from individual to individual, often varying because of geographical location, individual tatstes and objective analysis of recent performances.
This means that each fan will have their own pound for pound list, that others may agree and disagree on. So it's up to you where you place Joe on your list.

[brucelee]

PAcquaio could well be placed in the top spot but it would create endless debates here. So to keep the peace between my brothers in this forum, I'll concede that Pac is number 2 right now. In case PBF will not be impressive against ODLH, I will put PBF in the second spot eventhough he wins again.

[ICB]

PAcquaio could well be placed in the top spot but it would create endless debates here. So to keep the peace between my brothers in this forum, I'll concede that Pac is number 2 right now. In case PBF will not be impressive against ODLH, I will put PBF in the second spot eventhough he wins again.

Pacquiao probably has the best 3 wins than anything on Mayweather's resume Morales x2, Barrera x2, Marquez, etc. But like i said before other than those wins Mayweather overall has beat much more quality opponents than Pacquiao, plus he has more achievements and P4P Mayweather would beat Pacquiao as well. Thats why i feel Mayweather should be rated higher than Pacquiao.

[JLAQ]

PAcquaio could well be placed in the top spot but it would create endless debates here. So to keep the peace between my brothers in this forum, I'll concede that Pac is number 2 right now. In case PBF will not be impressive against ODLH, I will put PBF in the second spot eventhough he wins again.

Pacquiao probably has the best 3 wins than anything on Mayweather's resume Morales x2, Barrera x2, Marquez, etc. But like i said before other than those wins Mayweather overall has beat much more quality opponents than Pacquiao, plus he has more achievements and P4P Mayweather would beat Pacquiao as well. Thats why i feel Mayweather should be rated higher than Pacquiao.

LOL are you crazy? MAB is a million times better than Corley, Morales is a billion times better than Bruseles, and Marquez is a trillion times better than Baldomir. And Pac fought these HOFers 8 frigging times, and KDd them 12 frigging times. Did Floyd even KD anyone of the turds Corley, Bruseles or even Baldomir? NO. Clearly Pac's resume is a MILLION times better than Floyd's. PLEASE.

[ICB]

PAcquaio could well be placed in the top spot but it would create endless debates here. So to keep the peace between my brothers in this forum, I'll concede that Pac is number 2 right now. In case PBF will not be impressive against ODLH, I will put PBF in the second spot eventhough he wins again.

Pacquiao probably has the best 3 wins than anything on Mayweather's resume Morales x2, Barrera x2, Marquez, etc. But like i said before other than those wins Mayweather overall has beat much more quality opponents than Pacquiao, plus he has more achievements and P4P Mayweather would beat Pacquiao as well. Thats why i feel Mayweather should be rated higher than Pacquiao.

LOL are you crazy? MAB is a million times better than Corley, Morales is a billion times better than Bruseles, and Marquez is a trillion times better than Baldomir. And Pac fought these HOFers 8 frigging times, and KDd them 12 frigging times. Did Floyd even KD anyone of the turds Corley, Bruseles or even Baldomir? NO. Clearly Pac's resume is a MILLION times better than Floyd's. PLEASE.

NO ARE YOU CRAZY OR DO YOU JUST NEED GLASSES ?? READ WHAT I SAID MORON I SAID MORALES, MARQUEZ, BARRERA, ARE BETTER WINS THAN ANYTHING ON MAYWEATHER'S RESUME. BUT MAYWEATHER OVERALL HAS GOT MORE QUALITY WINS AND ALL YOU DONE IS COMPARED MAYWEATHER'S WORST OPPONENTS AGAINST PACQUIAO'S BEST OPPONENTS THATS STUPID COMPARISON AND I COULD FLIP THE COIN AND DO THAT WITH PACQUIAO AS WELL. LET ME PUT IT IN SIMPLE TERMS SO EVEN A MORON LIKE YOU CAN UNDERSTAND OK ??

MAYWEATHER'S BEST WINS.

ZAB JUDAH
ARTURO GATTI
GERNARO HERNANDEZ
OSCAR DE LA HOYA
RICKY HATTON
CARLOS HERNANDEZ
DIEGO CORRALES
ANGEL MANFREDY
JESUS CHAVEZ
PHILLIP NDOU
JOSE LUIS CASTILLO X2

MANNY PACQUIAO'S BEST WINS

ERIK MORALES X2
MARCO ANTONIO BARRERA X2
JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
OSCAR LARIOS
JORGE SOLIS

NOW DO YOU GET MY POINT ?? MAYWEATHER OVERALL HAS MORE QUALITY WINS THAN PACQUIAO, THATS WHY WHEN YOU ARE RANKING FIGHTER P4P YOU LOOK AT HIS WHOLE CAREER AND NOT JUST SINGLE WINS, MAYWEATHER HAS GOT MORE ACHIEVEMENTS THAN PACQUIAO WINNING 5 WORLD TITLES IN 5 DIFFERENT WEIGHT CLASSES, HE WOULD BEAT PACQUIAO P4P, PLUS HE HAS MORE QUALITY WINS THAN PACQUIAO THATS WHY HE IS RATED HIGHER P4P IS THAT SIMPLE ENOUGH FOR YOU ?? AND PLEASE DO NOT USE THAT ARGUMENT THAT SOME OF MAYWEATHER'S OPPONENTS WERE PAST THERE PRIME, BECAUSE BOTH BARRERA AND MORALES WERE BOTH PAST THERE PRIME WHEN PACQUIAO BEAT THEM AS WELL.