You can't seriously compare Reagan to those Presidents. What did he do that was ever remotely comparable?
Perception is not reality. At one point following 9/11, Bush had the highest approval rating of any President ever, and for years afterwards his rating remained high. That does not make him a great President. Reagan might have been the best President from 1980-1988, but that's about it. He's not even the best President in the last 30 years.
Bookmarks